1974 Omega Marine Chronometer Wristwatch
News release from Omega dated : December 1974
From :
SSIH (UK) Ltd
67 - 74 Saffron Hill
London
EC1N 8RS
NEWS RELEASE
World's most accurate watch accepted by Science Museum.
Omega are proud to announce that the Science Museum in London has accepted a new electronic wrist watch with a guaranteed accuracy to within one second a month for permanent
display in the time measurement gallery. With its unprecedented accuracy of a second a month the new model called the Marine Chronometer, the World's most accurate and technically
advanced wristwatch. Its accuracy is achieved by a tiny wafer thin lenticular quartz crystal vibrating at the incredible rate of 2359296 times a second when stimulated by the current by its
Aspirin sized battery. The other main component of this new time piece is an integrated circuit containing several hundred micro-miniaturized elements on a surface area of four square
millimeters. The special feature of the watch is a device for setting the hour and second hands independently without effecting its accurate timekeeping, an important advantage for members of the jet-setting flying from one time zone to another. Before the new Marine Chronometer watches were released for sale, each and every one was sent by Omega for intensive an rigorous testing at the Bescanon Observatory in France. Each watch is awarded its own individual certificate by this independent authority confirming its performance and time keeping under various conditions.
The new Marine Chronometer is resistant to water, shock, magnetic fields, humidity, dust and temperature changes. It has a stainless steel case and bracelet, and sells for £680. A limited
supply of the model is now available for sale in the U.K.
For further information contact Gary Priest, Public Relations Manager, SSIH U.K. Limited 67-74 Saffron Hill, London EC1N 8RS.
Date December 1974
Stockist names and address supplied on request.
---------------
The Science Museum in London has had an example of the Marine Chronometer on public display since 1974. Arrangements can be made with the curator of timekeeping to view the documentation that they have about the exhibit.
In addition to the exhibit itself, their Omega folder contains:
A glossy brochure about the Megaquartz range of watches
An Omega Q.A. card for their watch - see reproduction.
A press release about the watch being on permanent display at the S.M. Copies of a press release on the workings of the watch, this is reproduced here. A couple of letters concerning the repair of a section of the exhibit (dated 1983) An Omega press release concerning temperature effects on rate.
The following is taken from the glossy Omega Megaquartz brochure, that included the Marine Chronometer.
The twenty or so page brochure was in A4 landscape format, with a plain white very glossy cover embossed with the word 'Megagqartz'. (This Science Museum version was rather worse for wear, having got damp at some time - parts of the pages had become stuck together.)
It showed a range of perhaps four of five different versions of the Megaquartz 2400 series, some in Gold or Steel with bracelets or leather straps. The Marine Chronometer was at the front of the brochure, and seemed to be very much the 'flagship' model.
The flowery 'blurb' was written on a smaller booklet which was interleaved within the big double page images of the various watches. (One double page was an image of the enlarged I.C. substrate.)
I did not bother with all the platitudes, though did note the following:
' A milestone in watch making history, you will find that the Omega Megaquartz 2'400 is more than a superb timepiece it is the most advanced electronic wrist watch in the World, in fact and in a word, it is unique. To confirm its outstanding accuracy and reliability, Omega sent two production line models of the Megaquartz 2'400 (one of which is illustrated here [3437165]) to the Nuchatel Observatory in Switzerland for 63 days testing. There they were submitted to the rigorous tests demanded for a marine chronometer. They passed them with ease in fact they were found to have an average variation of not more than plus or minus 0.002 and plus or minus 0.003 second a day respectively. An astonishing result considering that the standard demanded for a marine chronometer is plus or minus 0.17 second. So these Megaquartz 2'400 models became the first wrist watches ever
to be officially certified as marine chronometers. A World premier and at the same time, and eloquent proof that every Megaquartz 2'400 has the potential to merit the marine chronometer certificate.
Behind this singular achievement are over 125 years of pace setting leadership. As the Megaquartz 2'400 clearly shows, Omega are staying in the forefront of watch making development in this electronic era.
... The circuit, comprising several hundred transistors on a surface of only 4 square millimeters may
be compared to the approximate size of a match head. ...
Another important component is the revolutionary electromagnetic motor, which receives one impulse
per second from the integrated circuit and in tern activates the hands of the watch.'
My comments:
The first watch called 'Omega Megaquartz' came to market in around 1974 and consisted of about half a dozen different versions. They all worked at 2.4 MHz and were of similar rectangular form with similar movements. The most expensive non-precious metal version was labeled 'Marine Chronometer', and these all had a 14K Gold 'picture frame' surrounding a black painted sapphire glass. An engraved 14K serial number plate was let into the front lower facet of the stainless steel case. In 1976 the movement in the Marine Chronometer was changed from CAL1511 to CAL1516 (probably resulting from improvements to the IC and deletion of the analog dividing transformer first stage), though the case and bracelet remained the same.
Just two production samples of Marine Chronometer watch movements (probably 1511 caliber) were put through the 'full' 'Marine Chronometer' trials at the Neuchatel Observatory. My impression is that these tests were rather more stringent than for older mechanical chronometers, though Landies remarks that by
this time the Annual Chronometer Competitions had in fact been suspended (in 1968). So I am a little uncertian as to exactly what tests the Omegas were actually subjected to at Neuchatel, but they apparently passed.
The normal production movements type 1511 and later 1516 movements did not undergo chronometer testing at Neuchatel, but were certificated as 'Marine Chronometers' by the Besancon Observatory in France. Thus Omega 'Marine Chronometer' watches only had the potential to be such instruments, but
were not actually certified by the Neuchatel Observatory.
One assumes that Nuchatel would not be able to cope with the certification of hundreds or even thousands of wrist watches (I recall that Kew in London had ceased chronometer testing by 1972).
Though Besancon was of course already geared up to provide (and still does) 'chronometer' certificates on a mass scale. Indeed if there had been a continuing need for professional high grade chronometers, the various trials and competitions would not have gradually died out.
The following text is a slightly revised transcript of Omega
'Folder 0 - 1510, which seems to be a slightly more in-depth
description of the workings of the Omega Marine Chronometer.
The line drawings are photographs of the originals.
This document was probably part of a press release.
OMEGA Folder 0 -1510
Description and performances
The quartz watch, Megaquartz 2400 is the first watch whose
oscillator is equipped with a high frequency quartz (2.4 million
oscillations per second = 2.4 Mhz).
