Photo by Ben Hershey on Unsplash; Image has been cropped and tinted

Fantasy Sleepers and Busts for the 2021 Season

Don't just follow the rankings- here are all the underrated and overrated players this season

September 3, 2021

Fantasy football experts study players as a full time job, so most of the time, they know what they're talking about. However, they sometimes miss a player set for a breakout season or expect too much out of a player. So, I am here to identify those players. Here are my sleepers and busts for the 2021 fantasy football season.

Sleepers

Here are some players that I believe are being undervalued by fantasy experts this season.

Quarterbacks:

Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert, the fifth-overall pick in the 2020 NFL draft, has MVP potential this year. With one of the strongest arms in the league, good accuracy, mobility, and decision making, Herbert has all the traits needed to become one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. Herbert was the seventh highest scoring quarterback last season, and experts are ranking him right around there for this season. However, with weapons like Keenan Allen, Mike Williams, and Austin Ekeler, as well as the addition of Rams quarterbacks coach Joe Lombardy as offensive coordinator, there is no reason why Herbert can’t shatter this ranking.

Russell Wilson (Seattle Seahawks): Wilson is already established as a top five quarterback in the NFL. He was leading the MVP race last season until a subpar second half. However, Seattle replaced old-school offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer in the offseason, a move that will likely benefit Wilson. With receivers like DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett at his disposal, Wilson has potential to regain his MVP form from the first half of last season.

Matthew Stafford (Los Angeles Rams): The Rams acquired Stafford in a trade with the Lions over the offseason. He has one of the strongest arms in the NFL and also has solid accuracy. With playmakers like Robert Woods, Cooper Cup, Desean Jackson, Van Jefferson, and Tyler Higbee to go along with one of the best play callers in the league in Sean McVay, Stafford has a chance to explode this year.

Zach Wilson (New York Jets): Wilson, the #2 overall pick in the 2021 NFL draft out of Brigham Young University, is often overshadowed by #1 overall pick Trevor Lawrence out of Clemson, but his talent is comparable, if not better, than Lawrence’s. Wilson has all the traits of a great quarterback. He is accurate, has a strong arm, can scramble inside and outside the pocket, and has a feel for the game that not many quarterbacks have. The sky is the limit for him.

Running Backs:

D’Andre Swift (Detroit Lions): Swift, a 2020 second-round pick, has a chance for a breakout season this year. Detroit’s new head coach, Dan Campbell, is an old-school coach who wants his team to be physical and run the ball more. Moreover, the Lions hired former LA Chargers coach Anthony Lynn as offensive coordinator. Lynn is regarded as one of the best running backs coaches in the league. Swift has tremendous talent; he was the second running back drafted in the 2020 NFL draft. He has all the ingredients to blossom into one of football’s best runners this season.

Damien Harris (New England Patriots): Harris, the older brother of 2021 first-round pick Najee Harris, emerged as New England’s best back late last season while Sony Michel was injured. After Michel was traded to the Rams, Harris has the running game all to himself, although he will be replaced by excellent receiving back James White on passing downs. The Pats are set to have a run-oriented offense this season, meaning Harris is set for a heavy workload. Harris is a bruising, powerful runner who should have great success behind New England’s stout offensive line.

James Robinson (Jacksonville Jaguars): After rookie Travis Etienne suffered a season- ending foot injury, Robinson is Jacksonville’s undisputed workhorse again. He burst onto the scene last year as an undrafted rookie and was fantasy’s seventh highest-scoring running back. Before Etienne’s injury, Robinson was being drafted as about a seventh-round pick. He should now be taken in the second to third round.

Phillip Lindsay (Houston Texans): Most fantasy experts are projecting David Johnson to be Houston’s number one running back, but they are underrating Lindsay. Johnson used to be one of the NFL’s best backs, but injuries have derailed his career and he has had back-to-back subpar seasons. Lindsay is a younger, more explosive runner and has decent receiving ability as well. Johnson likely won’t be completely phased out of Houston’s backfield, so Lindsay’s upside is limited, but he could be a consistent mid-range fantasy running back that you can easily pick in the 10th to 15th rounds.

Wide Receivers:

Davante Adams (Green Bay Packers): Adams has been fantasy’s number one wide receiver for the last two seasons. However, Adams was bumped down draft boards while rumors about Aaron Rodgers’ future in Green Bay swirled. Now, with Rodgers officially back in the fold, Adams should again be the first receiver off the board in fantasy drafts. If you are able to grab him in the late first round, do it. He is a steal where he is being ranked by the experts.

Terry McLaurin (Washington Football Team): McLaurin is being ranked as the eighth to tenth receiver by fantasy experts, but he has top five potential. Washington’s new quarterback, Ryan Fitzpatrick, is known to lock in on his #1 target, which is McLaurin in this case. If Fitzpatrick is as good as he was last season, McLaurin should get plenty of targets and hall in most of them. With his speed and ability to run short, medium, and deep routes, he is one of the few do-it-all receivers in the NFL.

D.J. Chark Jr. (Jacksonville Jaguars): Chark, a 2018 second round pick who has broken out over the past two seasons, will finally have a star quarterback to work with in Trevor Lawrence. I hate to say this, but while he may be overrated, Lawrence is a definite upgrade over Gardner Minshew, my favorite NFL quarterback. Chark is a poor-man’s version of McLaurin, but he has potential to improve. He is currently being rated as an eighth to ninth round pick in fantasy, but he should probably be more like a sixth to seventh round pick with potential to be even better than that.

