DAY ONE

S. Pete Worden

Welcome and Introduction

Scientific space missions have historically been dominated by governments and industrial contractors invested in building bespoke, highly capable systems that are typically large and expensive. For years, launch vehicles saw little innovation and launch costs remained extremely high, limiting new ideas and wider access to space. Even ground-based telescope costs have increased exponentially with aperture size. But today, technological advances and business revolutions are shaking up the old ways of doing science-on Earth and beyond. Low-cost small satellites, high-performance consumer electronics, innovations in optics and materials, progress in life sciences, and the plummeting cost of launches are revitalizing space activities. Non-profits, universities and startup companies now compete and collaborate with governments on innovative space exploration projects.

Simon Peter “Pete” Worden, (Brig. Gen., USAF, Ret., PhD) is the Chairman of the Breakthrough Prize Foundation and Executive Director of the foundation’s Breakthrough Initiatives. He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Physics and Astronomy from the University of Michigan and a PhD in Astronomy from the University of Arizona. Prior to joining the Breakthrough Prize Foundation, Worden was Director of NASA’s Ames Research Center at Moffett Field, California until his retirement on March 31, 2015. He has held several positions in the United States Air Force and was research professor of astronomy at the University of Arizona, Tucson, USA. He is a recognized expert on space and science issues, both civil and military, and has been a leader in building partnerships between governments and the private sector internationally.

SESSION ONE:

A Bigger Bang for Your Buck
Affordable and innovative concepts for cosmological measurement


Co-Chair: Suzanne Staggs

Princeton University

Suzanne Staggs is the Henry deWolf Smyth Professor of Physics at Princeton University. She is an experimentalist, with a focus on making and interpreting measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) to inform our understanding of cosmology and particle physics. One of the particular interests of her lab is the development of ever-more-sensitive densely-populated detector modules and associated cryogenic readout components. She is the current director of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the current Spokesperson of the Simons Observatory.

Co-Chair: Phil Mauskopf

Arizona State University

Philip Mauskopf is a Professor with a joint appointment at Arizona State University in the School of Earth and Space Exploration and the Department of Physics. His work involves development of new technologies for experimental cosmology and astrophysics as well as design and integration of new types of instruments for measuring signals from the most distant objects in the universe. This research includes development of new types of quantum limited photon detectors, optical elements and readout electronics and has applications in solid state physics, atmospheric science and quantum communications and cryoptography. Prof. Mauskopf has developed detectors and optics that have been deployed on space-based, balloon-borne and ground-based telescopes.

Shirley Ho

Flatiron Institute


Using Artificial Intelligence to Discover New Rules of Our Universe

Shirley Ho joined the NYU Physics Department as Research Professor and as an Affiliated Faculty at Center for Data Science at NYU in 2021. Ho joined Simons Foundation in 2018 as leader of the Cosmology X Data Science group at CCA and in 2021, she assumed the role of CCA’s interim director. Her research interests have ranged from fundamental cosmological measurements to exoplanet statistics to using machine learning to estimate how much dark matter is in the universe. Ho has broad expertise in theory, observation and data science. Ho’s recent interest has been on understanding and developing novel tools in statistics and machine learning techniques, and applying them to astrophysical challenges. Her goal is to understand the universe’s beginning, evolution and its ultimate fate. In her bidding to understand our Universe, Ho plans, builds and analyzes data from a number of astronomical surveys such as Actacama Cosmology Telescope, Euclid, the Rubin Observatory, Simons Observatory, Sloan Digital Sky Survey and the Roman Space Telescope.
Ho earned her Ph.D. in astrophysical sciences from Princeton University in 2008 and her bachelor’s degrees in computer science and physics from the University of California, Berkeley in 2004. She was a Chamberlain fellow and a Seaborg fellow at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory before joining Carnegie Mellon University in 2011 as an assistant professor. She became the Cooper Siegel Career Development Chair Professor and was appointed associate professor with tenure in 2016. She moved to Lawrence Berkeley Lab as a Senior Scientist in 2016.
Since 2011, she has been a primary mentor to more than 35 postdoctoral fellows, 10 graduate students and 20 undergraduates in the fields of astrophysics, computer science and statistics. She has received several awards including NASA Group Achievement Award, Macronix Prize and Carnegie Science Award. She is also elected a Fellow by the International Astrostatistics Association.

Maura McLaughlin

West Virginia University


Pulsar Timing Arrays See Red!

The NANOGrav collaboration monitors an array of about 80 rapidly rotating millisecond pulsars in order to detect perturbations due to nanohertz-frequency gravitational waves resulting from supermassive black hole binaries at the cores of galaxy mergers. NANOGrav’s most recent analysis revealed a common spectral process in the data consistent with a stochastic gravitational-wave background. Significant gains in sensitivity from additional data, discoveries of millisecond pulsars, more sensitive telescopes and instrumentation, and international collaboration are soon expected to enable the conclusive detection of the stochastic background, followed by multi-messenger detection and study of individual nanohertz gravitational-wave sources.


Maura McLaughlin is the Eberly Distinguished Professor of Physics and Astronomy at West Virginia University (WVU) and Director of the Center for Gravitational Waves and Cosmology at WVU. She is Co-Director of the NANOGrav Physics Frontiers Center, which aims to detect gravitational waves using high-precision timing observations of millisecond pulsars with the world's largest radio telescopes. She was the recipient of the Research Corporation’s Cottrell Scholar Award and an Alfred P. Sloan Fellowship. She is also the co-founder and co-director of the NSF-funded Pulsar Search Collaboratory program, which has involved over 2000 high-school students in pulsar searches using the Green Bank Telescope.

Suzanne Staggs

Princeton University


Recording the Evolution of the Universe with the Cosmic Microwave Background

From study of its remnant radiation, we comprehend more about the primordial universe than one might have guessed possible. Knowledge of the present-day universe gives hindsight for modeling the early universe and its dynamics, and measurements of the remnants (called the cosmic microwave background or CMB) provide initial conditions for models. Three powerful space missions have already probed the CMB, and yet there is more to learn from new studies. To compete with the powerful data sets provided from major space missions requires years of observations from bespoke arrays of many thousands of detectors cooled to 100 mK, deployed on special-purpose telescopes in remote and arid sites. With those, however, we can address questions of high energy physics that the biggest accelerators cannot, while also refining our picture of the contents of the more nearby universe and its ongoing evolution.

