Tony earned three varsity letters in Football, three varsity letters in Baseball, and two varsity letters in Basketball. He was named Second Team All-State in Football his senior year.
Tony earned First Team All-MAC in Football during his senior season and Honorable Mention All-MAC during his junior season. In Basketball, he was named to the All-Northwest Ohio Honorable Mention list during his senior year. Tony earned All-MAC First Team in Basketball during his junior and senior seasons. He was a District 8 All Star during his senior year in basketball.
In Baseball, Tony was named First Team All-MAC during his junior and senior seasons. Tony was a member of the 1987 State Championship Baseball Team. He received the Don Black Scholarship during his senior year.
Tony played Baseball at the University of Dayton where he lettered for three years.