This ensures great accuracy - less than one second variation per
month. The watch is fitted with a calendar, a pusher for
correcting the second, as well as a rapid hour corrector which
enables it to be adapted to the time zone without loss of
accuracy in minute and second.
1. Description of Quartz crystal
The high frequency (HF) quartz gives better results than other
types of quartz in all respects : shock resistance, low
temperature coefficient, slow aging. Both surfaces of the
lenticular shaped crystal are metalized so as to permit electrical
contact. Vibrations is of the shearing type : the upper part of the
crystal moves in opposite direction to the lower part. Thus,
there is no vibration in the neutral area
and the quartz disk can therefore be fixed securely and with
great shock resistance.
The influence of temperature on performance is shown by a
shallow S shaped graph whose trace crosses the Y axis on or
around the 28 degree Centigrade point. One may conclude that it
is a straight line between + 10 and + 50 degree C. By
judicious cutting of the crystal, the inclination of this straight
line may be altered in order to obtain a thermal coefficient
approaching 0 around 28 deg. C. The watch will be adjusted to
a zero rate at the average temperature of wear (28 deg. C).
Any variation around this temperature will thus incur a slight
loss or gain.
(Indeed, Omega were later forced to issue a press release to
clearly make the point that while the watch will give less than
one second a month rates, to do this it must be worn on the
wrist. Perhaps in display cases and shop windows, < 1 sec /
month rates were embarrassingly not being observed.)
2. Description of electronics
The quartz resonator (1) is maintained at its resonant frequency
(2, 359,296 Hz) by the oscillator driver circuit (2).
The trimmer (3) allows adjustment of the quartz oscillator
within approximate limits of +- 2 secs. per day. This frequency
of approximately 2.4 Mhz is then divided by 6 by the analogue
divider (4) which comprises a transformer (5), namely to
393,216 Hz.
(On the drawing this section has been struck through and the
comment 'not now used' added. One assumes that in production
[1510 / 1516 movements ?] frequency division was done
completely digitally by a revised chip.)
18 logical division stages (6) (17 dividers by 2 and 1 divider
by 3) lower the frequency to 1 Hz. The energy is supplied by the
power cell (10). After setting-up, the control circuit (7) feeds
the motor (8) each second with an impulse lasting 6 ms.
The motor, of the electro-dynamic type, converts
the electrical data into mechanical data for the time
display module (9).
2. Description of movement
The watch consists of 3 modules :
1. The electronic module comprising the quartz
resonator with its trimmer, the integrated circuit,
the transformer, the connecting point with the
motor, the phasing contacts for the second and for
correction of the second.
2. [Sadly this section is missed from the copies in the Science
Museum, but seems to refer to the electro-dynamic motor
module.]
3. The time display module comprising the reduction wheel-
train, the date and the hour corrector.
Electronic Module
This miniature printed circuit (6) forms the support of the
module. It is fixed to the plate by 3 screws (2) one of which
ensures electrical contact on the plate.
The module consists of the following :
- The quartz (3) and the trimmer (4) constituting the time base.
- The transformer (5) serving for a first analogue division.
- The integrated circuit (1) which comprises :
- the quartz driving circuitry EQ
- one analogue division stage DA
- one logical division stage DL
[Also on the electronics module are : ]
- the circuit forming the appropriate impulse for the motor CM
- two capacitors
- the power cell contact blade (8) that connects directly to the
module.
(Sadly three further pages are missing from the copies held at
the Science Museum, but they do have page 8 : )
4. Technical data and performance of caliber 1510
Dimensions :31 x 25.6 x 6 mm
Frequency of resonator :2.359.296 Hz
Quality factor :> 250.000
Thermal Coefficient :< 0.025 s/d/ deg. C
(between 0 and 60 deg. C)
Isochronism :< 0.04 s/d/ 100 mV
Consumption :max. 13uA
Running time : 15 months
Variations during wear :< 1sec / month
The Marine Chronometer watch of 1974 was arguably Omega's finest achievement in terms of precision wrist time keeping, but was at the same time part of a closing chapter in the art of
mechanical chronometry. While a significant artifact of the Quartz Revolution, it was also the first wristwatch to gain from the Neuchatel Observatory certification as a (proper) marine
chronometer. Indeed, at that time the observatory seemed to have tightened up the performance requirements for chronometers in line with the new technology of Quartz, and required levels of precision rather better than the few tenths of a second variation per day expected from doing things the old way. Ironically though, while near perfection of timekeeping had at last been achieved with the wristwatch, the practical worth of such self-contained precision had by then in fact become rather moot.
Since early in the Twentieth Century radio time signals had largely removed the need for the classical marine chronometer to be needed as a primary navigational instrument and later
technologies in the form of LORAN, Decca, Omega (no connection) and satellite based global positioning systems such as TRANSIT and NAVSTAR, would provide self-contained and highly portable navigational equipment capable of unimagined levels of precision.
So the real days of finding one's position by sextant and clockwork were over. And the mechanical marine chronometer; that precious and revered instrument of detent escapement,
helical compensated balance and fusee, on which the lives of countless sailors and aviators once depended were a fast fading memory when Omega's little electronic masterpiece came into being.
For a short while the Second World War generated a new need for chronometers of all types, and during that desperate period the last significant advances in mechanical chronometry were to be made by Hamilton in the United States. But once hostilities had ceased the reliable resumption of radio navigation signals rendered even the superb Hamilton models 21 and 22 obsolete and unwanted.
Wristwatch 'chronometers' would of course continue to be sold. But these somewhat ironic items were actually to do with capturing the imagination and cash of those with large disposable incomes, and had little to do with advancing the art of precision chronometry. The reality was that the arrival of the quartz epoch had made professional chronometer trials even more irrelevant. No longer would the military need carefully graded mechanical timekeepers, no longer would specialist manufactures vie with each other in the race to perfection, as it had become quite apparent that almost any reasonable quartz watch would be perfectly good enough to navigate by. The Swiss suspended their chronometer competitions in 1968 (to save the embarrassment of cheap quartz watches 'demolishing' their expensive clockwork), the trials were never revived and
Kew stopped theirs in 1974. But the 'designer' watch industry still required quantities of 'chronometer' certificates to help sell its costly offerings. So to meet this somewhat different need machines were devised to rate and print out 'chronometer' certificates automatically and by the million. Levels of scrutineering were revised downwards to reflect the modest capabilities of the mass-produced mechanical movements submitted for trial. And thus the modern 'chronometer'
became a rather spurious concept far more to do with marketing than precision time keeping.