Suzanne Staggs is the Henry deWolf Smyth Professor of Physics at Princeton University. She is an experimentalist, with a focus on making and interpreting measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) to inform our understanding of cosmology and particle physics. One of the particular interests of her lab is the development of ever-more-sensitive densely-populated detector modules and associated cryogenic readout components. She is the current director of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the current Spokesperson of the Simons Observatory

Ritoban Basu Thakur

Caltech


Origins of our Universe: The Earliest Achievable Glimpses

Some of the oldest questions asked by humanity continue to be answered today. How did the universe begin and what is its evolution? Are there simple elements and rules that can explain all that is observed? I will showcase how we are trying to answer these questions with experimental methods. This talk will focus on our current endeavors in using telescopes to understand the processes behind the Big-Bang. I will then address how we can peer back in cosmic time to understand the universe’s evolution. In both contexts, I will discuss how the so-called “first light” or the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) enables this manner of scientific inquiry. This is an active field where new technology is continuously being developed and deployed to make high sensitivity measurements of weak cosmological signals. I will touch on the suite of current and future-looking experiments that aim to answer the questions about the origin of the universe, and the growth of structure. I will touch on how technological cross-pollination between CMB science and quantum materials can accelerate potential discoveries.


Ritoban Basu Thakur’s main research is in using the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) to understand origins of our universe. He also develops quantum sensors for studies of the dark sector which forms the bulk of our universe. Basu Thakur was born in Kolkata, India and completed his B.S. in Physics at Dickinson College. He earned his PhD from the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign with a URA/DOE fellowship. His thesis research pioneered a low-mass dark matter search experiment (CDMSlite) combing techniques from particle and condensed-matter physics. For this, he won the Felix T. Adler award in nuclear physics. Thereafter he was a Kavli-fellow at U. Chicago, developing submillimeter instruments for measuring the CMB. Basu Thakur is now at Caltech leading efforts on experimental probes of inflationary cosmology with the BICEP-Keck collaboration and is a CMB-Stage 4 governing board member. Supported by NASA, his team is also developing cutting-edge superconducting on-chip interferometers. These new devices will enable measurements of CMB spectral distortions as probes of early universe physics. With such devices, Basu Thakur and colleagues are also pursuing research applications in spectral line intensity mapping and quantum sensing.

Andrea Gallo Rosso

Stockholm University


Hunting ADxions with Metamaterials: the ALPHA Detector

The nature and origin of dark matter continues to baffle physicists. Due to its ghost-like nature we can only infer its existence from its indirect effects on a large scale in the universe around us. Axions make an ideal candidate. They were hypothesized to solve another cosmological puzzle: the fact that the Strong nuclear force seems to be the same regardless of in what direction time flows. Like feeding two cats with one bowl, if axions exist they also turn out to naturally make up the dark matter, permeating the universe as an invisible wave. In recent years, the efforts to build a kind of radio that would tune to this unique frequency has intensified, with conventional techniques failing to look for high frequencies. By arranging materials macroscopically in a clever fashion (so called metamaterials) to engineer a custom plasma, the Axion Longitudinal Plasma Haloscope (ALPHA) will allow for some of the best motivated and most difficult frequencies to be scanned, potentially revealing the nature of dark matter.

Andrea Gallo Rosso (yep, two last names) is an astroparticle physicist. That is, he is fascinated by the story that tiny particles can tell about the Universe and the massive stuff it contains. Theorist by birth, phenomenologist by adoption, his research interests go from supernova neutrinos to dark matter. He strongly believes in the cross-fertilization of the sciences. He is a member of ALPHA and XENON collaborations for direct dark matter search, to which he mainly contributes through statistical inference and data analysis techniques. He currently holds a postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Stockholm.

Sean Bryan

Arizona State University


High Impact, Low Cost: Cosmology with Balloons and Small Spacecraft

Small space missions consistently have an outsized impact on our knowledge of cosmology, the early universe, and astrophysics. In this talk, I will discuss how a focus on the science, targeted development of new technology, and a closely-integrated positive team environment, came together to lead to success in the NASA BOOMERanG, Spider, and WMAP mission teams. This same approach forms the foundation of the NASA SPHEREx mission currently working towards launch in 2025. SPHEREx observes the entire near-infrared sky in 102 spectral colors, yielding an unparalleled legacy dataset. The mission precisely measures the 3D distribution of galaxies to probe the physics of cosmic inflation in the early universe. At Arizona State University, we are writing the survey planning software to optimally schedule the observatory to improve operational efficiency. I will conclude by discussing several emerging mission concepts that benefit from applying the common approach developed across all of these recent small space missions.


Sean Bryan is an Associate Research Professor at the School of Earth and Space Exploration at Arizona State University where he leads the SENSE laboratory to develop novel systems and algorithms for remote sensing, wireless communications, and astronomy. For his PhD at Case Western Reserve University, he worked on the Spider telescope array which successfully flew in a NASA high-altitude balloon mission over Antarctica. Currently, Bryan is the PI of the NASA CubeSounder high-altitude balloon mission that aims to map the 3D distribution of water vapor and air temperature to improve weather forecasting. He is also the survey planning software lead on the NASA SPHEREx infrared astronomy satellite mission.

SESSION TWO:

Low-Mass Transit
Light, fast and cheap ways to explore the Solar System and beyond

Co-Chair: Slava Turyshev
NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory

Slava G. Turyshev is an astrophysicist at the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology and a professor at the Physics and Astronomy Department of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA). Turyshev earned his PhD in astrophysics from the Moscow State University in 1990. His primary research areas include gravitational physics, research in relativistic astrophysics, astronomy, and planetary science. He is an expert in high-precision spacecraft navigation, solar system dynamics, lunar laser ranging, and related technology efforts. Turyshev served as the NASA Project Scientist on the CNES/ESA Microscope mission (2016-2020); JPL Project Scientist for the Advanced Lunar Laser Ranging Facility at the Table Mountain Observatory, CA (2015-ongoing); Principal Investigator on the investigation of the Pioneer Anomaly (2003-2012). Currently, he is the Principal Investigator on the 2020 NIAC Phase III effort investigating the use the solar gravitation lens for multipixel imaging and spectroscopy of exoplanets. He has published over 250 papers, 2 books. In 2020 Turyshev was elected a member of the International Academy of Astronautics.

