Upon realizing that the United States would be shut down in order to protect its citizens from the mass outbreak of the COVID-19 virus, many people began stocking up on toilet paper and select foods while they still had the chance and began to act cautiously around anybody to the point that one could have thought themselves to be an enemy to the public and to just stay home. Prior to this, many people had vaguely heard of "coronavirus." This disease that was supposedly ravaging China that caused the country to go under mandatory quarantine in order to stop the virus from spreading. However, COVID-19 inevitably got out shutting down country after country until everybody was in a panic. Many people feared to leave their house for fear of contracting the virus and passing it on to a loved one who was at risk or possibly going into critical condition themself. However, like every other crisis in history there needed to be someone to blame. During the Black Plague, people who happened to be Jewish were persecuted for supposedly causing the plague, while in the 1990's the LGBTQ+ community was targeted for being the ones to cause the HIV/AIDS epidemic. This time, it is the Asian American community. On this page, I will be discussing the issue of modern day racism that Asian Americans are facing during this time as well as the history of utilizing scapegoats during times of crisis.
Historically, when there is a widespread crisis, the affected usually tend to blame those who are different from them out of expediency and ignorance. During the peak of the Black Death in Europe, 200 Jewish communities were nearly wiped out in response to accusations that they were spreading contagions and poisons to those around them with little to no evidence supporting this claim.
This act of blaming minority groups for the causes of widespread suffering is nothing new and is still utilized today through the use of politics and social media. Usually, scapegoating is done in order to take the blame off of one's self and when it comes to blaming others who have less power, the groups with more power are usually deemed right. The modern theory regarding the Black Death pandemic suggests that the disease spread from the Mongols while they reigned across Eurasia taking it from one end to the other, but that the disease might have originated in the Great Lakes region of Africa hundreds to thousands of years before. Therefore, who is to blame for bringing it to the Mongols in the first place?
Within Ethnomusicology, we studied Merriam's Tripartite Model which is used to analyze the overall organization of actions, sounds, and beliefs related to a certain cultural action or situation. With regards to the current events occurring, I made a tripartite model which demonstrates the organization of the various responses to COVID-19 related racism. This model deals with the concepts (the overall goals or ideas) of responding to COVID-19 related racism, the behaviors that can be taken in order to combat racism, and the physical sounds that are produced as a response to this racism. These sounds can vary from rap songs, audio clips of altercations (which can be sampled into songs), podcasts, and even poetry as they all have sonic relevance to the current situation at hand.
With the bombing of Pearl Harbor, Japan had essentially declared war with the United States. As a result, President FDR ordered through Executive Order 9066 that Japanese internment camps be established throughout the American West and Mid-West. The policy stated that anybody of Japanese descent (up to 1/16 Japanese) would be relocated to various assembly centers around the United States. A majority of the near 117,000 people forced to leave their homes were American citizens and had very little ties to the Japanese except for the color of their skin and the way they looked. Japanese Americans out of any type of Asian in America had tried incredibly hard to be American. Parents would convince their kids to enjoy the American way of life and to these kids their dreams and aspirations were that of any other American kid. They loved baseball, watching movies, dancing the popular dances, and partaking in the average Tom Sawyer-like activities as well. So when authorities rounded up all of these nisei (2nd generation) Americans, they were really confused as they believed they were as American as anyone else. Children and the elderly were a part of this mass movement as well and with such poor living conditions at the centers, any ill or disabled people were basically sentenced to death.
Once everybody was brought together the government handed out cards asking for their names and birthdays that also asked if they were willing to give up any preexisting Japanese citizenship and if they were fully loyal to the American war effort. Those that said no were deported to Japan and those that said yes had the option to join the military and serve. Those that chose to serve became a part of the most decorated United States Infantry Regiment of all-time. This military regiment made up of almost entirely nisei Japanese Americans was awarded more than 18,000 awards with over half of these awards being Purple Hearts to a regiment of around 14,000 men strong for combat against their parent's motherland. Personally, I feel like this is the truest affirmative answer these Americans could give to the question "are you loyal to your country?"
Once the war ended, many people were allowed to return to their homes however some of the internment camps did not close until nearly two years after the war ended. The internment of the Japanese as a quick scapegoat to "protect America" because of their political powerlessness in America was one of the worst violations of the civil rights of Americans signifying how eager the United States and its people are to jump on the gun to blame people for something they themselves had nothing to do with.
In the 1980's, the Detroit automotive industry was plummeting as Japan's post-economic miracle was steadily growing. Japan's automotive industry was booming as they were making better cars and selling them cheaper to the United States. Because of this, many American employees within Detroit were laid off and began to grow angry at the Japanese for causing them to lose their jobs.