In addition (as if almost to add insult to injury), serious chronometry marine or otherwise had in fact long since severed its links with the watchmaking business and had made a complete departure from things mechanical. It is now to be found within the 'physics packages' of costly scientific instruments.
Quite where this leaves Omega's 'Marine Chronometer' of 1974 remains to be seen. Despite the decline of the quartz watch generally as an object of desire and being out of production for over a quarter of a century, it remains an interesting horological item and is worth some study perhaps. Its movement caliber was known by Omega during development as the 'Elephant', and it was quite an elephant of technological achievement back then. And who knows? perhaps some were
even used to navigate by.
In early 2002 I became sufficiently interested (and affluent) to acquire an example of my own. And having done some research on the beast a small web presence seemed to be appropriate,
particularly as there was such scant information available on the net (with of course the exception of Mr. Schone's interesting and authoritative web page).
While putting together this fairly rambling account I found myself including quite a bit of the background to quartz watches in general, and so it therefore seems appropriate to begin by just setting the scene:
In the late nineteen fifties it was becoming increasingly apparent that the on-going advances in technology as brought about by the space (which was in reality the arms) race might eventually allow the considerable amount of electronics required for a quartz clock to be miniaturized sufficiently enough to fit inside the case of a wrist watch. Large quartz clocks using vacuum tubes had been developed in the nineteen twenties and had already replaced high precision pendulum clocks as standard time references. These were themselves then in the process of being replaced by Cesium beam 'atomic' time standards. The transistor whose working parts were perhaps a thousand times smaller than those of the miniature vacuum tube that it replaced, was about to be introduced to the wrist watch in the form of the Bulova Accutron. Miniature
Mercury power cells that were most likely developed for a mixture of military and domestic hearing aid use, had for some time provided a reliable power source for various hybrid electro-mechanical watches. The development of the monolithic integrated circuit during the mid 1960's
would provide the complex low-power 'nano' electronics needed for a practical quartz wristwatch, and various technical spin-off's from semiconductor manufacture itself would bring
new and highly cost effective ways of fabricating sub-miniature comparatively low frequency 32kHz quartz crystals. And so within this emerging and successful environment of what might be thought of as general technological positivism, remarkable implications for the future of wrist watches (and of course most everything else) were being drawn by those people with sufficient imagination. Indeed a viable quartz watch was definitely on the horizon by 1969, and Seiko's Astron was of course by a very narrow margin the first example to arrive. But while the Seiko watch was the first, a number of worthy competitors were well on their way as well.
The conservative Swiss watch industry did just realize that this new and very alien technology might be a threat to the bastions of their mechanical supremacy. And as they had done with the
American development of component interchangeability in the past, they decided to study and evaluate these new developments. By 1960 the Swiss had already formed a cooperative research laboratory based at Neuchatel. This became known as the Centre Electronique Horloger, and was a consortium of some 20 organizations all with the intention of eventually producing various types of electronic and quartz watches. At the time it is likely they had no idea of how important a move this was to be in the face of the impending but completely unsuspected technological storm that was soon to arrive. Indeed some thought the 'new fangled' electronic watch was just a mere technical novelty and a passing fad. However, after five or so years of what looks like a period of rather sedate development work, the first prototype Swiss
quartz movement was exhibited at the 1967 Basel watch fair. Known as the Beta 21, this home grown effort was brought to market in April 1970 and would eventually be offered for sale by some 16 'manufacturers', including Omega. C.E.H. would supply the integrated circuit (probably using bipolar technology), Ebauches S.A. manufactured the plates, gear train, motion work and the quartz resonator, while Omega produced the vibrating electromagnetic micromotor. According to the Smithsonian Institute: 'The watches were assembled by three
separate shops that produced the final products according to the design requests of the Swiss watch companies that placed orders'.
Just after Seiko introduced their rather premature and ill-fated Astron quartz watch on Christmas day 1969, things were moving sufficiently rapidly for Richard Good to write in the in
the Horological Journal that 1970 was the 'Year of the Quartz Crystal Watch', and proceeded to describe the Seiko as well as watches with the Beta 21 movement and other offerings by
Longines, Bulova and Girard Perregaux. Interestingly, Mr. Good writing in the UK had not actually seen any of these exotic watches in person and was just relating third party reports and
promotional literature. Indeed I suspect that many of these new electronic marvels only existed as prototypes or mock-ups, and I recall images of the very unlikely interior of an early
Perregaux. (Though later they did produce production watches with electronics by Thompson CSF.) While Bulova initially employed a modified quartz governed Accutron tuning fork
movement, the Longines's 'Ultra Quartz' seemed to have been a remarkable combination of micro-engineering and miniature knife and fork electronics. This looks to have been an absolute
nightmare to manufacture and to service. It used an 8,500 Hz quartz crystal to drive a tiny vibrating magnetic arm by means of a discretely wired 'cybernetic circuit'. I am not sure exactly
how this movement functioned, but it used a lot of very small discrete (that is separate and individual) electronic components probably sourced from the hearing aid industry. The
electromagnetic motor was a torsion-wire suspended arm that resonated at 170 Hz (which is one 50th of 8,500 Hz).
The seemingly rather more developed Beta 21 movement as used by Omega et all, employed a combination of low frequency bar form 8,192 Hz quartz crystal and a single integrated circuit giving an output pulse rate of 256 Hz (which was 8,192 Hz divided by 32). This drove an Omega manufactured electromagnetic vibrating 'motor'. This beautifully made component consisted of a pair of laminated core electromagnets which were connected to the electronics
by a flexible printed circuit. These electromagnets acted upon a tiny horizontal 'pendulum' that had an adjusting screw to bring it to a resonance of 256 Hz. This 'pendulum's' oscillations drove the hands by means of a tiny ratchet and index wheel rather similar to those used in the original Bulova Accutron and possibly sourced from the same supplier. Therefore the Beta 21's hands also moved smoothly around the dial. The movement was quite modular in concept, with electronic timebase package, motor, and motion work all being separate de-mountable sub-assemblies. Mr. Good commented that the integrated circuit used in the Beta 21 contained the
equivalent circuitry of five transistor radios. This was high technology 35 years ago and might equate to perhaps some thirty transistors and a hundred or so other passive electronic
components. Some 14,000 of these movements were manufactured.