Co-Chair: Amanda Hendrix

Planetary Science Institute

Amanda R. Hendrix is a Senior Scientist with the Planetary Science Institute, based in Boulder. She worked for twelve years at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory and was the Deputy Project Scientist for the Cassini–Huygens mission. She has been a scientific investigator on the Cassini, Galileo and Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter missions and a principal investigator on NASA research and Hubble Space Telescope observing programs. Her science focus is on moons in the solar system, including Earth’s moon and those of Jupiter and Saturn, their composition and evolution. Hendrix chaired NASA’s Roadmaps to Ocean Worlds study, is co-chair of the National Academies Committee on Planetary Protection and served as chair of the American Astronomical Society’s Division for Planetary Sciences. She is the director of NASA’s Toolbox for Research and Exploration (TREX). She co-authored Beyond Earth: Our Path to a new Home in the Planets, published by Penguin/Random house in Nov 2016. Hendrix received a B.S. in Aeronautical Engineering from Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo and an M.S. and Ph.D. in Aerospace Engineering Sciences from the University of Colorado Boulder. She is the namesake of Asteroid 6813 Amandahendrix.

Mahmouda Sultana

NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center


ScienceCraft for Outer Planet Exploration

Missions to the outer planets are an important part of NASA's goals as they will enable us to better understand the formation and evolution of our solar system. However, outer solar system exploration has been quite limited in our sixty years of space exploration due to the high cost, long travel time and narrow window for mission implementation. Solar sails may offer a drastically new approach for deep space exploration paving the way to low cost and fast-transit missions. Nevertheless, owing to very stringent mass requirement, solar sails have limited capability for science payloads when compared to a flagship class mission spacecraft. We are developing a mission concept using ScienceCraft, which integrates a science instrument and spacecraft into one monolithic and lightweight structure, to address the mass constraints of typical solar sails. By printing an innovative spectrometer based on quantum dots directly on the solar sail material, we create a breakthrough spacecraft architecture allowing an unprecedented parallelism and throughput of data collection, and rapid travel across the solar system. Unlike conventional solar sails that serve only to propel small cubesats, ScienceCraft puts its vast area at use for spectroscopy, pushing the boundary of scientific exploration of outer solar system.

Mahmooda Sultana is an instrument scientist at the Planetary Environments Lab at NASA Goddard Spaceflight Center. She received her PhD in Chemical Engineering from Massachusetts Institute of Technology and BSc in Chemical Engineering from the University of Southern California with Summa Cum Laude. She joined the Detector Systems Branch at NASA Goddard Space Flight Center in 2010, where she worked in the Detector Development Laboratory (DDL) to develop advanced semiconductor devices, including x-ray detectors, Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems (MEMS) and the Microshutter Array for the James Webb Space Telescope. Mahmooda joined the Instrument Systems Engineering Branch as the Associate Branch Head in 2017 and worked on several instrument and mission concept development efforts as an Instrument Systems Engineer, along with managing the branch. In addition, she has been leading the development of multiple nanomaterial-based instruments as the PI, including a Multifunctional Nanosensor Platform funded by the Early Career Initiative (ECI) at STMD and the Polaris program at HEOMD, and Quantum Dot-based Multispectral Imager funded by the ROSES program at SMD. In 2021, she joined the planetary environments laboratory as an instrument scientist. Some of her awards include 2021 Innovation Award from STMD, 2017 GSFC IRAD Innovator of the Year, 2021 ETD Craig R. Tooley award, 2019 Robert H. Goddard award for technical excellence, 2018 Robert H. Goddard team award, NASA Early Career Achievement Medal, ISTD New Achiever Medal, Bell Laboratories research fellowship, and WmC and Margaret H Rousseau fellowship at MIT and NSF graduate research fellowship.

Tom Pike

Imperial College London


Seismology from Hard Landings

Tom is usually working on the development of microinstruments for space and terrestrial applications, and data analysis of their outputs. He currently has several projects:

  • Development of silicon microseismometers for Mars and elsewhere in the solar system. These sensors are now operating on the surface of Mars on NASA's InSight mission

  • Analysing the seismic data returned from InSight

  • Developing gravity sensing for the Earth

Tom has lectured on Advanced Devices to second-year students, as well as tutor and demonstrate in the practical classes. He is happy to supervise PhDs in these and related projects, and currently has funded PhD studentships available for UK/EU applicants


Francis Nimmo

UC Santa Cruz


Probing the Structure & Evolution of Outer Solar System Bodies with Small, Fast Spacecraft

As described in the 2022 Planetary Decadal Survey, the outer Solar System contains a wealth of fascinating targets. The main drawback to exploring these worlds is the long transit time (~decades), often combined with restrictions imposed by the need to use a Jupiter gravity assist. Small fast sailcraft could solve the transit time problem, opening up a plethora of possibilities. I will discuss four examples of the science which could be enabled by fast flybys: the successful New Horizons flyby of Pluto; a Triton flyby; a combined Uranian moon and Kuiper belt flyby mission; and a comet/interplanetary interceptor. I will also discuss the implementation challenges imposed by mass and spacecraft velocity constraints.


Francis Nimmo's research covers the interiors and evolution of solid planetary bodies. He received his BA in 1993 and his PhD in 1996, both from Cambridge University, and joined the faculty at UCSC in 2005. He was awarded the Urey Prize and Macelwane medal in 2007, and elected to the National Academy of Sciences in 2020. He has participated in the Cassini, New Horizons, GRAIL and InSight spacecraft missions, and is on three Europa Clipper instrument teams. He served on the Steering Committee for the 2022 Planetary Science and Astrobiology Decadal Survey.

