Penal Substitution Debate

<< Back Home


Because my blog (where the debate essays are posted) is getting kind of cluttered, I have decided to make a page listing the individual essays.

NOTE: This turned out to be a LONG debate, so if you are Catholic and want the 'essentials' of the Catholic position, I suggest you at least read the essays marked with '*'.

Debate Announcement & Format

Affirmative Constructive Essay

* Negative Constructive Essay

Affirmative Rebuttal

* Negative Rebuttal

Affirmative Questions to the Negative

Negative Answers to Affirmative Questions

Negative Questions to the Affirmative

Affirmative Answers to Negative Questions

* Negative Concluding Essay

Affirmative Concluding Essay

-- Post Debate Comments/Questions --