Digital @ The Arts Unit Creative Classes

Best manners

Learn how to speak with confidence in a debate

Student debating resource developed by The Arts Unit

Years 5 to 8 debating

What will I learn?

You will:

  • explore strategies for improving manner

  • reflect on yourself as a speaker

  • improvise with public speaking games

  • develop your persuasive speaking skills.

Before you begin

For the lesson, you will need:

  • a device to watch the videos

  • your debating journal (or paper) and a pen.

For the games, you will need:

  • a stopwatch or timer

  • a buzzer or bell

  • a list of topics (specific suggestions are listed with each activity)*.

*Note: Debating coaches or teachers may want to note these down before the lesson.

  1. Explore

Explore different strategies for improving your speaking skills (or your ‘manner’) so you can feel confident in a debate.

Before we get started, fold or divide a piece of paper into quarters and add the headings as below. Alternatively, use The 3 m's and manner in debating worksheet (DOCX 321KB) below.

Note-taking activity - Best Manners.docx

Watch the 2 videos ‘The 3 m's of debating’ and ‘Tips for improving your manner’ with Tony Davey from The Arts Unit, who will take you through the 3 m's of debating as well as some tips for improving your manner.

As you watch the videos, use the note-taking worksheet to record what information is new to you, what you find interesting, what you already knew and what you don’t quite understand. You should use dot-points when writing your notes.

Hint: It is an important debating skill to be able to take notes as you listen to someone speak. If you are new to note-taking, you can pause the video when you need to.

After watching the videos, discuss your notes with your teacher or coach and your teammates.

  • What was new information for you? Share 1-2 discoveries per person.

  • What did you find most interesting?

  • Is there something Tony said that you don’t quite understand?

As a group, make a list of things that are considered ‘good’ manner, and things that you should avoid doing, or are considered 'poor' manner.

2. Reflect

Reflect on your speaking skills by answering the following questions. Write both the questions and your answers in your debating journal.

Your likes and dislikes

  • Do you enjoy public speaking (speaking in front of others)?

  • What do you like about debating and/or public speaking?

  • What do you find difficult about debating and/or public speaking?

Your strengths and habits

  • What are some of your strengths in public speaking? For example, you may enjoy talking, you might feel confident improvising or you may be good at memorising.

  • Are you aware of any habits you have when you speak in front of people? For example, do you sway, speak quickly or struggle with eye contact?

Your goals

  • What are your goals for public speaking and what would you like to improve? For example, you might want to feel more confident, be louder or improve your eye contact.

  • What could you do to work towards your goal?

3. Improvise

Improve your general public speaking skills by playing the following improvisational games.

A lot of your debating speech (specifically, your rebuttal) will require you to think on your feet and improvise. This means speaking without preparing or writing your speech down beforehand.

Remember, it’s okay to say “um …” or pause in debating! It just shows that you are thinking. Focus on getting your point across and not giving up if you stumble. Let’s have a go with a few improvisational games!

Game 1 – who and where?

Step 1: When it’s your turn, collect a card with a fictional person and public speaking scenario on it.

Some example characters and scenarios:

    • news reporter – reporting on the birth of new animals at the local zoo

    • teacher – teaching shapes to Kindergarten students

    • a new and fairly unknown actor – winning an Academy Award

    • a Prime Minister – giving a press conference about the upcoming election

    • CEO or businessperson – presenting an exciting new product to their stakeholders or business team

    • spruiker at a fair – encouraging people to come and try the food at their stall

    • a used items salesperson – trying to sell an item that doesn’t work anymore to someone over the phone

    • Olympic medallist – giving a press interview right after winning their medal

    • a famous YouTuber – reviewing a new product

    • Australian of the Year – acceptance speech at the awards ceremony.

Step 2: You have 30 seconds of thinking time to mentally prepare for your performance.

Step 3: Stand in front of the group and speak as if you are the fictional character in that scenario. Note: you can’t give it away too easily! For example, you couldn’t say “That’s why I, as a famous actor, am so excited to receive this Academy Award today!” However, you could say “I am just so surprised that I’ve won this prestigious award today for my work in High School Musical 7. What an honour!”.

Step 4: Students have one turn each at guessing your character and the scenario. Reveal the correct answer.

Step 5: Repeat the game until all players have had a turn at performing.

Game 2 – stay on topic!

The aim of the game is to be the person speaking when the buzzer goes off (as a group, choose your time goal – it could be 3 minutes, 5 minutes or 10 minutes).

Step 1: The teacher or the group selects a topic. For a more challenging game, instead of picking an open-ended topic such as ‘sport’, use a debating topic such as ‘Schools should/should not have daily sport lessons’.

Step 2: The first student stands in front of the group and begins to speak about the topic.

Step 3: If the speaker repeats themselves or talks about something not related to the topic they can be ‘challenged’ by another student. To challenge, the student should raise their hand and the stopwatch stops momentarily.