Konstantin Batygin

Caltech


Looking for Planet Nine from Outer Space

Over the course of the past two decades, observational surveys have unveiled the intricate orbital structure of the Kuiper Belt, a field of icy bodies orbiting the Sun beyond Neptune. In addition to a host of readily-predictable orbital behavior, the emerging census of trans-Neptunian objects appears to display dynamical phenomena that cannot be explained by interactions with the known eight-planet Solar System alone. Specifically, the observed physical clustering of orbits with semi-major axes in excess of ∼ 250 AU, the detachment of perihelia of select Kuiper belt objects from Neptune, as well as the dynamical origin of highly inclined/retrograde long-period orbits remain elusive within the context of the classical view of the Solar System. This newly outlined dynamical architecture of the distant solar system points to the existence of planet with mass M9 ∼ 5M⊕ on a moderately inclined orbit with a semi-major axis a9 ∼ 400−800 AU and eccentricity e9 ∼0.4−0.6. In this talk, I will review the observational motivation, dynamical constraints, and prospects for detection of this proposed object known as Planet Nine.


Konstantin Batygin received his bachelor’s degree in physics from University of California, Santa Cruz in 2008, before pursuing graduate studies in Planetary Science at Caltech and receiving a Ph.D. in 2012. Batygin's research is primarily aimed at understanding the formation and evolution of planetary systems, including our own. Prior to joining the faculty at California Institute of Technology in 2014, Batygin was a postdoctoral scholar at Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur in Nice, France, and Harvard University.

Penelope Boston


Are We There Yet?

Can We Biomap the Solar System with Low-Cost Solar Sail Missions?

Much of our space exploration efforts are devoted to one-off missions with major investments in each. This is a great strategy for early investigations of clearly significant planetary and small body destinations, but we have an entire Solar System to interrogate and the pace has definitely been slow to date. We are in the dawning era of much smaller spacecraft, and the potential to gather data from multiple destinations over longer time spans with a heightened cadence of missions to allow us to conduct survey-style investigations of the vast number of objects that attend our particular star. If we think of solar systems as belonging to one of two classes, i.e. life-bearing or not life-bearing, then the presence of some sort of biological or prebiological phenomenon on any individual body in a system places that system in the first category. The emergence of life can then be considered as a solar system-wide property and the entire suite of ingredients and processes that go into kindling of life anywhere within that system is of interest. This ranges from bodies with prebiotic chemistry through to full-blown biospheres. Thus, all bodies in a solar system are part of the milieu within which life occurs. Can the idea of low-cost solar sail-propelled spacecraft deployed en masse be useful for something as hard to investigate as life-like phenomena and their precursors? Perhaps, the answer is yes, and we must give serious attention to the possibilities.

DPenelope Boston is currently Associate Director for Science Business Development (Code S, Science) at NASA Ames Research Center, in the Silicon Valley area of California helping to develop research and missions concepts. Research areas include geomicrobiology and astrobiology in extreme environments (caves and mines, hot and cold deserts, high latitudes and altitudes); geological processes creating caves on other planets; human life support issues in space/planetary environments; and use of robotics and other technologies to assist exploration and science in extreme Earth and extraterrestrial environments. Boston is author of 250+ technical and popular publications, editor of 4 volumes, and her work has featured in ~300+ print and broadcast media outlets. Formerly, Boston served as Director of the NASA Astrobiology Institute (NAI, 2016-2019), and she was Professor and Department Chair of the Earth and Environmental Sciences Dept. at the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology as well as Associate Director of the National Cave and Karst Research Institute (2002-2016). She is a poet, artist, animal adorer, and friendly.

Sarah Gibson

National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR)


Beyond Flatland: A Star of Many Dimensions

The more we learn about the Sun, the more we can appreciate its essential complexity. Telescopes have taught us it is not an unblemished sphere. Multi-wavelength observations reveal its structured atmosphere, and ever-higher temporal and spatial resolutions expose its spectacular dynamics. Helioseismology penetrates its depths, and STEREO and Solar Orbiter views from off the Sun-Earth line yield the beginnings of a three-dimensional perspective. But what will we see when we finally leave our ecliptic bias behind and view the Sun from high latitudes? A continuous solar polar view could resolve outstanding questions about the solar dynamo and global heliosphere, and reveal the structure and dynamic evolution of essentially all Earth- and planet-directed space weather in the ecliptic plane. This talk will describe the compelling solar polar science that could be done with high-latitude trajectories, and consider how 4-pi coverage might be achieved through instrument miniaturization and constellations or swarms of satellites.

Sarah Gibson is presently a scientist at the High Altitude Observatory (HAO) at the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) in Boulder, Colorado. Her primary interest is in the magnetic structure and dynamic evolution of coronal mass ejections (CMEs), and she uses theoretical CME models to explain a wide variety of space- and ground-based observations of CMEs from pre-eruption, through initiation and eruption, to their post-eruption state. Gibson is also a leader of the Whole Heliosphere international coordinated observing and modeling efforts to characterize the three-dimensional, interconnected solar-heliospheric-planetary system at solar minimum. Gibson was the recipient of the AAS-SPD 2005 Karen Harvey Prize. She obtained her Ph.D. in astrophysics from the University of Colorado, Boulder. She served on the NRC Committee for a Decadal Strategy for Solar and Space Physics, the Committee on Distributed Arrays of Small Instruments for Research and Monitoring in Solar-Terrestrial Physics: A Workshop and the Astro2010 Panel on Radio, Millimeter, and Submillimeter from the Ground, and was co-chair of the Committee on Solar and Space Physics (National Academy of Sciences).

