Recently, 3 Louisville city metro council members- Nicole George, David James and Pat Mulvihil- proposed changes to the anti-homeless ordinance to fine the homeless for camping on public property. The ordinance, which was first introduced back in 2018, has now been an ongoing process of amending since the middle of September. The original ordinance was made to give rights to homeless individuals camping in public areas not to be removed without a prior warning. The proposed change to the ordinance was argued so that homeless could be fined up to $200 per day for camping in public parks, and up to $1,000 per day for leaving personal items in public areas. The proposed changes were described to help clean the city and have a more appealing look to the public every day. The main concern for these 3 council members has been to minimize the objects left behind everyday in the streets and in neighborhoods. According to an article written by Ana Rocio Alvarez Brinez for the Courier Journal, a statement made from Councilwoman George regarding the ordinance was “We don't want to see a canopy and a La-Z-Boy (recliner) on the sidewalk, right? We don't want to see a barbeque grill on the sidewalk. You don't want to see a motorcycle on the sidewalk, like, chained to the utility pole. We're not talking about someone's housing status ... we're talking about what this looks like from a public access standpoint.” The city has had a range of viewpoints for “restricting access to public space” - as George put it - fellow council members, soup kitchens, and homeless shelters/services believe that to relieve homelessness, “fining them is not the way to go about it”. However, some people who are living in the Downtown Nulu area disagree, specifically parents have expressed their distress for finding needles lying around, and the question of their children's safety for even playing outside. Our school has had issues with the homeless prior to the changes of our entrance to the school. Our Safety Administrator, Curtis Moss, when asked if he believed the ordinance would change the “regulars” hanging out around Peace Park or the school in general, he answered, “No, because if they are homeless they probably will not be able to pay for it. You can't charge people for money they don’t have, it won’t solve the problem.” He explained that the current change in the amount of homeless people around the school is not due to any ordinance, but ultimately the weather, “The homeless use the shelter more during the winter but many don’t want to most of the time.” Moss said they tend to camp outside, but once the temperatures get below 40 degrees Fahrenheit, they tend to go back to shelters. When the weather warms back up, even with our new upgrades and any proposed changes Louisville Metro passes, he doesn’t expect to see any changes. Furthermore, throughout the entire city of Louisville, Councilman Jecorey Arthur explained his goal for the ordinance is to make sure it doesn’t criminalize homelessness, “I’ve been fighting to get rid of any recommendations that would fine people just for trying to survive.” He explained that furthermore, beyond being fined money they might not possess, it then becomes impossible to get services, including housing. “The best way to help people who are homeless is to make sure they have a home.” Arthur explained to solve the city’s homelessness problem, it can’t just be on the city’s local government. “We have been able to get more funding for housing and services, but we need more. We also need the state and federal governments to do more to help us here locally.” He added, “The housing gap in Louisville is so big it would take over $5 billion to close it. We do not have enough money in the city budget to this bit the state and federal governments do.”Councilman Bill Hollinder is in agreement with Councilman Arthur and believed that from the beginning of the ordinance back in 2018, the rights of the homeless are important. He explained that the ordinance originated from an incident that occurred in Portland where belongings that were left in a public area were taken away and thrown in a landfill. “These are people’s only belongings, and they're being thrown away,” Hollander said. As the ordinance has had proposed changes since 2018, he says that the recent changes are “troublesome” because it's talking away from what the ordinance is supposed to stand for. He says that he is opposed to the initial proposal, however, with recent changes he does agree with a small portion. “You can’t impede sidewalks for anyone for any reason.” So as far as not impeding sidewalks, that portion of the ordinance does make sense to him. But overall, to help relieve homelessness, Hollander says more permanent housing or even temporary shelters are necessary and more funds from the americanrescuefunds would be above all helpful. Though changes and improvements have been made, Hollander has looked towards Councilman Arthur's proposal about increasing funds from the federal government. Overall he says, “If we are going to tell people they have to get off the street, we have to have some place for them to go, moving them around from place to place isn’t going to do anyone any good.In agreement with these sentiments, upcoming running Louisville Metro District candidate Andrew Owen expressed his fresh perspective on the ordinance and homelessness by determining that the city needs to address the issues with the utmost compassion. His opinion sways towards keeping the original ordinance, “but I would also like to have a conversation with Nicole George, I know she is a social worker and has had experience working with the homeless” he said. Owen explained that his understanding of the frustration coming from current members seems to stem from the game of “whack a mole” they seem to be playing by removing an encampment and having them pop up a few blocks away. He agrees with Council members Arthur and Hollinder that in order to create new provisions for the ordinance, homelessness needs to be further addressed and more efforts need to be made. Whether it be through Councilman Arthur’s view or a few of his own ideas. Owen expressed that he would like to work with Hope Villages and create more stable housing while offering opportunities and services to help an individual. But Owen truly believes that to make any kind change, it starts with compassion. In turn, there are changes from the initial proposal to fine the homeless, however as a community, everyone should be informed for the future of the homeless because they also call Louisville home.