Step 4: The challenger must explain their objection in a factual, respectful manner. If the teacher agrees the challenge is correct, that student takes over as speaker and the stopwatch restarts. This continues until the buzzer or timer goes off.

Step 5: Repeat the game with a different topic and a different starting speaker until everyone has had a turn at speaking.

Game 3 you can’t distract me

Occasionally, a distraction will occur when you are speaking in a debate. The bell might ring, the other team might be whispering loudly or someone in the audience makes a comment. It is important to be able to stay focused.

Practise ignoring distractions by playing this game.

Step 1: Pick a text to be read aloud (a chapter book for example).

Step 2: One student starts off, reading from the book.

Step 3: One by one, the other students get a 5-second window to distract the speaker as they remain seated.

They can do this by whispering, making a funny face or tapping their foot. They cannot get up, move around, yell or do anything too ridiculous. Think about distractions that might occur in a debate and stick to these sorts of things.

Step 4: The speaker stops when the other students have all had a turn at attempting to distract them. If you ‘break’ (for example, you break into laughter or forget what you were saying), just take a breath, focus and try to resume talking as best you can until the end of your turn.

Step 5: Repeat the game until all students have had a turn at speaking.

Game 4 one-minute madness

Step 1: In a team of 4, allocate one job to each person:

  • speaker

  • timer

  • recorder

  • reporter.

Step 2: The teacher will give you an open-ended topic such as ‘school’, ‘happiness’, ‘family’ or ‘being healthy’.

Step 3: The speaker has 30 seconds to quickly jot down some ideas (dot points) about what they could talk about. For example, “Health = education. Need to educate about food, physical activity and mental wellbeing.”

Challenge: if you want to make it harder, try using simple debating topics instead of open-ended topics. For example: ‘School days should be shorter’ or ‘All schools should teach gardening and cooking skills’.

Step 4: The speaker gets up and presents their impromptu speech in front of the group, using only their dot-point palm card. The aim is to speak for at least 1 minute (no more than 2 minutes – you do not want to ramble on).

Step 5: The timer is responsible for timing. They should raise their hand briefly or ring a bell when the speaker reaches 1 minute. They should hold their hand in the air or ring the bell twice if the speaker reaches 2 minutes to indicate that time is up.

Step 6: The timer, recorder and reporter have 45 seconds to discuss what the speaker spoke about, to show they were listening. The recorder quickly writes down some dot points for the reporter about what was said in the speech.

Step 7: The reporter stands up and provides a clear, simple summary of what the speech was about.

Step 8: Rotate roles and repeat the activity until everyone has had a turn at being the speaker.

Challenge: When you become competent at this activity, remove step 3 (the 30 seconds preparation time). Instead, the speaker will have to immediately stand up and begin speaking with no palm cards to refer to!

4. Develop

Develop your skills as debater by practising to speak in a confident, persuasive manner.

The following activities are more focused on debating and speaking persuasively.

Game 5 parachute

Step 1: Together, create a list of some well-known celebrities (enough for each person playing). These should be diverse. For example, there should be people of different ages, genders and occupations included in the list.

Step 2: Each student is randomly allocated a celebrity character (you do not get to pick!)

Step 3: In this game, we imagine that all the characters are on board an aircraft. The aircraft is about to crash but there is only one parachute – therefore only one person gets to theoretically survive! Each student gets 1-2 minutes to explain why they should be the person to get the parachute.

Each student, speaking in character, gets a turn at presenting their case. You must first begin by explaining why the person before you does not deserve the parachute more than you.

Step 4: You then explain why you are the most valuable and deserving person on board and why you should get the parachute. A timer should use a bell or buzzer to let you know when your time is up.

Note: If you were the first speaker, you can’t ‘rebut’ the person before you as no one went before you! Instead, you wait until the end and rebut the final speaker, explaining why they do not deserve the parachute more than you.

Step 5: Continue until everyone has had a turn to speak. If you want an extra challenge, try not to repeat the same reason that someone else has already given!

Game 6 I couldn’t disagree more

Step 1: Students are given an overarching theme by the teacher. For example, it could be ‘health’, ‘the environment’ or ‘education’.

Step 2: Students sit in a circle. Students will take turns speaking, going in a clockwise direction.

Step 3: One student is selected to go first. They make a statement to do with the overarching topic.

For example: “I believe that everyone should have to exercise an hour a day.”

Step 4: The next student responds. They must always disagree with the statement. They begin with “I couldn’t disagree more…”, then explain why they disagree.

For example: “I couldn’t disagree more. Some people have injuries and cannot exercise for 1 hour every day.”

Step 5: Continue on to the next student. They must disagree with the statement made by the previous student. Always start with “I couldn’t disagree more…”

For example: “I couldn’t disagree more, if you have an injury you can always work around it. For example, if you have an injured arm, you could still go walking or do exercise that only uses your legs.”