The Beta 21 was a cornerstone of the first generation of quartz watches, all of which show aspects of heroic engineering that is common in the early days of any newly emerging
technology. (That is, before the manufacturers learn how to throw out half the components and make the rest out of plastic!) All these watches were exotic, rare and very expensive, and a very far cry from what the quartz watch was to rapidly evolve into. Many were also short-lived joint ventures between old established Swiss firms and young aggressive American
semiconductor manufacturers anxiously looking for mass market applications for their emerging technology, having won the arms race for the US military.
It must have been towards the later stages of development of the Beta 21 that Omega got together with the rather well respected Battelle Geneva Research Institute (still extant). This
resulted in the what was to prove a unique series of high frequency quartz watch movements; the calibers 1510, 1511, 1515 and 1516, which are only to be found in the Omega 'Megaquartz 2400' and Omega 'Marine Chronometer' series of watches.
While first exhibited with the prototype 1500 movement at Basel in 1970 (though oddly not mentioned by Good at the time), volume production of Omega's Megaquartz 2400 did not start until some three or four years later. This seems to have been a remarkably long time, though as Hamilton demonstrated with their Pulsar, it is one thing to build a few hand made prototypes and quite another to gear up to build many thousands economically. But this was a significant
delay, and in the then far from tranquil world of watchmaking things were already moving very rapidly. Consequently these models were to have a rather short life span of only four years,
with production ending in 1978.
As with the Beta 21, the CAL1500 series of movements were of rectangular form, used a single 1.5 Volt type 344 Mercury power cell, and demonstrated technology that was both state-of-the-art and that also perhaps harked back to slightly earlier times. Again of modular construction, with separate and de-mountable electronics package, motor and motion work, general influences of the Beta 21 movement may readily be observed.
Alas, circumstances rendered the Megaquartz 2400 the last of the line in Omega's long and distinguished 'quest for precision timekeeping', for much simpler and cheaper ways were soon
found to make perfectly satisfactory quartz watches for the largely un-discerning watch buying public. I am reminded here of how Maserati found themselves producing rather basic 'cart-
sprung' supercars in the 1970's, it has always been of course all in the 'designer' name. Perhaps I am being unfair here, but even today how many of the general public know or indeed care, for instance, what the difference actually is between a 'Chronometer' and a Chronograph? Omega Speedmaster 125's excepted of course.
The CAL 1500 also seems to have been Omega's first in house quartz movement, as while they would later offer 32kHz Megaquartz branded watches, is obvious that the modules in those owed a lot to and were probably made by ETA, of which Omega were fellow Societe Suisse pour l'industrie Horlogere (SSIH) members. Various other ETA modules were already used in a number of Omega watches by this time and after the general Swiss meltdown in the early 1980's Omega would source all their movements from ETA, becoming in effect just another Swiss marketing house. These days Omega's introduction of the coaxial escapement is a welcome change of direction perhaps, but there again Mr Daniels 20 year old inspiration seems just to have been integrated within yet another version of the ubiquitous 2892.
The 1970's were of course quite extraordinary times in the watch industry, and during this dramatic Quartz Revolution Omega found themselves offering such a wide range of vastly
different watch technologies that in reality could not be sustained for very long.
Then as now those times of turmoil seem highly confusing. For during that brief period Omega sold L.E.D. digital watches containing Hamilton Pulsar modules (SSIH had bought part of the group that owned Hamilton's digital technology). They sold watches with Bulova licensed ESA tuning fork movements, with optional modular chronograph work from Doubois-Depraz. They (Omega?) also produced their own quite stunning tuning fork watch, that used a magnetically coupled 'micromotor' with sapphire 'springs' (by this time Max Hetzel was working for Omega, and also on ways to get around the Bulova patents). Omega also offered 8 kHz analog quartz watches with E.S.A. (E.T.A.) sourced movements, as well as soldiering on with a range of conventional mechanical watches and chronographs. To mark the 1976 Olympic Games they produced the World's first quartz analog watch with built-in digital stopwatch (see below), and they even introduced a new self-winding mechanical 'chronometer'/chronograph to celebrate
their 125 anniversary. This, the collectable Seamaster 125 with its unique movement, had a reputed run of just 2,000.
This wonderfully creative nightmare lasted for just over a decade and in the end all this apparently heroic effort was to little avail in the face American and Japanese competition.
Japanese watch production increased by 10 times between 1974 and 1978, and so by the early 1980's it became just a case of finding a financially safe haven or sinking below the waves. Omega was already part of the much larger SSIH group, which evolved into SMH, which these days calls itself Swatch.
Back to the Megaquartz 2400:
There seem in the end to have been five versions of the 1500 movement. The 1500 itself was the prototype, of which a few were quietly exhibited at Basle in 1970. Production started in
1974 with the 1510 movement fitted to the 'standard' Megaquartz 2400 range of watches, and the chronometer certified 1511 version fitted to the Marine Chronometer watch. During the life of the 1510/1511 movement, improvements were made to the integrated circuit which resulted in the deletion of the out-board first stage dividing transformer, together with what looks like some other minor mechanical revisions. In 1976 (?) this resulted in revised type 1515
movements being fitted to the 'standard' constellation 2.4 Megaquartz watches and 1516 versions to the Marine Chronometer. It does though remain rather unclear what the exact differences there were between the various versions of this movement. The 1500 and 1510 would seem to share mounting arrangements, first stage analogue division transformer and associated chip capacitor, as well as a sweep seconds friction spring and capacitor in parallel with the battery. The chronometer certified 1511 version shared mounting brackets with the previous movements but did not have the sweep seconds friction spring or the parallel battery
capacitor (though the cut-out for this item remained in the plastic cover). In addition, because the 1511 did not have an additional cut-out for the dividing transformer's associated capacitor, it looks as though it had the updated chip first divider stage. The 1515 and 1516 had the updated electronics, revised and incompatible mounting arrangements, and no battery capacitor or cut-outs for these in the plastic insulating cover. The Marine Chronometer's case and bracelet remained essentially similar throughout the life of the watch, but with slight changes to the 'slope' of the watch case and the width of the bracelet. (Folded link bracelets are probably a later replacement.) According to Bill Schone, the 1511 and 1516 movements were the only ones to be fitted to the Omega Marine Chronometer watch. It might though be quite possible to interchange 1510 movements with 1511s, and 1515 movements with 1516s, so if you are looking for a watch that is correct check at least that it has the right movement...
