STEM III Reflection Essay

Overview

Working as an individual, write an essay reflecting on your personal experiences in each of your 1st, 2nd, and 3rd quarter PBLs as they relate to the application of the collaboration, critical thinking, and innovation learning targets.

Note: This essay is not a team essay. It must reflect the individual work and perspectives of the writer rather than a consensus approach of the team. If your team wants to work on a team project, your team should choose the pandemic project.


Unit Plan

STEM III Reflection Essay 2020

Project Rubric - Final Version

This rubric will be used solely to determine the rating for these learning targets:

PBL 4: COLLABORATION 5/15 (100 points)

PBL 4: CRITICAL THINKING + INNOVATION 5/15 (200 points)

STEM III Reflection Essay - Project Rubric

Pacing Guide

STEM III Reflection Essay 2020 - PBL Pacing Guide

Additional Information

Reflective Writing Video

Watch this 6 1/2 minute video to learn how to write an effective reflective essay

https://youtu.be/SntBj0FIApw

Writing an academic reflection

Review this online guide with examples of how to apply the Describe-Interpret-Evaluate-Plan method to writing an academic reflection

https://emedia.rmit.edu.au/learninglab/content/writing-academic-reflection-0

Tips for Using the Describe-Evaluate-Plan (D-I-E-P) Method

Describe

    • Describe the insight

      • An insight is something new that you learned or realised. The insight must be relevant to the course and ideally could change your thinking or behaviour in the future.

    • Describe the circumstances

      • Provide brief and relevant details of the situation from which you gained the insight. Say what was happening when this learning occurred.

Interpret

    • After describing your insight and the circumstances, you need to discuss its meaning. Interpret what the insight means. You can:

      • Explain why the insight is significant (in general but particularly to you).

      • Discuss the questions it raises (in general or for you).

      • Make connections between the insight and the course

      • Discuss factors that influenced your insight such as your personality type, the setting, or environment, your relationships with people involved

      • Discuss the consequences of the insight, how does it change things, does it cause confusion, doubt or deeper understanding about previous knowledge?

      • Whether the insight is valid and logical, transferable or relevant to other situations, a new idea or an evolved understanding

Evaluate

    • Once you have considered the meaning of the insight, you can discuss its value. What relevance does it have? How does it benefit your:

      • Learning?

      • Coursework?

      • future professional development?

Plan

    • Finally, say how you might apply this new insight in the future. You may use the new insight in:

      • your current course, placement or project

      • other courses in your degree

      • your future work or practice

      • your private or professional life in general

    • You may find you need to:

      • set behavioural or learning goals for yourself

      • develop strategies to learn concepts or skills that you are unfamiliar with or find challenging

Tips for Connecting Your PBL Experiences to Learning Targets

Collaboration Learning Target

  • Reflected on the application of the collaboration learning target relating to the STEM Tenet for Juniors:

TIME MANAGEMENT: Manage time for team projects.

  • Addressed topics such as good and bad applications of these skills:

    • Delegating & accepting responsibility, demonstrating leadership

    • Using time effectively

    • Use of SMART tasks and project plans in planning and assigning work

    • Productive or non-productive use of class time

    • Effectiveness of working outside of class time and working independently

    • Effectiveness of integrating work created independently into a team project

    • Monitoring project progress and adjusting plans when needed

    • Following up on incomplete work to stay on track

    • Examples of good and bad risk management (accelerating work and completing deadlines early to reduce risk of unexpected issues late in project)

Innovation Learning Target

  • Reflected on the application of the innovation learning target relating to the STEM Tenet for Juniors:

DESIRABILITY: Create desirable products and solutions.

  • Addressed topics such as good and bad applications of these skills:

    • Application of the design thinking process (e.g., empathy, defining your challenge, ideating, prototyping, testing)

    • Insights from applying empathy (i.e., learning about the audience for whom you are designing)

    • Effectiveness of ideation (i.e., brainstorming and coming up with creative solutions)

    • Effectiveness of testing (i.e., returning to your original user group and testing your ideas for feedback)

    • Actively seeking out and taking creative risks

    • Application of sponsor feedback that positively influenced the approach to your solution

    • Lack of sponsor feedback that negatively impacted the approach to your solution

    • Proactively seeking out early and frequent feedback from diverse perspectives including sponsor, teacher, and fellow students

Critical Thinking Learning Target

  • Reflected on the application of the critical thinking learning target relating to the STEM Tenet for Juniors:

PROTOTYPING: Iterative process, developing and testing multiple solutions.

  • Addressed topics such as good and bad applications of these skills

    • Application of an iterative rapid prototyping process to explore multiple approaches to discover the best solution

    • Fabrication skills and their impact on the prototyping of your solution

    • Building a representation of your ideas to show to others

    • Use of analog and digital fabrication for prototyping

    • Use of digital modeling and simulation (e.g., TinkerCAD for physical and electronic prototyping)

    • Use of small scale prototyping and large scale prototyping

    • Impact of prototyping on final product development