Step 6: This continues on around the circle, with each student disagreeing with the student before. Continue until you are back to the start.

Although you need to be persuasive, remember that debating is about disagreeing in a logical, respectful manner. You must disagree (or ‘rebut’) using logic and facts and it’s important to explain why you disagree each time. Adding an example is a fantastic way to make your argument stronger.

Game 7 – speed debating

Step 1: Students create 2 concentric circles. The inner circle is the negative team, the outer circle is the affirmative team. Each student should have a partner they are facing from the other circle.

Step 2: The teacher gives the students a debating topic. For example, the topic could be ‘That schools should ban plastic’ or ‘That school days should be shorter’. All students have 5 minutes to write down 3 arguments for their case.

Remember, the negative team disagrees with the topic and the affirmative team agrees with the topic.

Step 3: The affirmative team goes first. Each affirmative team speaker explains their first argument to their partner (all affirmative team members speak at the same time to their partners). They have 1 minute. The buzzer or bell goes when time is up.

Step 4: The negative team can choose to either rebut what the affirmative team member has said or they can say their own argument (they also get 1 minute).

Step 5: The affirmative team then rebuts or gives another argument (1 minute time limit).

Step 6: Students on the outer circle all rotate, moving one spot to their right so they are in front of a new partner.

Step 7: This time, the negative team begins. They have 1 minute to explain an argument that supports their case.

Step 8: The affirmative team rebuts or gives their own argument. Return to the negative speaker for their next argument or rebuttal.

Step 9: The affirmative team rotates again, taking one more step to the right. Start from Step 3 again.

Step 10: Continue until you are back to the partner you started with.

Note: It is okay to repeat arguments or rebuttals throughout the game. It is good if this happens as it will give you more confidence when you get to explain your argument or rebuttal for the second time.

Game 8 – pick a side

Step 1: Students are given a topic (for example ‘That swimming lessons should be compulsory for all students’). Each student decides whether they agree or disagree.

Step 2: If they agree, they sit on one side of the room. If they disagree, they sit on the other. The teacher stands in the middle, halfway between both teams.

Step 3: Students volunteer by raising their hands and giving an argument for why they are correct. If the teacher believes it is a strong argument for their case, they will take one step towards that team. They can take a big step or regular step depending on the level of persuasiveness. Hint: try to give examples to add emphasis to your argument.

Step 4: A student from the other team then gets a turn. They can choose to either rebut (say why a previous argument was incorrect, irrelevant or inaccurate) or state their own argument. Again, if the teacher believes it is persuasive, they take a step back towards that team.

Step 5: The game ends when each speaker has had a turn at speaking. See which team the teacher has ended up closer to! Often, the teacher will be somewhere near the middle if both teams have been very persuasive.

If the teams are different sizes (for example 4 students on one team and 2 on another), each team gets an equal amount of turns (in that example it would be 4 turns per team). Therefore, if you are on the smaller team, you might have to speak more than once!

Tricky challenge: The teacher, at any time, may choose to reverse your decision. For example, the teacher might decide that all the students who sat on the ‘agree’ side have to instead disagree with the topic and vice versa. This is good practice as you don’t get to choose which side you are on in a debate!

Reflect on your progress

After a few weeks of debating training or after you have completed a few different activities, return to your reflection from part 2 of this lesson.

Consider whether you feel more confident speaking and whether you have made progress towards your goals. You may like to update your goals or write about your progress.

Remember, improving your manner is all about practice. Take every opportunity you can to speak in front of others! It might be a bit scary to start with, but it will get easier with time.

If you are interested in watching a debate, you might like to view the NSW Premier’s Debating Challenge 2018 - Years 5 and 6 State Final or the NSW Premier’s Debating Challenge 2018 - Years 7 and 8 State Final.

NSW Premier’s Debating Challenge 2018 - Years 5 and 6 State Final

Duration: 40:34

NSW Premier’s Debating Challenge 2018 - Years 7 and 8 State Final

Duration: 52:41


To continue learning about debating and develop your skills, you might like to complete these other debating Digital @ The Arts Unit Creative Classes:


Marvellous mechanisms - Years 5 to 8 debating
Best manners - Years 5 - 8 debating - Learn how to speak with confidence in a debate.
Crafting persuasive arguments - Years 5 and 6 debating.
Ready, prep, debate! - Years 5 to 8 debating.
Characterisation in debates - Years 5 to 8 debating.
Deep diving into definitions - Years 5 to 8 debating.
Roles and rules of debating - Years 5 and 6 debating
Considering responsibility in debates - Years 5 to 8 debating.
Discovering definitions - Years 5 and 6 debating.
That's debatable! - Year 5 and 6 debating.

Congratulations!

You have completed this Digital @ The Arts Unit Creative Class.

Third-party content attributions