All these Omegas were very expensive, but The Marine Chronometer was even more so. Only available in stainless steel with bezel and engraved serial number plate in 14k gold, the 1974 SSIH press release at the Science Museum quotes a UK price of £680, or about £3,500 in modern money. This was apparently around 3 times the cost of a 'basic' Megaquartz 2400 watch, and was at a time when UK inflation was running at about 25% per year.
(Marine Chronometer with 1516 movement
What made the Marine Chronometer so much more costly does remain a bit of a mystery because all the 1500 series of movements look to be so very similar. They all share the same
high frequency 2.4 MHz timebase and electromagnetic 'jumping' motor, and apart from the mounting arrangements, all look very similar. Certification is probably the main diffrence, but in fact only two 'production line' Marine Chronometers were actually submitted for the full
Neuchatel 63 day 'Observatory' certification as 'proper' marine chronometers. This was perhaps to demonstrate that the M.C. could be a marine chronometer 'if it wanted to'. The normal production watches were certified by the Besancon Observatory in France. Besancon being probably the only facility for the volume certicication of 'chronometer' movements.
One can of course make a couple of assumptions; that Nuchatel would have been unable to accommodate the quantities of production Marine Chronometer movements (1,000 caliber 1511 and 7,000 caliber 1516 movements manufactured), and that the 1511/16 movements were
perhaps more carefully assembled and / or had specially selected components.
The rectangular CAL 1511/16 movement is marked with a serial number (hopefully the same as the one on the case), 'thirteen jewels unadjusted', and looks neat and rather more like a classical mechanical watch movement than a utilitarian quartz 'module'. It appears to be built in the 'traditional Omega' way, with their usual copper-plated, hardened brass plates and bridges. Finish seems to be to the normal un-ostentatious house standards of the time. The movement is divided vertically into three sections, from top to bottom: electronic timebase package, motion work and the stepping motor. The single 1.5 Volt power cell is located next to the stepping
motor.
Occupying some forty percent of the movement's real estate, the self-contained electronic timebase package is attached to the movement's pillar plate by three gold plated screws and is
protected by a moulded plastic cover. The single integrated circuit (probably using bipolar transistors) is soldered within a central rectangular cutout in the glass fibre printed circuit
board, and appears to be encapsulated in a standard commercial quality unmarked plastic 8 pin 'flip-chip' package. To the left of the integrated circuit, within an oval cutout in the plastic cover, is a most unusual rate adjuster. I first thought this item was the quartz crystal itself, but it is in fact (well is probably!) a screening cover for the R.F. oscillator's trimming capacitor. This item is a machined and slotted hollow copper-plated cylinder, located by four pins and held down by a gold-plated annular ring and two stainless steel screws. This 'regulator' is un-calibrated, but can vary the going of the watch by about plus or minus 2 seconds per day. The quartz crystal itself is actually mounted directly under this trimmer on the underside of the printed circuit board, just behind the 7 ' baton of the dial. This crystal is unusual for a wrist watch in both type and frequency, and takes the form of a shallow lens-shaped (bi-convex) quartz disk about the same diameter as the watch's power cell. Sealed within a specially developed button-shaped flanged and cold-welded metal can, the crystal is cut to resonate at 2,359,296 Hz. This is some 73 times that of a normal 32 kHz quartz watch, and is actually within the 120 meter High Frequency radio waveband.
The trimming capacitor and quartz crystal are mounted above eachother in very close proximity, and this indicates good practice both in terms of minimizing stray capacitance and good thermal tracking. It is probable that the designer (The Omega site states that the project was co-ordinated by a Mr John Othenin-Girard) would have selected capacitor and crystal with opposing temperature coefficients so that to some extent they would cancel each other's relatively slight temperature drift.
Before my visit to the Science Museum, my assumption was that while the Marine Chronometer's timing crystal was of a very high frequency for a watch, it was still conventional
in form. Flat disk type quartz blanks being the most common type to be found in frequency generation and filtering circuitry. These are fairly easily ground to specific frequencies by
diamond lapping machines. Indeed in the very early days (WW2), crystal holders were made to be opened. This would allow the user to remove and grind their crystal to the exact frequency by using nothing more advanced than a fine knife sharpening stone! Later, quartz crystals evolved into those typically to be found in the HC-XX/U type of flattened, sealed, metal can as used in computers and model radio control equipment. As is well known of course, watch crystals are either of bar or of tuning fork form. This allows for the relatively low (ultrasonic) frequency quartz crystals to be made small enough to fit into a watch case. Unfortunately as is
also well known, that the temperature stability of quartz depends on the shape or the 'cut' of the crystal itself, with the shapes and cuts used to make low frequency tuning forks and bars being something of a compromise. Frequency is also significant, with the higher frequency providing better stability. The best and most stable timekeeping quartz crystals ever made were Mr. Louis Essen's large flat rings (which may also be seen at the London Science Museum), but that's another story. The point I am rather laboring here, is that quartz crystals are usually tiny tuning forks, thin bars, or rather larger flat disks.
The quartz crystal used in the Omega Megaquartz 2400 movement, is a lens shaped disk...
The documentation that can be viewed at the Science Museum (Omega technical folder 0-1510), describes a 'wafer thin lenticular' quartz disk having an almost flat temperature curve between 10deg C and 50deg C. The watch's rate being set at an ambient temperature of 28deg C, which is apparently the average temperature of a person's wrist.
