Vaccination Mandates

California Mandate

To combat surging cases and hospitalizations, California will now require some healthcare workers to get vaccinated or receive regular COVID-19 testing at least once per week. The California Department of Public Health has released guidance that describes the new requirements in detail.


According to the governor’s office, optometry offices are not required to follow this guidance but are strongly encouraged to do so. If staff is required to get tested, the employer is responsible for the cost.


Optometrists can choose to mandate the vaccine for all staff in their own practices even if California doesn’t require it. Both the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the State Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) have issued guidelines supporting mandatory vaccination policies in the workplace, subject to medical and religious limitations.


Medicare Mandate

Optometrists are exempt from the federal mandate that all Medicare providers be vaccinated if you have less than 100 employees and provide patient care out of a physician's office instead of a hospital, clinic or other health care facility.


Patient questions

My patient informed me he received the COVID-19 vaccine. Do I still need to implement the same precautions as I do for other patients without the vaccine?

Yes. Until further notice, it is important that you maintain the same COVID-19 prevention precautions in the practice consistently among all patients. According to the CDC, experts need to understand more about the protection that COVID-19 vaccines provide before deciding to change recommendations on steps everyone should take to slow the spread of the virus that causes COVID-19. Researchers are still conducting studies on how long the vaccine is efficacious for, and whether booster vaccines are necessary. Other factors, including when the vaccine was received, whether the patient has received the second dose, how many people become vaccinated and how the virus is spreading in communities, will also affect this decision.

My patient asked if I’m requiring all employees of the practice to receive the vaccine. The patient doesn’t want treatment until all employees receive the vaccine. What should I tell this patient?

As the employer, it is important that you protect and keep your employees’ health and health status information confidential, therefore, disclosing whether your employees have or will receive the vaccine is not information you can, nor should share with patients.

 

A sample response to the patient who asks this question is, “Employee health and medical information is protected by the right to privacy, but please be assured that our optometric practice is continuing to do all it can to ensure patient safety." Further, explain to the patient the protections (such as PPE, staggering of patient appointments, patient and employee daily screenings, social distancing and additional patient barriers) your practice has put in place to mitigate COVID-19 exposure and keep patients safe.

Employee questions

If all of my employees are vaccinated, do I still have to implement the extra COVID-19 precautions (i.e., N95/face shield/HEPA filters/staggered lunch breaks)?

Yes. Even with vaccinated employees, or patients, existing COVID-19 prevention precautions remain necessary until further notice. Cal/OSHA requirements remain in place regardless of the vaccine.

Should I make the vaccine mandatory for my employees?

Employers in health care settings have the right to establish legitimate health and safety standards, policies, and requirements so long as they are job-related and consistent with business necessity. 


Optometrists can choose to mandate the vaccine for all staff in their own practices even if California doesn’t require it. Both the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the State Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) have issued guidelines supporting mandatory vaccination policies in the workplace, subject to medical and religious limitations.

 

If employers feel strongly about requiring employees to be vaccinated, COA recommends speaking with an employment law attorney before implementing a mandatory policy.

What circumstances would allow for an employee exemption from vaccination?

Employees may be exempt from compliance with a mandatory vaccination policy if they have a sincerely held religious objection or a qualifying disability under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) that prevents them from safely receiving the vaccine. Specific to the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines, this includes factors such as whether the employee is pregnant, nursing, is allergic to ingredients of the vaccine, or has a compromised immune system.

 

Upon receiving a request to be excluded from a vaccination requirement as an accommodation, whether due to disability or religious-related reasons, an employer must engage in an interactive process with the objecting employee to determine if they can provide the employee with a reasonable accommodation that does not pose an undue hardship for the employer.

Do I need to pay my employees for their time and costs associated with receiving the COVID-19 vaccine?

Voluntary policies do not require an employer to pay employee costs associated with the vaccine or time obtaining the vaccine. Most health insurers are covering the cost of the vaccine. However, employers who encourage employees to obtain the vaccine may consider reimbursement of costs (when applicable) and compensation of time to obtain it in order to remove any barriers for employees who may be reluctant to receive the vaccine. If you require employees to obtain the vaccine, then you are required to compensate your employees for their time and costs not covered by their health insurance associated with obtaining the vaccine.

What is an employer’s legal exposure if an employee refuses to be vaccinated?

Currently, there is no law that requires employers to vaccinate all employees with the COVID-19 vaccine. It is still too early to fully provide a legal liability response. Theoretically, it may be possible that, in the future, failure to provide or offer the vaccine to employees could be a workplace safety violation – but this is purely speculation.

 

At this time, we are recommending that employers strongly encourage employees to obtain the COVID vaccine. Employers who decide to mandate the vaccine for all employees must consider reasonable accommodations for any employee requests not to be vaccinated due to a disability, medical contraindications or sincerely held religious beliefs.

 

It is possible that an employer may never have 100% of their employees vaccinated. Having a fully vaccinated staff does not completely reduce an employer’s liability or obligations to maintain workplace safety standards.

Can I have my employee, who refuses the vaccine, sign a waiver to release my liability if that employee transmits COVID-19 to a patient or another employee?

A waiver signed by an employee who refuses the vaccine may not provide an employer with liability protection from patients or other employees. Continue to follow standard COVID-19 prevention precautions regardless of employee vaccinations until further notice.

I’ve heard many people feel sick for several days after receiving the vaccine. Will my employees need sick time off following the vaccine? Do I pay them for the time off? Do they qualify for the COVID-19 FFCRA paid time off?

First, COA recommends staggering the distribution of the vaccine among the optometric team in the event that team members experience adverse reactions within the same window of time. Consider asking your front office team to stagger the days in which they receive the vaccine and the same for your back office team. This will help the practice maintain staff coverage. Employees who request time off due to the vaccine side effects may request to use any available employer provided paid sick leave or vacation time, if approved by the employer.

 

Any reactions to the COVID-19 vaccine must be reported to the employee’s medical care provider, or to local public health department if the individual does not have a medical care provider.

 

In the event that an employee experiences long-term health effects and requires a leave of absence, as of Jan 1, 2021, employers with five or more employees must provide up to 12 weeks of unpaid time off to eligible employees under the California Family Rights Act (CFRA).

 

Illness as a result of the COVID-19 vaccine is not a qualifying reason to provide emergency paid sick leave through the Families First Coronavirus Relief Act (FFCRA expired 12/31/2020)

 

Finally, an employer may consider offering additional paid sick time to all employees as a means to encourage employees to receive the vaccine and eliminate concern over missing work unpaid.

DISCLAIMER: Please note that the information and any suggestions contained in this resource represent the experience and opinions of COA. This communication does not constitute and should not be considered a substitute for legal, financial or other advice provided by licensed professionals. For that, you must consult your own attorney, accountant or other professional advisor.