DAY 2

KEYNOTE:

Tom Kalil

Schmidt Futures

Tom Kalil is Chief Innovation Officer at Schmidt Futures. In this role, Tom leads initiatives to harness technology for societal challenges, improve science policy, and identify and pursue 21st century moonshots. Prior to Schmidt Futures, Tom served in the White House for two Presidents (Obama and Clinton), helping to design and launch national science and technology initiatives in areas such as nanotechnology, the BRAIN initiative, data science, materials by design, robotics, commercial space, high-speed networks, access to capital for startups, high-skill immigration, STEM education, learning technology, startup ecosystems, and the federal use of incentive prizes.
From 2001 to 2008, Kalil was Special Assistant to the Chancellor for Science and Technology at UC Berkeley. He launched a program called Big Ideas@Berkeley, which provide grants to student-led teams committed to solving important problems at home and abroad. In 2007 and 2008, Kalil was the Chair of the Global Health Working Group for the Clinton Global Initiative, where he developed new public and private sector initiatives in areas such as maternal and child health, under-nutrition, and vaccines.
Prior to joining the Clinton White House, Tom was a trade specialist at the Washington offices of Dewey Ballantine, where he represented the Semiconductor Industry Association on U.S.-Japan trade issues and technology policy. He also served as the principal staffer to Gordon Moore in his capacity as Chair of the SIA Technology Committee.
Tom received a B.A. in political science and international economics from the University of Wisconsin at Madison, and completed graduate work at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy.

SESSION THREE:

New Outlooks on Life
Novel approaches to detecting life and intelligence beyond earth

Co-Chair: Cherry Ng

Dunlap Institute / SETI Institute / UC Berkeley

Cherry Ng is a research associate at the Dunlap Institute for Astronomy & Astrophysics, jointly affiliated with the SETI Institute and UC Berkeley. During her PhD study, she discovered 60 rapidly-spinning neutron stars with the Parkes Radio Telescope in Australia. She then worked on the Canadian CHIME telescope, using it to detect and study “Fast Radio Bursts”, a new astrophysical mystery that involves short bursts of radio waves that have come from far outside our Milky Way galaxy. Her hunting effort continues, now in the area of technosignature (SETI). She is the project scientist for the MeerKAT and the Very Large Array (VLA) SETI projects. She and her team use these two sensitive radio telescope facilities to attempt to answer the question of whether there are other advanced extraterrestrial civilizations in the Universe.

Co-Chair: Steve Croft

UC Berkeley SETI Research Center

Steve Croft grew up in England, where he received a PhD in astrophysics from Oxford University in 2002, before moving to California to work as a postdoctoral researcher at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. Since 2007, Croft has been a researcher at UC Berkeley.
Croft's research has included the study of supermassive black holes and their environments, as a principal investigator for both the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes, in addition to over 100 nights on ground-based optical and infrared telescopes including Keck and the Lick 3-meter. He has performed surveys for variable and transient radio sources with the Allen Telescope Array, the Very Large Array, and the Murchison Widefield Array, and looked for the signatures of black hole collisions as a member of the NANOGrav collaboration.
Croft has been a full-time scientist on the Breakthrough Listen program since 2015. He serves as Listen's Project Scientist for the Green Bank Telescope, and is the Director of the NSF-funded Berkeley SETI Research Center "Research Experience for Undergraduates" Site. He is also involved in many aspects of the planning, execution, analysis, and publication of results from the program, as well as proposal writing, documentation, coordinating and writing press releases, donor cultivation, industry engagement, outreach, education, and social media.

Chenoa Tremblay

SETI Institute

Hunting for Life with Meter Wavelengths

We are still finding new ways to search for life almost 65 years after the birth of the experimental phase of wanting to understand our place in the Universe and if we are alone. Searches are typically broken up into two categories: searching for techno-signatures with the assumption that a civilization is at least as advanced as our own; and the search for biosignatures as molecules which includes signs of either primitive life or seeds for it. Typically, the search for biosignatures and technosignatures are completed via separate surveys. However, we have developed ways to search for both types of signatures simultaneously at 99–165MHz and toward over 10 million stars in a single field of view with the SKA pathfinder telescope; Murchison Widefield Array. With this work, we have set new records for simultaneous searches and demonstrate the potential power of the SKA low-frequency array in this field. I will present our motivations, processes and how we are searching and providing key information about future searches for androids and space amoebas with meter wavelengths.


Chenoa Tremblay is a radio astronomer who recently joined the SETI Institute to work on the new Commensal Open-Source Multimode Interferometric Cluster (COSMIC) for the Jansky Very Large Array which is designed to complete an all-sky search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Prior to this role, Chenoa worked at the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, the Australian national science agency, and has over 20 years of experience working in industry research and development in the field of analytical chemistry. She received her PhD at Curtin University in Western Australia and has been involved with building and commissioning a number of low-frequency radio telescopes including the Long Wavelength Array (LWA), Murchison Widefield Array (MWA), and the Australian SKA Pathfinder (ASKAP). Chenoa is the current board-appointed chair of the MWA Galactic and Extragalactic Astronomy science group, a Project Scientist for an international collaboration aimed to study the large-scale structures of the Galaxy through the detection of neutral hydrogen and the hydroxyl molecule, and a Principle Investigator on a number of low-frequency SETI programs with the MWA and ASKAP telescopes designed to study the potential for life in the Galaxy and create programs to get school children involved in the search.

Jason Wright

Penn State University


Biosignatures and Technosignatures as Complementary Paths to Life Detection

The search for life in the universe has grown and evolved significantly since the first modern efforts in the 1960's with Project Ozma. Today, astrobiology, including SETI, can draw upon decades of theoretical, experimental, and observational work that helps us understand the limits of life-as-we-know it, and has given us some weak but significant upper limits on the presence of biological life and technology both in the Solar System and beyond it.
Two primary and complementary modes of life detection are searches for biosignatures and searches for technosignatures. These modes often have striking differences in the assumptions, philosophies, and techniques they employ, and the communities that pursue them have often worked in parallel, with little communication or cross-fertilization. That said, they also share many important commonalities in their assumptions, philosophies, and so would benefit from tighter collaboration.
In this talk, I will outline some of these issues, and address some common misconceptions regarding the relative merits of the two approaches. I will argue both communities have much to learn from each other, that both approaches deserve similar levels of support and effort. I will highlight and applaud the recent move to accept searches for technosignatures back under the broader umbrella of astrobiology.

Jason Wright is a professor of astronomy and astrophysics at Penn State, a member of the Center for Exoplanets and Habitable Worlds, and director of the Penn State Extraterrestrial Intelligence Center. He works on a variety of problems related to stars, their planets, and life in the universe. His work in SETI includes searches for signs of extraterrestrial industry via waste heat (e.g. Dyson Spheres), and the development of curricula in the field. He also studies stars, their atmospheres, their activity, and their planets. He is an Instrument Team Project Scientist for NEID, a PI of NExSS, a co-PI of MINERVA, and a member of the Habitable Zone Planet Finder team.