High frequency (>1 MHz) flat quartz disks are common in the electronics industry. These are though typically much larger than tuning fork watch crystal for any given frequency. In the late 1960's during the development of the Megaquartz 2400, Batelle/Omega worked with ITT STC Quartz Crystal Division, at Harlow in the UK to design and produce the first high frequency quartz crystals for their new state-of-the-art watch. They started at 1 MHz, which was the highest frequency that C.E.H.'s integrated circuit could cope with at the time (as regards to working frequency verses level of integration and power consumption). However, during the life of the project C.E.H. were able to refine their IC while keeping current consumption acceptable. This was difficult development work because monolithic integrated circuits were not particularly suited to high frequency radio applications in those days, and the low 1.5 volt supply was also a challenge. 'Old hat' now, but very cutting edge in the late 1960's. Eventually they were able to increase the working frequency to 2.4 MHz, the whole thing being a trade off between maximum frequency (for the best timekeeping stability), and what the electronics were capable of in terms of working frequency and power consumption. All STC had to do now, was to make a 2.4 MHz quartz disk small enough to fit the available space, and come up with the
most compact hermetically sealed package to mount it in. The problems being that a conventional quartz disk to fit the available space would have a resonant frequency in the
region of 6 MHz, and thus be far too high for the electronics to cope with. In addition, a conventional but bulky crystal mounting 'can' would simply make matters worse. STC solved
these problems by using an AT cut bi-convex crystal in their own specially developed housing. Grinding the crystal into a lens form apparently reduces the resonant frequency compared to a flat disk. This quartz lens was then metalized and soldered by its circumference into a unique cold weld/resistance sealed, 'flattened top hat' only slightly larger than the crystal itself. The mode of vibration of the crystal allowed them to use the strongest method of mounting and they chose an AT cut because of its low thermal drift at a 28deg ambient 'wrist temperature'. And so the ingenious and precise heart of Omega's Megaquartz 2400 watch (and the Marine
Chronometer watch) was actually designed by a (once) British company in deepest Essex.
I am indebted to Doug Dwyer for the above information and corrections (he was there), and his authoritative contributions about quartz watches and atomic clocks, are well worth reading at Howstuffworks.com.
It would seem that development work on the integrated circuit continued into the production phase of the watch, as the first examples (according to Omega Folder 0-1510) used a
transformer in the 'front end' of the division circuitry. This was later deleted as the IC became able to work with the 2.4 MHz crystal directly. Given time it is possible that we might have
seen even higher frequency Megaquartz watches, as the electronics were developed further. RCA introduced CMOS (Complimentary Metal Oxide Semiconductor) integrated circuits in 1972, and this now widespread technology had profound implications for highly integrated low current consumption electronics, which of course continues today. Omega themselves went on to produce a full sized 4 Megahertz boxed marine chronometer (deck watch) for the French Navy, but by this time the quartz revolution had arrived and many priorities had changed.
Much later technology would bring temperature compensation or microprocessor 'tuning' of relatively humble 32KHz quartz crystals (either by ambient temperature sensing or 'disciplining'
by an intermittent high frequency timebase) and one must give respectful nods in the direction of Rolex, Seiko and ETA. But in those ancient and heroic times of the early 1970's, No one had
such options, and Omega had the courage (?) to do things rather more simply and arguably more 'elegantly' in the first place.
In addition to the chronometer certificate from Brescanon, Omega also supplied their own test report.
Omega Marine Chronometer thoughts:
If you are thinking about acquiring one of these interesting watches, these few comments may be of some help.
While the Marine Chronometer's sapphire crystal and dial did not seem to change during the production run of the watch, the case and bracelet apparently did. The first watch cases with the 1511 movements seem to have a different slope to the top and bottom of the front of the cases, It also seems that the later bracelets (or factory replacements) are slightly narrower where they meet the watch case, and they also may be of the cheaper 'folded' construction. The original bracelets seem to have followed the 'big Omega' chunky house style of the time, and consisted of thick and solid main links with hidden flattened tubular
intermediate links 'embedded' on the inner surface of the bracelet. Small and rather weedy 12mm long spring bars held the whole lot together. The big chunky Omegas of the early 1970's all had this type of bracelet, and one can swap the links between different models of watch.
If the case of the watch looks new it has probably been re-finished at some point. Not a total disaster I suppose as the factory seems to do this as a matter of course during a service. The obvious place to confirm this is on the case back. While these 2.4 'Megaquartz's were all Omega 'Constellations', they did
not have the traditional Omega 'embossed observatory' logo on the case back. Instead they came with a very plain brushed rectangular back with a very shallow embossed Omega sign within a 2 line rectangular frame. Refinishing over the years usually removes most of this logo.
The watch glass will usually look good as this is sapphire (exotic for 1974), unfortunately the paint on the dial side can sometimes flake or fade (some examples also seem to have yellow hands). As far as I can see, the 14K gold bezel is a puerly decorative feature, and just serves to underline the marine chronometer 'theme'. The gold bits 'echo' the traditional brass fittings of a boxed mechanical chronometer perhaps - it does look nice though. (For a while I did think about getting Gary Sellick of Salt Lake City to
make me a 'proper' miniature chronometer box for my watch, I but acquired a very nice wooden box from Omega instead - at about half the price wanted by those selling the same boxes on eBay.
While the engraved serial number on the little 14K plate at the front is supposed to be that of the movement, it is not impossible after a quarter of a century to find that these in fact do not match. Not the happiest discovery for the collector perhaps, though a 'proper' Marine Chronometer movement (CAL
1511 or 1516) will only fit a Marine Chronometer case, and Omega regard a non-matching watch as still quite 'correct'. One might imagine that the factory would sometimes just replace a complete movement in the event of a serious problem (or to save time / cost). Actually non-matching Marine Chronometer
numbers are quite traditional in the maritime world, as many a classical mechanical chronometer will have ended up with a mixture of numbers.
The Bescancon observatory won't thank me for this, but one can still get copies of the original rating certificate if yours is lost. I think that this is a quite remarkable service in this day and age, though you might have to wait some months for them to dig the figures out. However, you will have a nice new hand written duplicate certificate at the end - bravo!
Omega do though still seem to look after these watches, and there is evidence that they are even manufacturing some new parts for it. Servicing can take a while though, as all watches these days have to be sent back to 'the factory' in Switzerland. Expect to spend some money as well (my overhaul cost
£390). But unlike when you get your car serviced (often at less cost!) Omega don't bother to give you a list of what they have actually done, very poor show that. From what I could see with mine, they installed a new 'phasing' pusher and re-finished the watch (without asking). Hopefully they changed the oil and put
new plugs in as well... Actually I have the feeling that work on these watches is 'farmed out' to local individual watchmakers that are experienced with these movements.
Battery:
Omega fit a RENATA 386 (but mine didn't last a year), though the thinner 344 will also work.
