Day 4 Activities

Instructions

Round 1 (pair, 15 minutes)

• pair with one group member for peer feedback on your homework

• While you read: 

  • write next to each sentence what you think is the function of this sentence in the narrative WITHOUT retelling the content of the sentence

• After you read: 

  • answer the following questions (insert a comment balloon in your peer’s document with your answers)

  • what peaked your interest? 

  • what did you push back against?

  • what is the main message you take away from the draft?

Round 2 (team, 10 minutes)

• Share: what did you take away from your peer feedback?

  • what did your peer praise?

  • what will you change in response to the feedback?

Round 3 (all, 10 minutes)

• Reflect: what stood out to you about this round of feedback?

  • was there a suggestion or concern that was given to multiple team members?

  • what did you recommend to each other? what did you notice?

Instructions

Round 1 (5 minutes; in your group)

• • briefly share concerns in your team

  • then share thoughts on your team's slide on the instructor slide deck

    • make sure each article is assigned to at least one reader

Round 2 (10 minutes; all)

• • instructor leads discussion of concerns

Instructions

Round 1 (You, 5 minutes)

• Write down your worries about peer review

  • ONE worry per post-it note

  • create as many post-its as you want

Round 2 (You, 5 minutes)

• Share your worries: post your worries on the sharing wall

  • stick your post-its on the sharing wall of you team

Round 3 (Groups of 3 teams, 15 minutes)

• Categorize your worries: find shared worries

  • cluster related post-its

  • aim for 3 to 6 clusters

Round 4 (All, 10 minutes)

• Share: develop a list of worry types

  • what are common worries?

  • which of those worries do you have control over?

Instructions

• Complete the seven steps in the workbook. Abbreviated instructions below.

• Step 1: check the mission statement and author instructions of your target journal

• Step 2: develop multiple options for your title

• Step 3: draft your abstract

• Step 4: revise your Introduction

• Step 5: revise your Conclusions

• Step 6: check your citations

• Step 7: draft a cover letter

Instructions

• free write for 3 minutes

• pick one or more of the following writing prompts

  • • what from today can you use or implement right away?

    • what would you like to follow up on or learn more about after today?

    • what do you plan to do by our next meeting to work on your paper?

Instructions

• Organize regular meetings. 

• Use one or more of the feedback procedures below to get useful and holistic feedback