Abstract:
The purpose of this phenomenological study is to identify what students believe is contributing to how “smart” they are and if there is a link between “smartness” and growth mindset discussion in the classroom. At this stage in the research, “smartness” will generally be identified as students who get “correct answers, fast responses, good grades” (Shafer, 2017). This study investigated how students perceived what it means to be “smart,” and noticed if growth mindset was a contributing factor to their responses. As I began pulling together my literature review, I had noticed overarching themes throughout the many sources that I had read and referred to throughout my research. Some overarching ideas discussed throughout the literature would be the discussion of malleability of intelligence, factors within and outside of the classroom that play a role in impacting the mindset of students and different strategies that educators can implement in the classroom everyday to promote growth mindset learning for all students. The research that was done in this phenomenological study yielded interesting results as a majority of participants were not familiar with nor could define growth mindset and how they see it represented in their classrooms. Furthermore, students had generally defined “smartness” as those who are were good at math, stay focused, and participated in classroom discussions. It is ever so important that students understand that we all learn differently, we all learn at different rates and we can achieve anything we set our minds to. Teaching students the power of “yet” and emphasizing that it is okay to not get something right away, but we will get there and we can do it! It is clear from the data collected by the researcher, that growth mindset discussion is lacking in elementary school classrooms and it is affecting how students are not only perceiving themselves, but others around them as learners and how they are internalizing "smartness."
"I haven't failed. I've just found ten thousand ways that don't work."
-Thomas Edison
This is one of my favorite quotes EVER! It shows the power of perseverance and the ability to keep going even when things get hard. Writing this thesis made me aware of how important it is to talk about growth mindset with your students and to teach them that being smart isn't just getting good grades, wearing glasses, or being good at math. Being smart is taking risks, being kind, working hard, and believing in the power of "yet." Learning will never be a one size fits all for students because everyone has a different path and different ways to reach their goals. It doesn't matter how you get there, just as long as you keep going!!
Recommendations for the future!!
Incorporate growth mindset discussions in the classroom as part of your everyday routine!
Educators and administrators should allow themselves to be vulnerable in front of their students and staff. This will send the message that nobody is perfect and we all make mistakes and we can all learn from them!
Always make it a point to explain that mistakes are part of the learning process and should not be viewed negatively!
Schools could implement growth mindset Professional Development days where educators can collaborate and discuss what strategies they are using and if they find it beneficial to their students!
Interesting Data Collected by Researcher!
"Building a classroom culture of growth mindset changes how students approach learning and helps them develop strong work habits that lead to achievement and success."
"When teachers are “protecting” students from failure, they may not develop healthy attitudes towards challenges, risks or mistakes."
"Talk with students about what it takes to learn effectively, such as asking for help and using a variety of study tools and techniques...make explicit your expectations about the amount of time and effort students should be putting into their learning."
To all of the Education Staff at Endicott: I truly would not be the educator I am today without your constant support, guidance, leadership, and unwavering dedication to the field of education.
To my parents: Thank you from the bottom of my heart for giving me the opportunity to go to an amazing college where I could make my dreams come true! I would not be where I am today without you guys!!
To my practicum placement: I wanted to thank my practicum placement for giving me the chance to work in an amazing and collaborative environment where we all worked together and navigated this unprecedented school year together. Getting the opportunity to work in an amazing district for the entirety of my senior year will be something I will always treasure and take with me in any school district I get to work in.