In 1982, Vincent Chin, an industrial draftsman for an automotive company, was with his friends at a strip club celebrating his bachelor party in advance of his wedding when two men came up to him calling him racial slurs telling him "it's because of you little [censored] that we're out of work!" Vincent, who had grown up as a second generation Chinese American, was a fun and energetic guy who studied engineering at the Control Data Institute, but could get heated at times. The three men got into a physical altercation and were consequently kicked out of the bar. They parted ways only for the two men to pay a 3rd man to find where Vincent Chin was headed. They later found him at a nearby McDonalds and where Michael Nitz pinned him to the ground and Ronald Ebens repeatedly beat his head with a baseball bat until it cracked open and Chin was unrecognizable. I heard a slam poem one time and I couldn't find it now, but this line stuck out to me because of how true it was: "and the two used America to beat and wipe away every visual representation of Asia they could see..."
Vincent Chin later died in the hospital without his mother or fiancee knowing. The two men were arrested, tried, and charged guilty of manslaughter in which they had to pay a $3000 fine (equivalent to $8000 today) and had 3 years of probation with no jail time. This case was heavily flawed as it turns out that the jury was all-caucasian and that the police officers who were African American were not even called in to have testimonies and as a result, sparked a massive response from the Asian American community demanding that the two men be charged of murder. Eventually, Ebens would be forced to pay the Chin family $1.5 million dollars to settle what Vincent would have lost in ten years worth of wages and that it could be renewed every ten years.
Overall, this hate crime (which is was later deemed once there were hate crime laws in place) was the result of Anti-Asian racism and Asians were used as a scapegoat during this time to justify workers in the automotive industry being unemployed. This case also reaffirms Asian Americans insecurities that Asian Americans, no matter how many generations born in America, will never be deemed full United States citizens.
On February 4th, 2012 in Madison Square Garden, the New York Knicks were down to the New Jersey Nets when both of New York's role-playing Point Guards were injured and Iman Shumpert fouled out and little-known Jeremy Lin checked in to play. Upon entering the game, he lead the team to an impossible comeback scoring 25 points and providing 7 assists, both career highs for him. He then started the next game and lead the team to another win in what was going to be another horrendous Knicks season. The next five games, he lead the team to five more wins including dominating against John Wall, the supposed best Point Guard in Jeremy's recruiting class, and putting up a career high 38 points against Kobe Bryant. After that, he, once again, shocked the world and had a game winner against Toronto. During the 22 games he played, Jeremy Lin averaged All-Star caliber statistics and had the record for most points scored in their first 5 starts. Jeremy Lin had been so underrated his entire basketball career that this didn't seem feasibly possible. Despite being California's Mr. Basketball and winning the state championship his senior year, he had no Division 1 collegiate offers. He then went on to play at Harvard for no scholarship money and proceeded to get All-Ivy League team honors three times. His pre-draft workouts ranked him within being the 15th best player in the draft and yet he was not drafted by any team. Rockets GM Daryl Morey said blatantly that "Our model said take him with, like, the 15th pick in the draft." A year after the Rockets failed to draft Lin, they began to measure the speed of a player's first two steps; Lin had the quickest first move of any player measured, and he was able to change direction far more quickly than most NBA players. "He's incredibly athletic," said Morey. "But the reality is that every person, including me, thought he was unathletic. And I can't think of any reason for it other than he was Asian." Jeremy Lin despite all of this defied the odds and became the most popular Asian celebrity and a role model to nearly every single Asian American in the United States.
The problem was that nobody knew what to do now that the NBA's star was Asian American. Reporter's would say and write things fully aware of the connotation to various stereotypes and wouldn't be guilty until their viewers complained. ESPN put an article on the front page of their website titled "Chink in the Armor" after a loss to the Charlotte Hornets. Towards the end of Jeremy Lin's battle versus Kobe Bryant Fox Sports columnist Jason Whitlock tweeted "Some lucky lady in NYC is gonna feel a couple inches of pain tonight" while commentators called his game "deceptive" as if it was never there or you couldn't see it further pushing racial stereotypes against Asian Americans. Another commentator said that he "was cooking with some hot peanut oil" after leading the Houston Rockets the following season to a win over the New York Knicks. Madison Square Garden created a graphic of Jeremy Lin popping out of a fortune cookie saying that he was their good fortune for the season. Some of these instances are out of ignorance (such as the ESPN article) and others are purely reporters and writers taking advantage of privilege to belittle someone who is at the top of the world that they didn't want to give credit to.
One sonic work that supports this, however, is a slam poem by G Yamazawa titled "Linsanity" in which he uses Asian stereotypes and imagery to challenge ideas about racism towards Asian Americans in the United States entertainment industry. Some of the most powerful lines are "I'm a hammer in the hands of a Chinese railroad worker/I'm a kamikaze jet running suicides" (Yamazawa. 00:01:42-00:01:48) and "America, now you officially have a chink in your armor/And there will be millions more just like me as long as you are willing to give them a shot" (Yamazawa. 00:02:29-00:2:38).
With COVID-19 shutting down the world, many people are afraid. They want to go outside and live a normal life, but the reality is right now they can't. Many of these people are angry too that their way of life has been altered and they need to blame it on someone, so they blame it on the Asians and Asian Americans who "brought the virus" to this country. The image on the left highlights some of the things that were said to Asian/Asian American people on the streets. Many of these statements utilize stereotypes created because of the coronavirus, with President Trump calling it the "China virus" and generating that stereotype by making it something that is ok to be said mainly because he says it on television.
