Search this site
Embedded Files
EL Ed Central 6-8

EL Education : 8th Grade : Module 1 : Unit 3

Compare and Contrast Essay: Summer of the Mariposas and Latin American Folklore

EL Education Unit Page

Lessons

1     Close Read Summer of the Mariposas, Author’s Note

2     Mid-Unit 3 Assessment: Determine a Central Idea

3     Close Read: La Llorona

4     Compare and Contrast Depictions of La Llorona, Part I

5     Compare and Contrast Depictions of La Llorona, Part II

6     Painted Essay®: Analyze a Model

7     Write a Compare & Contrast Essay: Draft the Intro

8     Write a Compare & Contrast Essay: Draft Proof Paragraph 1

9     Write a Compare & Contrast Essay: Draft Proof Paragraph 2

10     Write a Compare and Contrast Essay: Draft a Conclusion

11     Plan End of Unit 3 Assessment Essay

12     End of Unit 3 Assessment: Write Compare & Contrast Essay

13     Introduce the Performance Task

14       Performance Task: Create a Webpage 

Link to G8M1U3 Student Materials

Link to G8M1U3 Slides

Designated ELD Lessons for G8M1 Unit 3

  • These are DRAFT materials developed by OUSD teachers for OUSD teachers, not yet a complete core ELD program.

  • Consider beginning the school year with the Secondary Designated -ELD Unit Zero, an optional three-week unit that provides an introduction to Designated ELD.

  • Grade 8 Module 1 Designated ELD Scope and Sequence may be viewed here for context and big picture.

  • Please consider filling out the Designated ELD for EL Ed Lesson Feedback Form to help us improve the Designated ELD lessons, units and modules.

G8-M1-U3-L3-L4 Language Dive

G8-M1-U3-L6-L7 Text Level Language Dive

G8-M1-U3-L9-L10 Language Dive

G8-M1-U3-L11-L12 Language Dive

Unit Description

In the first half of the unit, students read informational texts relevant to Summer of the Mariposas and the topic to determine central idea. In the second half of the unit, students write a literary analysis essay using the Painted Essay® structure to compare and contrast how La Llorona was portrayed in Summer of the Mariposas with the original story, to explain how Guadalupe Garcia McCall has rendered the story new. For their end of unit assessment, students write another essay explaining how they modernized their own monster in the narrative piece they wrote in Unit 2.

For homework, students will continue to preread chapters of Summer of the Mariposas before discussing them in class. On any day that a prereading of a chapter is not assigned, students should continue their independent research reading by reading for at least 20 minutes and responding to a prompt. Additionally, students should continue independent research reading over the weekends.

Texts


Summer of the Mariposas

by Guadalupe Garcia McCall

one per classroom

Preparation and Materials

Prepare vocabulary logs and independent reading journals.

Ensure that families are aware of the sensitive content of Summer of the Mariposas, and prepare students who may be affected by this content in advance.

The following materials are introduced in this unit and referenced throughout both the module and the school year:

  • Paint an Essay lesson plan (for teacher reference)

  • Painted Essay® template (one per student)

  • Peer Critique Protocol anchor chart (new, to be created)

  • Directions for Peer Critique (one for display)

Habits of Character/Social-Emotional Learning Focus

Central to the EL Education curriculum is a focus on "habits of character" and social-emotional learning. Students work to become effective learners, developing mindsets and skills for success in college, career, and life (e.g., initiative, responsibility, perseverance, collaboration); they work to become ethical people, treating others well and standing up for what is right (e.g., empathy, integrity, respect, compassion); and they work to contribute to a better world, putting their learning to use to improve communities (e.g., citizenship, service).

In Unit 3, students track working to become ethical people as they finish the novel Summer of the Mariposas. In Lessons 1-7, they summarize each chapter and look for examples of how the Garza girls grow in their capacity to show empathy, compassion, and integrity in their interactions with others (and especially with one another).

In addition, students focus on working to become effective learners as they complete a series of partner tasks while preparing to write their explanation essays. As students work together, they identify ways in which they can increase their perseverance and effective collaboration. Students then evaluate their successes and challenges in this work, setting new goals for the next partner session.

For their Performance Task, students work on contributing to a better world by creating a website to house their narrative retelling of a myth from folklore of Latin America and their compare and contrast literary analysis essays that compare the original myth to their retelling. Myths and folklore of Latin America are not well represented on the internet, and creating a webpage for these stories helps to contribute to a better world in which these important stories are more well known.

Report abuse
Page details
Page updated
Report abuse