To set the watch:
The crown has 3 positions:
1) Pressed in: normal running
2) Pulled out to the first position: this allows you to move the hour hand independently (the minutes and
seconds are not influenced) and also to set the date. (The watch does not have a quick date change.)
3) Pulled fully out: the watch is stopped, the minutes (and hours) can be set. This position is used
normally only after a battery change.
The push button near the crown is to precisely adjust the seconds: while the button is pressed (say with a cocktail stick) the seconds are stopped, when you give pulses to this button on each press the seconds hand will go ahead one second.
That's the theory, but even after an overhaul the seconds hand seems to have a life of its own. I have found that the best way to set the watch to the second is to slightly turn the minute hand anti-clockwise until the seconds hand (actually) stops. Then you can start the watch by pushing the crown fully in. Judicious jabs of the pusher can get the watch to show time to the second.
Indeed, it seems rather too easy to reset the time on this 'chronometer'. On a real chronometer you can only change the hours and minutes, and this has to be done by unscrewing the front glass (one 'of course' never touches the seconds hand). It is a pity that Omega didn't make the crown and seconds pusher a little less accessible with some sort of bracket or cover, rather than festooning it with gold beezels and serial number plates. But that's the jewelry business for you. If I had a milling machine I would make a new back with some sort of side protection cover. After all, one should only need to adjust the watch after
replacing the battery. And of course with a real chronometer one never set the thing to the second anyway, you just note the machine's error against a known standard . But there again we are not in the eighteenth century -
'Set the topgalants Mr Christian'...
Oh, and a last note on regulating the beast. I found that the biggest influence on the timekeeping of my example was ambient temperature. Of course Omega expected you to keep the watch on your wrist and adjusted the going accordingly. However as my watch spends 99.6% of its time safely in its box, I found that it consistently gained (which was the opposite of what one would expect). Assuming the two small screws holding the ring surrounding the trimmer to be also locking screws, I though it unwise to attempt to meddle. I am therefore grateful to Craig Rodgers for discovering that the trimmer is quite easily
adjusted by simply turning the large main slot with a screwdriver. Clockwise to go faster and anticlockwise to go slower, though as with all these types of trimmer: very small movements are needed. And now I have a watch that has lost less than a second in 3 months
While the timebase of the Megaquartz 2400 movement was unique for a wrist watch, so also it seems was its electromagnetic motor. In those dark ages Seiko showed how all would do this sort of thing in the future. They used a simple 'skeletal' form of stepping motor with single cylindrical coil and extended soft iron pole pieces. However, Omega's solution was more complex, probably more expensive and possibly less reliable. It was though an elegant and significant simplification of much that went before including the Beta 21's vibrating pendulum. In those days converting electronic pulses into rotary motion with something that would fit into a watch case, was cheap, and ran on microwatts of power remained rather a challenge.
It seems that Omega went back to the earlier technology of perhaps a decade before, when the likes of Hamilton, Lip and others mounted tiny electromagnets on modified lever watch
balances. These miniature swinging electromagnets drove the hands of the watch by an escapement 'working in reverse' with the magnetically pulsed balance driving the gear train instead of locking and unlocking it. But while not needing to be wound and involving much lower forces than a spring driven movement, these electric watches were actually rather
unreliable and of little practical advantage over conventional mainspring driven watch (though they may have had better isochronism). These delicate electro-mechanical hybrids did though demonstrate that a low energy electromagnetic impulse could successfully drive the motion work of a wristwatch, but without electronic switching (a transistor), not for very long.
For the Megaquartz 2400 movement Omega fashioned something vaguely similar to those old electromagnet-balances. But this time in a compact and efficient miniature flat coil that rotates sideways in an arc of approximately 30 degrees between the gap of two pairs of powerful (probably rare earth) magnets. (These magnets are the silver-Grey rectangles just to the right of the battery in the above image). The coil 'jumps' across the magnetic field once a second, and
this tiny 'armature' is returned to rest by a pair of spiral hair springs mounted coaxially with the pivot. This sideways 'tick' drives the wheel train forward one second per 'jump'.
From cursory examination it would appear that Omega used something vaguely similar to an anchor 'escapement' to drive the motion work. Ruby pallets mounted on substantial anchor
horns alternately push and lock a modified 'escape' wheel that is just visible in the image below. Once a second the tiny coil jumps forward and back under the influence of those
powerful magnets. It takes less than 1/25th of a second to do this and clearly makes an audible 'tick' (actually the 'tick' of this watch is quite loud). Because no mechanical switching is
involved, the mechanism is working at one fifth the frequency of a mechanical lever watch, with a remarkably high jewel count, this anchor mechanism would seem to be fairly under-
stressed.
The pivots of this little coil's 'armature' are mounted in shock resistant settings similar to the Incablock type. The coil itself has many turns of fine wire, and is mounted (glued?) at one end
of what looks like a dumbbell shaped glass-fiber printed circuit board with a counterpoise at the other side of the arbor. The electrical impulses are transferred to the coil by two spiral hair springs placed between the moving coil armature and its bridge. The upper spring is welded to a pin connected to the Positive potential of the movement plate, and the lower spring is welded to a pin connected to the electronics module. The substantial 'anchor' driving the 'escape' wheel has a pair of dissimilar pallet jewels and is mounted on the other side of the armature, between the flat coil and the pillar plate. The spring tensions are set such that this 'escapement' is locked most of the time by one of the pallet jewels resting between two 'spokes' of the 'escape' wheel. The short-duration Negative pulses from the electronics module are transferred to this motor by means of a flat Stainless Steel backwards L shaped 'bus bar', clearly visible just above the movement. One end of this bus bar is connected to the electronics circuit board by a gold-plated screw, and the other is spot welded to the upper hair spring pin of the motor module.
For ninety percent of the time the movement is actually at rest and locked by one of the pallet jewels. On receiving a pulse from the timebase the coil it finds itself in an opposing magnetic field while at the same time attracted to the adjacent pair of magnets. The magnetic forces become stronger than both the frictional and the hair spring biasing tensions, and the coil rapidly rotates towards the adjacent magnetic field. The sudden rotation causes one or more of the pallet jewels to give an 'escape' wheel tooth a glancing blow. This increments the mechanism one second, and the coil rapidly returns to rest and the movement locked until the next pulse. One wonders if they fed the coil's back EMF into the battery to help with power consumption...