Devonta Smith (Philadelphia Eagles): Smith, the 2021 Heisman Trophy winner at Alabama and the 10th-overall pick in the 2021 NFL draft by the Eagles, reminds me a lot of Kansas City Chiefs superstar receiver Tyreek Hill. He can out-run almost any defender and can do pretty much anything a coach might ask of a receiver – he can run everything from screens to intermediate routes and deep posts. The only things that could hold Smith back are his physical stature and the play of the Eagles young quarterback, Jalen Hurts. Smith is 5-foot, 11 inches tall and weighs 170 pounds. While this profile could limit his strength, he demonstrated the ability to separate from defenders and get open in college. His speed should compensate for any lack of strength. Even more, Tyreek Hill has a similar profile, coming in at 5-10 and 185 pounds. The only other question for Smith is Hurts. He was inconsistent last season but showed flashes of great potential. If Hurts improves this year, Smith could shatter expectations.

Marquez Callaway (New Orleans Saints): Callaway won’t be a sleeper for much longer if he continues to impress at training camp and in pre-season games. He has caught eight passes for 165 yards and two touchdowns in two pre-season games thus far, including a five-catch, 104-yard, and two-touchdown performance in just a quarter of action against the Jaguars. With Michael Thomas set to miss the start of the regular season while recovering from foot surgery, Callaway has a real chance to emerge as New Orleans’ number one wideout.

Honorable Mentions: Tyron Johnson (Los Angeles Chargers) and Parris Campbell (Indianapolis Colts): Johnson is buried on the Chargers depth chart but is a deep threat who could emerge if any of LA’s top pass catchers get hurt. Campbell appeared to be a blossoming star last season before a torn ACL cut his season short. He has looked good in the pre-season thus far and could pick up where he left off last year if he stays healthy. Considering Johnson and Campbell’s circumstances, don’t draft them unless you are in a deeper league. Wait and see how they play to start the season before making a move.

Tight Ends:

Irv Smith Jr. (Minnesota Vikings): With the departure of longtime starter Kyle Rudolph, Smith is the undisputed starting tight end for the Vikings. After breaking out late last season, Smith should take even more steps forward this season and should be a reliable option for fantasy managers at a thin tight end position.

Tyler Higbee (Los Angeles Rams): Similar to the situation in Minnesota, Higbee is now the Rams undisputed starting tight end after Gerald Everett left for the Seahawks in free agency. Higbee has shown flashes of greatness over the past two seasons, and with Matthew Stafford running the offense, he has a chance to put it all together and have a breakout season.

Pat Freiermuth (Pittsburgh Steelers): Freiermuth, a 2021 second round pick, has impressed in training camp, has a chance to take over the starting job from incumbent veteran Eric Ebron, who has struggled with drops throughout his time in Pittsburgh. Freiermuth has star potential, but rookie tight ends often struggle early in their careers compared to quarterbacks or other skill players while acclimating to the NFL, so it is far from a certainty that this will happen.

Busts

Here are some players I am staying away from this fantasy season.

Quarterbacks:

Dak Prescott (Dallas Cowboys): The quarterbacks are ranked accurately for the most part, so Prescott is the only bust I could come up with. Don’t get me wrong, I believe Prescott will have a great season. He has a plethora of receivers to throw to and will likely have to throw a lot considering how bad Dallas’ defense is. However, he is coming off a gruesome ankle injury that caused him to miss most of last season and has been dealing with shoulder fatigue in training camp. Guys like Herbert and Wilson are being ranked lower by experts, but they are more talented, have good receivers to throw to, and are less of an injury risk than Prescott.

Running Backs:

Saquon Barkley (New York Giants): Barkley is a consensus top 5-8 running back among fantasy experts. However, he missed almost all of last season with a torn ACL and has a below- average offensive line to run behind. He is hit or miss as a runner and will sometimes try and do too much, resulting in negative plays. At his best, Barkley has potential to be one of the best do-it-all backs in the NFL, but considering his recent injury, poor offensive line, and aggressive running style, I question how productive he will be this season.

Ezekiel Elliot (Dallas Cowboys): Elliot is one of the more overrated players in the NFL. He is a good running back, but he is far from elite or even great. Add that to the likely pass- heavy game scripts Dallas will likely be in considering their poor defense, and Elliot is far from being worth a first-round pick in fantasy.

Mike Davis (Atlanta Falcons): Davis, for some reason, is being ranked as a top 60 overall player by experts. He is one of the worst starting running backs in the league. There is absolutely no reason to waist a mid-round pick on Davis.

Chase Edmonds (Arizona Cardinals): Edmunds is not a bad player, but he is an average starting running back. He is also set to be part of a committee with former Steeler James Connor, limiting Edmonds upside. As he is currently being ranked as a top 50 player in fantasy, he is very overrated.

Wide Receivers:

Adam Thielen (Minnesota Vikings): Thielen has been a great receiver for the Vikings for years now, but he is getting old and losing his stride. Additionally, Justin Jefferson, a 2020 first-round pick, has surpassed him on the depth chart. Thielen should have an ok season, but he is not worth a top 50 pick in fantasy anymore.

"11 - Adam Thielen" by apc99 is licensed under CC BY 2.0

Tight Ends:

Eric Ebron (Pittsburgh Steelers): With his drop issues and Pat Freiermuth waiting in the wings, Ebron could lose has a chance to be phased out of the Steelers offense.

Happy drafting and good luck this season!

Max Teply (10)

Max is in his fourth year at Edgewood and second on the Edge staff. He enjoys rock climbing, following sports, reading, writing, and listening to country music. This year, he hopes to bring some more great stories and ideas to the Edge.