James Davenport

University of Washington


Technosignature Opportunities with the LSST


The newest generation of wide-field, time-domian sky surveys are creating a “big data” revolution across all of astrophysics. These surveys are creating a movie of the sky, which can reveal nearby asteroids, exoplanets, new types of super novae, and everything in between. Despite the transformative power of these optical surveys, their full potential for technosignature research has not yet been realized. In this talk I will review the capability for discovering novel astrophysics and possibly technosignatures from these surveys, with particular emphasis on the upcoming Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) from the Vera C. Rubin Observatory.

James Davenport is a Research Assistant Professor of Astronomy and the Associate Director of the DiRAC Institute at the University of Washington. His research focuses on studying active stars and searching for technosignatures with large surveys, especially NASA’s Kepler mission and the upcoming Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) 10-year program on the Vera C. Rubin Observatory.

Noemie Globus

UC Santa Cruz


The Chiral Puzzle of Life

While biologists have not yet reached a consensus on the definition of life, homochirality - the specific molecular handedness of biomolecules - is a phenomenon only produced by life. The unraveling of its origin requires interdisciplinary research, by exploring each of fundamental physics, modern chemistry, astrophysics, and biology. We will discuss the origin of biological homochirality in the context of astrophysics and particle physics. Most of our radiation dose from cosmic rays comes from muons that are formed in a decay involving the weak force. Because parity is violated in muon production, the muons are magnetically polarized on average. Earth is the only body in the solar system where muons dominate the cosmic radiation at ground level. Recent ideas connecting the chirality of cosmic muons to a chiral bias in biological processes will be presented.


Noemie Globus is a theoretical astrophysicist and a Chancellor's Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of California, Santa Cruz, where she conducts interdisciplinary research on the role of cosmic radiation in the emergence of life, involving knowledge from different fields. The goal of her research is to understand if natural, spin-polarized cosmic radiation can act as a chiral evolutionary pressure.​ Her other topics of interest are in high energy astrophysics: she studies the formation of relativistic jets around spinning black holes, and the origin of ultra-high energy cosmic rays.

David Deamer

UC Santa Cruz


A unique biosignature: Biopolymers in nanopores

Solid-state nanoscopic channels can detect single molecules of nucleic acids in solution. Such channels, now referred to as nanopores, use an applied voltage to translocate linear ionized polymers such as DNA or RNA through the channel. During translocation, the polymer causes a transient decrease of the ionic current flowing through the pore. This decrease is a unique characteristic of biological polyanions. A commercial solid-state nanopore device has been developed to analyze nucleic acids. A modified version of this device is small enough to be incorporated into a life-detection instrument package for future missions to Mars and icy moons such as Europa and Enceladus.

David Deamer is a Research Professor of Biomolecular Engineering at the University of California, Santa Cruz. Deamer received his undergraduate degree in Chemistry from Duke University in 1961, and PhD in Physiological Chemistry at the Ohio State University School of Medicine, 1965. Over his scientific career, Deamer has maintained a central focus on biological and synthetic membranes. In 1989, Deamer proposed the idea that it may be possible to sequence a DNA molecule by passing it through a nanoscopic pore embedded in a lipid bilayer membrane. Deamer, Daniel Branton (Harvard University), and John Kasianowitz (NIST) demonstrated the feasibility of this concept in 1996. Collaborative work with Mark Akeson at UC Santa Cruz reported proof of principle in 1999 by showing that a nanopore could distinguish between sequences of adenine and cytosine in RNA. Oxford Nanopore Technology was founded in the UK in 2005 and has developed and distributed multiple devices that utilize nanopore sequencing concepts.

Cherry Ng

Dunlap Institute / SETI Institute / UC Berkeley


A new digitized age of interferometric SETI

The search for technosignatures - remotely observable indicators of advanced extraterrestrial life - addresses one of the most profound questions in science: are we alone in the universe as intelligent life? The Breakthrough Listen program is leading the most concerted search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) effort to-date through radio and optical surveys of nearby stars, nearby galaxies and the Milky Way galactic plane, thus representing the best chance the human race has ever had to detect a technosignature. Recently, Breakthrough Listen has partnered with the SETI Institute to develop commensal SETI search capabilities on some of the most sensitive radio inteferometers, including the Very Large Array (VLA) and MeerKAT. Interferometric radio telescopes have the advantage of providing a larger field of view, maximizing the SETI survey speed. The VLA search will be operating alongside latter portions of the third epoch of the VLA Sky Survey (VLASS), allowing us to monitor over 1 million nearby stars within the next few years. In this talk, we will present the latest updates on these surveys and conclude with a refreshed outlook on SETI search using next generation telescope facilities.


Cherry Ng is a research associate at the Dunlap Institute for Astronomy & Astrophysics, jointly affiliated with the SETI Institute and UC Berkeley. During her PhD study, she discovered 60 rapidly-spinning neutron stars with the Parkes Radio Telescope in Australia. She then worked on the Canadian CHIME telescope, using it to detect and study “Fast Radio Bursts”, a new astrophysical mystery that involves short bursts of radio waves that have come from far outside our Milky Way galaxy. Her hunting effort continues, now in the area of technosignature (SETI). She is the project scientist for the MeerKAT and the Very Large Array (VLA) SETI projects. She and her team use these two sensitive radio telescope facilities to attempt to answer the question of whether there are other advanced extraterrestrial civilizations in the Universe.

JUNE 23 EVENING RECEPTION


Raymond Pierrehumbert

University of Oxford


How not to waste half your star’s main sequence lifetime:
Alien megastructures for staving off habitability crises

The same fundamental physics (thermodynamics, radiative transfer and fluid mechanics) can be hooked together in a variety of ways to study a diverse range of planetary climate problems (recalling that Earth, too is a planet, and the Early Earth is practically a different planet than the Earth we now live on).