This stately 'electric ticking' is perhaps a less stressfull way of doing things than driving vibrating pendulums or tuning forks at hundreds of Hz. Moving a sensitive flat electromagnet once a second in a narrow, concentrated magnetic field is also very efficient (as demonstrated by flat printed circuit motors), and the mechanical lock-impulse-lock action of this 'escapement' seems in a subtle way to exibit more 'precision' in its action than conventional quartz watch 180 degree angle 'stepping' motors. Omega's mechanism does though remain a complex and probably expensive way of driving an electronic watch gear train. Watch repairers don't touch or like these movements simply because the mechanism is so alien and unique in comparison to the normal spring driven clockwork they are used to, but this should not in the slightest detract from Omega's overall achievement with this movement.
This jumping motor was I believe only used in the Megaquartz 2.4 series of watches, though I have recently been advised that Rolex continue to use something vaguely similar in their own
but rather undervalued Oysterquartz movements. Omega would soon change to a miniature rotary stepping motor which can be seen in slightly later watches such as the 1976 Chrono-
Quartz 'Albatross' (below right). I also have a slight though receeding suspicion that motor used in the Megaquartz 2400 could have been something of a mixed blessing as regards shock sensitivity. The jumping armature while probably of lower mass than a conventional balance and perfectly well protected by its shock absorbing bearings, will though have a much higher moment of inertia than a conventional stepping motor, and might be 'upset' by an external shock occouring at the wrong time. This might happen with say the armature unlocked between a beat, its arbor slightly deflected as the resilient jeweling absorbs a jolt and the anchor failing to return to the next position on the escape wheel. No damaged caused at all and with only a missed beat. But, with an old type balance electromagnetic or otherwise, the odd miss of a beat would be hardly significant, but with the Marine Chronometer one missed beat will represent a whole month's rate and be very obvious. And my suspicion is that this possibility may have caused this movement to have been so specialised and short lived. It is a fantastically accurate and well engineered piece of work, a tour-de-force and true state-of-the-art even today, but catch it wrong and you may suddenly lose or gain a second. Of course this is mere conjecture on my part (like most of this essay!), but it might answer some slightly nagging questions. So perhaps one shouldn't play tennis while navigating one's yacht with it. But for those of us without a yacht (or a tennis racquet for that matter), it may not be a
significant problem. Shame perhaps Omega didn't revise the movement to incorporate their own stepping motor. But of course there may have been other issues to do with developing a new chip, current consumption and who knows what else
The Omega Marine Chronometer was an even more expensive and exotic quartz watch at a time when all such things were expensive and exotic. It was though (probably) the most accurate and advanced watch of its time, and arguably remains the most accurate self-contained wrist watch ever made. My own example has achieved an average daily variation in rate of eight one thousandths of a second and an annual rate of minus nine seconds.
There was nothing quite like this Omega before or indeed since, and in addition to its timekeeping qualities I rather appreciate its unfussy and straight forward outer form. By modern standards it could perhaps be a little thinner and less 'chunky', but it does have perhaps the most ledgible face of any wristwatch. Unfortunately the World changed rather rapidly and Omega didn't build upon this impressive early achievement. Indeed some say that the Swiss threw away
their early technological advantage, preferring to remain with their 'quaint' spring driven mechanisms. But what else in reality could they have done? Happily for the few survivors, in time the World changed full circle. How ironic that the old-fashioned became again fashionable towards the end of last century? But nothing stays the same. As to wether the 'modern' wrist watch has much technical merit is a diffrent question. Most Swiss 'manufactures' rely on common mass produced quartz or mechanical movements, mostly designed years ago. The thought of old wine in expensive new bottles usually comes to mind, and in some cases not particularly impressive or costly wine at that. But all this is well known. There are of course a few notable and even impressive exceptions mostly from the far east (and indeed from Switzerland if you can afford a Ferrari or two), but in the quarter century since the exciting chaos of the quartz revolution we do not seem to have travelled very far. If things had progressed the way they were looking briefly in the mid 1970's, then by now we might indeed be telling time by our own Rubidium or Cesium wrist watches. But we don't because we never did actually need or could afford such precision in the first place. It's nice to own and to 'show-off' an expensive watch with the 'right' name of any technology and that's about it. We might though sometimes remind ourselves that the quartz watch was once a coveted and rather exciting object which many of us perhaps naively perceived as one of the significant technological harbingers of better things to
come. Seiko proclaimed that 'some day all watches will be made this way', and they were proved quite (and probably much to their surprise) correct only a few years later. But the new
technology proved only to be good in parts; the relatively easy things like making ever more complex chips did indeed bring us many remarkably complex and remarkably affordable new
toys to strap on our wrists, but the difficult things still remained out of reach. Yes one can buy a wrist 'atomic clock', but the real thing remains (for the moment at least - see below) a large and unaffordable scientific instrument. And these days when I gaze in the watch seller's window I am usually depressed by the booring, decadent and deeply unimpressive stuff on offer and my mind goes back to a time when words such as Accutron, Pulsar and Megaquartz captured the
imagination and seemed to foretell of a bright technological future that didn't quite happen.
Since starting this piece a couple of years ago some remarkable work has been going on at NIST in America. It seems that their scientists have been able to build a prototype simplified atomic
clock physics package that is approximately the size of a grain of rice (!). By exciting Cesium atoms with a semiconductor laser instead of traditional microwaves in a structure owing much to
semiconductor fabrication techniques, they have developed a tiny low-power timebase that is over three thousand times more stable than the quartz crystal used in the Marine Chronometer watch. It is expected that mobile phones, GPS equipment and the military will be the first applications for these new 'nano' atomic standards, but one wonders if the likes of Casio and Citizen are aware of these interesting developments as well. Possibly the Swiss also, though how they are going to integrate this miniature physics packages into yet another version of their self-winding mechanical 2892 movement remains to be seen... No problem getting the COSC
sales ticket, oh sorry; 'Chronometer Certificate' though!
Gino Mancini, May 2005
Sources:
B.H.I.- Horological Journal
'World Mook' - The Electric Watch
D.S. Landies - Revolution in time
Cutmore - Watches
Omega Technical folder 0-1510
The Internet, including Omega and NIST sites.
And my thanks to Doug Dwyer and to Craig Rodgers.