Congratulations! You've finished your research project and now you want to publish it! This help guide provides tips, resources, and videos for publishing your work.
First step is to create a shortlist of journals you think might be a good fit. There are a number of considerations and tools to help you! Start with your reference list and re-search the literature. What journals are coming up consistently? Then check each journal website for aims, scope, and author guidelines.
Check out these two free tools too:
JANE (Journal Author Name Estimator) Copy & paste the abstract of your draft manuscript into JANE and it will produce a list of potential journals ranked by relevance. Note: JANE focuses on medical journals so some psychology journals may not be included.
Scimago Journal Rankings Search by journal name or browse by discipline to find journal metrics like impact factor, total citations by year, journal ranking quartiles, and journal ranking by discipline.
Check out the Clinical Psychology list of journals!
Part of creating your shortlist includes verifying the quality and legitimacy of journals. The Open Access (OA) publishing model promotes free, unlimited access to research in turn facilitating global collaboration and increasing author impact. OA journals require a publishing/author fee to publish as they do not profit from expensive subscriptions.
Unfortunately, sham OA journals aka "predatory journals" are rampant. They "exist for the sole purpose of profit, not the dissemination of high-quality research findings and furtherance of knowledge" (Berger & Cirasella, 2015).
These can harm your scholarly reputation, promotion, and institution.
Signs of a Good OA Journal
Indexed in bibliometric databases, such as PsycInfo, PubMed, Web of Science, & the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)
Journal website looks legit & includes:
Editorial board information - member affiliations and emails (geographic location should be very distributed)
Contact information - email, mailing address that goes to a legit location; contact is not just a blank web form
Article review process described including peer-review
No promises of instant or rapid publication
Author fee is transparent and only required after acceptance of an article
To protect yourself and your work, thoroughly check your journal before submitting an article for publication and ask us for help! Check out the criteria above and the two free tools below:
Checklist of questions to help you assess the legitimacy of a journal or book/book chapter publisher. TCS does not provide a bottomline answer, but it helps critically evaluate.
Verify open access journals by searching for the OA journal name and look for the green checkmark to verify the journal has gone through DOAJ’s quality control indexing process
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) Preparing a Manuscript - ICMJE has developed standards in publishing including how to structure & write a paper as well as authorship guidelines.
Elsevier Researcher Academy - A series of online learning modules on the publishing process including research preparation, peer-review, writing for research, and more.
University of Maryland Writing Center - Writing Tips Video Series - series of short, helpful videos on how craft an argument, structure a paper, proofreeding, and editing. Also features time management videos such as how to carve out time for writing and limiting distractions.
Determining authorship and author order is a significant step of the publishing process. According to the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), every author should meet ALL of the following four criteria:
Substantial contributions to the conception, design, data collection, or data analysis
Drafting or revising the manuscript
Approving the final version to submit to a journal
Being accountable for the work should any questions or concerns arise
If all criteria are not met, then it is appropriate to acknowledge those individuals in the Acknowledgements section of your manuscript.
Berger, M., & Cirasella, J. (2015). Beyond Beall’s list: Better understanding predatory publishers. College & Research Libraries News, 76(3), 132-135.