Raymond Pierrehumbert's chief interest relates to the climate dynamics of exoplanets, and of the ancient Earth, but there are many general phenomena, such as generalizations of water vapor feedback, that are as important to global change problems on Earth as they are to the climate of exoplanets with permanent magma oceans. His general philosophy is that big ideas come from small models, but three dimensional global circulation models are also included in his toolkit. Even when he uses 3D climate models, the emphasis is on using the tool to illuminate fundamental physical phenomena, rather than to provide the greatest realism (at the cost of being understandable). The problems emerging at the leading edge of the subject often blur the boundaries between geology, geochemistry and atmospheric science as atmospheres are dynamic entities which exchange with crustal material, the deep planetary interior and outer space. Besides this class of problems, he is leading research in a number of global change problems that are motivated primarily by their significance for policy. This includes such things as the effect of beef production on climate, and the proper way to assess the relative importance of mitigation of carbon dioxide vs. short-lived greenhouse gases such as methane.
Pierrehumbert has also maintained an interest in more traditional areas of geophysical fluid dynamics, particularly as related to baroclinic instability, storm track structure, and planetary wave propagation. Besides that, he is engaged in fluid mechanical research of a more abstract nature, particularly as related to two-dimensional turbulence and mixing in two-dimensional area-preserving flows (a subject which has a close affinity with Hamiltonian chaos). Many of these more abstract mathematically motivated lines of research have cross-fertilized with climate dynamic problems of central physical importance, as in the case of dynamical systems analysis of fluid mixing and the problem of water vapor feedback.

Hosts

Natalie Batalha

UC Santa Cruz

Natalie Batalha is a professor of physics and astronomy at San Jose State University in the heart of Silicon Valley, California and co-investigator on NASA's Kepler Mission. She holds a bachelor's in physics from the University of California (UC), Berkeley and a doctorate in astrophysics from UC Santa Cruz. Batalha started her career as a stellar spectroscopist studying young, sun-like stars. After a post-doctoral fellowship in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Batalha returned to California. Inspired by the growing number of exoplanet discoveries she joined the team led by William Borucki at NASA's Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., working on transit photometry -- an emerging technology for finding exoplanets. As a member of the Kepler team, Batalha is responsible for the selection of the more than 150,000 stars the spacecraft monitors and works closely with team members at Ames to identify viable planet candidates from Kepler photometry. As Director of the Systems Teaching Institute at the NASA Research Park, Batalha is responsible for creating programs and resources for students pursuing careers in fields relevant to the mission of NASA Ames.

UC Santa Cruz was founded in 1965 as the movement away from the conservative '50s was in full swing and America was experiencing a transformation. The founding faculty, administrators, and students embraced and embodied this change. They were open and revolutionary in their thinking—more than mere radicals, they dared to imagine a living and learning environment that would foster a community whose passion came from a deep sense of social justice. UC Santa Cruz is a public university like no other in California, combining the intimacy of a small, liberal arts college with the depth and rigor of a major research university.

David Korsmeyer

NASA’s Ames Research Center

David Korsmeyer is a member of the Senior Executive Service (SES) serving as the Associate Center Director for Research and Technology at NASA's Ames Research Center in Silicon Valley. At Ames since 1991, he is responsible for the overall scope and direction of the center’s research, technology, and engineering developments, which support NASA’s missions in: Aeronautics, Science, Exploration, and Technology. He is one of four senior leaders guiding Ames, managing NASA's Virtual Institutes, hosted at Ames, as well as (competitive) Internal Research and Development projects, and the center’s external research collaborations.
Korsmeyer formerly served as Director of Engineering for six years and led a broad range of engineering missions; he was responsible for all of the technical activities for spaceflight systems and project engineering staff at Ames. Notable mission successes include: NASA’s Lunar Atmosphere and Dust Environment Explorer (LADEE), Network & Operation Demonstration Satellite (NODeS), creating Human Exploration and Operations projects such as Biosentinel, flying numerous space biology instrumentation missions on the International Space Station (ISS) and as free-flyers, among other distinctions in the field.

NASA's Ames Research Center, one of ten NASA field centers, is located in the heart of California's Silicon Valley. Since 1939, Ames has led NASA in conducting world-class research and development in aeronautics, exploration technology and science aligned with the center's core capabilities.

Dave DeBoer

UC Berkeley Radio Astronomy Lab (RAL)

Dave DeBoer's research interests relate to instrumentation to explore the radio Universe. Currently this relates to building instrumentation for early Universe studies (Epoch of Reionization) and then trying to use them for planetary studies as well. From his past work on spectrum management, he also use instruments to help characterize the radio frequency environment. DeBoer helps manage the undergraduate lab facilities, with access to the new 4.2m radio cm-wave radio telescope.

The Radio Astronomy Laboratory (RAL) was created in 1958 to foster research in radio astronomy, a discipline that naturally extends beyond the borders of traditional academic departments at Berkeley. Over the years, faculty and graduate students from the Astronomy, Physics, Chemistry, Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, and Geology and Geophysics departments have made use of the RAL's facilities.
The main activity of the RAL has been to build and maintain a radio astronomy observatory at Hat Creek, near Mt. Lassen, supported by on-campus laboratory facilities in Campbell Hall. The current observatory is a state-of-the-art array of ten radio telescopes (the BIMA array) that operate at millimeter wavelengths, one of only four such facilities in the world. The signals from the antennas are combined to make images of cosmic radio sources. In July 1998, the RAL entered into an agreement with the SETI Institute of Mountain View California to design, build and operate an array of radio telescopes of a radically new design operating at centimeter wavelengths, known as the Allen Telescope Array (ATA). The BIMA Array will soon be moved to a site in the Inyo Mountains and combined with the six telescopes of Caltech's OVRO array to form a new, more powerful instrument known as CARMA. The RAL will thus be operating two observatories capable of making observations from frequencies of 300 MHz to nearly 300 GHz, or nearly 10 octaves in frequency.