Many people eye Asian Americans fearfully as if they have the virus and push or kick them away if they are close. Some use whatever is closest to them to beat them away. Many of these cases of hate crimes remain unreported despite there being various places where one can report.
In a YouTube video by USA Today, the speakers highlight how everybody is skeptical of their movements at stores or on public transit and how it has affected their mental health. One of the speakers even said how they were essentially segregated at a restaurant along with other people of Asian descent in a "quarantine" area outside of the main dining area (Eun. 00:01:40-00:02:27).
In efforts to combat COVID-19 related racism towards Asian Americans, many artists, celebrities, politicians, and public speakers have decided to engage in discussion and talk about what is going on instead of shying away from it.
YEAR OF THE OX's music video for their song "VIRAL" was one of the first pieces of media I had seen that challenged racism related to COVID-19. The music video from a visual perspective features a lot of the viral social media posts showing racist altercations between Asians/Asian Americans and their aggressor which showcases that this issue is larger than we thought. The lyrics, however, are dark and blunt. They cover the themes of how nowadays it seems like there are people out to get those in the Asian community and that it has a large effect on the mental health of these people. At the end of the music video, the rapper says that because of all of this bullying that is going on and the toll it has on one's mental health, suicide could be the only option for some of those bullied who are left with no happiness due to not having their social interactions and at the same time being bullied and harassed.
This video is from the NBA YouTube channel which has millions of subscribers. This is a highlight from a "virtual roundtable" that featured NBA Champion Caron Butler, Linsanity star and NBA Champion Jeremy Lin, Vanita Gupta, and ex-Democratic Candidate Andrew Yang as they talk about COVID-19, Jeremy's life playing professionally in China and his campaign to raise money for his #BeTheLight Campaign, and the issue of Asian American racism in the U.S.
Andrew Yang, in this clip, discusses how Asian Americans are now the scapegoat for this crisis per human nature and that he feels that, however, they have been unfairly treated as a result because in the end, they did nothing wrong.
Vanita Gupta also adds that this racism is nothing new and that it did not just appear out of nowhere. She mentions that the first two immigration laws in the U.S. were specifically to bar Chinese Americans from immigrating to the U.S.
Overall, this clip does a great job of helping viewers understand the underlying issues of this COVID-19 related racism, but that America should band together to stop the virus, not to hurt each other.
This short clip from the Associated Press demonstrates the concerns Asian celebrities in the American entertainment industry have for entertainment after COVID-19 ends. With these past few years being remarkable for Asian and Asian American representation in film with the successes of Crazy Rich Asians, Fresh Off the Boat, and Parasite, some of these actors feel that Asians are back at square one in the movie industry.
This is important because Simu Liu just got cast as Marvel superhero Shang Chi in an upcoming Marvel movie where he will be the main character of the film, a first in Marvel history.
Overall, this video poses some great thoughts and questions on the coronavirus' impact on the entertainment industry and whether or not Asians will have to work harder in the future.
This video is not a direct response to COVID-19, but it does bear elements of reacting to Asian American racism and it provides some positive thoughts about how to handle it. G Yamazawa, again, reuses stereotypes in order to create new meanings out of them and to empower Asian Americans in a society that just wants to bring them down.
I thought one of the greatest phrases he said was "8. When they call you Chinese, correct them. 9. Upon correcting them, tell them your full name in your native dialect, remind them of your parents' birthplace, remind them of Hiroshima and Nagasaki until the conversation feels nuclear. Remind them of your ancestors who danced with swords until the choreography was lethal, and then remind yourself that you were only reminding yourself because after the entire conversation you will still be Chinese to them" (Yamazawa. 00:01:33-00:01:57). This phrase represents the American view of Asians. They group them together expecting them to be a homogenous society, but to know that George Washington was British but opposed the British and who Paul Revere was despite being the son of a French immigrant instead of them just being "Europeans." This is relevant to now as everybody wants to call every Asian they see Chinese and fear them because of the coronavirus thus exposing their ignorance.
With all that is going on in the world right now that may be affecting you, it is still important to remain good human beings that have impeccable integrity. The economical and societal impact of COVID-19 has been unprecedented, however, that is not an excuse to act out hatefully or injure others. While mistakes have been made in the recent past, there is still potential for positive change. Kimora Lee Simmons (on the left) declared that you should "call racism out when you see it, hear it, or read about it" as that way you hold people accountable to their actions. The sonic environment with regards to the racism related to COVID-19 was anguished and melancholy with people full of fear and pain, but with the leadership that is present now the sounds of passion and justice are becoming louder by the day. Not just one person can end racism, but they can be a catalyst for change in others.
"Everything begins with one person; change begins with one person; and a path is forged by one person. Waves are set in motion when we meet with one person, speak with that one person and take action together with them."
-- Daisaku Ikeda