Jessica Rousset

ASU Interplanetary Initiative

Jessica Rousset is the Deputy Director of the Interplanetary Initiative, leading its strategy, collaborations and operations. Jessica is a mission-driven operational, business development and commercialization leader focused on growing early-stage technology companies, creating innovation engines in large organizations and bridging academic, government and corporate interests toward the common goal of improving people’s lives. She led a publicly-traded drug delivery company as its COO and served as the head of innovation at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, where over a 10-year period, she founded its Center for Innovation, helped launch medtech and biotech companies improving children’s lives and established an FDA-funded national pediatric technology accelerator.

The Interplanetary Initiative at Arizona State University engages broadly across disciplines and sectors to create an interplanetary future built upon cooperative and inclusive new structures, systems, and perspectives. We study and solve the big social and systems questions that pave our future in space. The Interplanetary Initiative most recently announced a collaboration with Blue Origin and other space leaders to launch a premier, mixed-use space station in low Earth orbit designed to open multiple new markets in space.

Harry Atwater
Caltech

Harry Atwater is the Otis Booth Leadership Chair, Division of Engineering and Applied Science, Howard Hughes Professor of Applied Physics and Materials Science, and Director, Liquid Sunlight Alliance at the California Institute of Technology. Atwater’s scientific interests span light-matter interactions from quantum nanophotonics, two-dimensional materials and metasurfaces to solar photovoltaics and artificial photosynthesis. Atwater is an early pioneer in nanophotonics and plasmonics; he gave the name to the field of plasmonics in 2001. He currently serves as Director of the Liquid Sunlight Alliance, a DOE Solar Fuels Hub project, and was the founding Director of the Resnick Sustainability Institute at Caltech. He also chairs the Breakthrough Starshot Lightsail Committee and is a PI of the Caltech Space Solar Power Project.

Caltech is a world-renowned science and engineering institute that marshals some of the world's brightest minds and most innovative tools to address fundamental scientific questions and pressing societal challenges. The Institute manages JPL for NASA, sending probes to explore the planets of our solar system and quantify changes on our home planet. Caltech also owns and operates large-scale research facilities such as the Seismological Laboratory and a global network of astronomical observatories, including the Palomar and W. M. Keck Observatories; and cofounded and comanages LIGO. Caltech is an independent, privately supported institution with a 124-acre campus located in Pasadena, California.

Charles Alcock

Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian

Charles Alcock is the Director of the Harvard- Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA), Director of the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (SAO), Director of the Harvard College Observatory, and the Donald H. Menzel Professor of Astronomy at Harvard University. He is also the Principal Investigator for the Taiwan-America Occultation Survey and previously for the MACHO Project, an international project involving scientists from seven institutions in the US, Australia, Canada, and Britain. His research interests include large astronomical surveys, the outer solar system, cosmic dark matter, astronomical data mining, and virtual observatory technologies. He earned his PhD in Astronomy from the California Institute of Technology (1977) and a BSc (Hons) in Physics from the Auckland University, New Zealand (1972).

Founded in 1973, the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian is an ongoing collaboration between the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory and Harvard College Observatory designed to foster innovation and propel discovery. Our mission is to advance knowledge of the Universe through research in astronomy and astrophysics and in related areas of fundamental physics and geophysics.

The Initiatives Team

S. Pete Worden

Breakthrough Initiatives

Simon Peter “Pete” Worden, (Brig. Gen., USAF, Ret., PhD) is the Chairman of the Breakthrough Prize Foundation and Executive Director of the foundation’s Breakthrough Initiatives. He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Physics and Astronomy from the University of Michigan and a PhD in Astronomy from the University of Arizona. Prior to joining the Breakthrough Prize Foundation, Dr. Worden was Director of NASA’s Ames Research Center at Moffett Field, California until his retirement on March 31, 2015. He has held several positions in the United States Air Force and was research professor of astronomy at the University of Arizona, Tucson, USA. He is a recognized expert on space and science issues, both civil and military, and has been a leader in building partnerships between governments and the private sector internationally.

Jamie Drew

Breakthrough Initiatives

Jamie Drew is Chief of Staff and Program Director for the Breakthrough Initiatives, a suite of scientific and technological space exploration programs searching for life in the Universe. Prior to his current role, Drew worked at the NASA Ames Research Center on agile-spacecraft technologies. At NASA he also served as an International Relations specialist for public-private partnerships in the Office of the Center Director, and Science Manager in the Office of the Chief Scientist. Drew holds a B.A. from Malmö University, Sweden and an M.S. from the Intl. Space University (ISU), France. Drew’s technical research interests lie in mobility systems on and off our planet; his humanities-based research interests focus on questions regarding the future survival of the human species.

Pete Klupar

Breakthrough Initiatives

Mr. Klupar has worked in the Aerospace Industry for more than 35 years. Holding positions in Government (US Air force and NASA) and industry( startups to multinational corporations). Prior to being the Engineering Director at the Breakthrough Foundation, Mr. Klupar was Director of Engineering at NASA’s Ames Research Center. While at Ames he helped develop the Aquila, LADEE, TESS, Pharmasat, OREO and other small spacecraft missions while aiding in the development and operations of Kepler and SOFIA projects.


James Schalkwyk

Breakthrough Initiatives

Born and raised in Cape Town, South Africa, James Schalkwyk’s professional interest in interstellar travel began in 2011 with DARPA’s ambitious 100-Year Starship study. The one-year program aimed to understand and build the organizational – rather than technological – underpinnings of an organization capable of building a starship within 100 years. After DARPA awarded the grant to Mae Jemison’s 100YSS organization, James moved to NASA’s Ames Research Center where he worked variously in the Communications and New Ventures Directorate, the NewSpace-focused “Space Portal” and in the Strategic Partnerships Division. During this time, his work ran the gamut, ranging from SmallSat technology to low-cost lunar settlements, and from asteroid cataloguing to space resource extraction.

James spent several months consulting for the Breakthrough Initiatives shortly after their inception in 2016. After completing graduate school at Columbia University in 2018 he rejoined the team to manage the growing Starshot program, bringing him squarely back to the serious business of building starships.


Kyran Grattan

Breakthrough Initiatives

Kyran currently works as the Associate Director at the Breakthrough Initiatives. He has an LLM from the international institute of air and space law in Leiden, the Netherlands. He is an avid member of SGAC and a former representative at the European Centre for Space Law.