Home‎ > ‎

Debate

Monday, May 23rd, 2016

posted May 23, 2016, 12:32 PM by Unknown user


This template helps students summarize the elements of an argument – claim, support, examples – and guides their reading and writing processes. Although somewhat prescriptive, it provides a useful structure for students to follow until they internalize the process.

The general argument made by the speaker, _________________________, in his/her speach (title) _________________________________, is that ___________________ ____________________________________. More specifically, the speaker argues that ______________________________________. He/She says, “ _________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________ .” In this passage, the speaker is suggesting that __________________________________________________________. In conclusion, the speaker’s belief is __________________________________________. In my view, the author is wrong/right because _______________________________________________________________________. More specifically, I believe that _____________________________________________. For example, ____________________________________________________________ ________________________________________. Although the speaker might object that ____________________________________________________, I maintain that _______________________________________________________________________. Therefore, I conclude that __________________________________________________

Tuesday, May 17th, 2016

posted May 17, 2016, 12:25 PM by Unknown user

We are going to play "point and counterpoint."

I will present a topic and your job as a group is to come up with as many reasons for the affirmative as possible. 
10 minutes to come up with support.
You will present one support and our opponents will have a chance to rebut your reasoning through understanding of logical fallacies or opposite reasoning. The team with the most reasons left standing wins that debate.

Topics:
1. Illegal Immigration should be eliminated completely from the U.S. 
2. HB2 (Affirmative is for the bill/Negative is against the bill).
3. Raising Minimum Wage to $15.00 an hour.

Wednesday, May 11th, 2016

posted May 11, 2016, 12:31 PM by Unknown user

Today we are beginning your final

This is due by May 26th.

Your job is to pick a speech of some form. This speech must come from the following criteria:
A speech from a Presidential Candidate from the last 28 years (approved by me)
A speech from a current political office holder (approved by me)

You will need to do the following things:
1. Research and explain the rhetorical background of this speech. Why as it given? When was it given? Who is the audience? What was the reception? Where was it presented? 
2. Rhetorical Analysis of your speech. Detail where Ethos is used. Detail where pathos is used. Detail where logos is used.
3. Rhetorical Analysis of logical fallacies utilized. Point out at least 3.
4. Include an arguable thesis. ie. President Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation was not pro-African American.

Monday, May 9th, 2016

posted May 9, 2016, 11:37 AM by Unknown user   [ updated May 9, 2016, 12:36 PM ]

Here is today's order of debates

Wednesday
1. Sianlei and Teresa
2. Landon and Max
3. Brittani and Sharon
4. Kasey and Kenzie
5. Austin and...


Thursday, May 5th, 2016

posted May 5, 2016, 12:29 PM by Unknown user

To help solidify the understanding of logical fallacy activity.

Get a partner (or do it Solo, that's fine too)

Create a Google Drive FOLDER titled "Your Name(s) - Logical Fallacies"
In this folder you need a visual representation (image) of each of the 13 logical fallacies. Rename each image the name of the logical fallacy it represents. 
Also create a document in this folder and in this document describing why these images represent this logical fallacy.

Finally, on this document, as a partnership, answer this question:

What does the casual acceptance of surrounding ourselves with fallacies say about us?
 
Remember that everything is an argument. Look for persuasive posters around the school. College posters trying to get you to go to school there. Look at how they are flawed in their persuasion.
Example:
Enter/Exit signs (either/or fallacy)
Memes from the internet: 
This could be Ad Hominem as well as Either/Or fallacy.

1. Ad Hominem

2. Ad Populem

3. Appeal to Tradition

4. Appeal to Improper Authority

5. Argumentum Ad Misericordiam

6. Argument from Adverse Consequences

7. Argument from Personal Incredulity

8. Straw Man Argument

9. Either/Or Fallacy

10. Undistributed Middle Term

11. Moving the Goal Posts

12. No True Scotsman Fallacy

13. The Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy

14. The Slippery Slope Fallacy

Needs to be done by 2:30

Tuesday, May 3rd, 2016

posted May 3, 2016, 12:34 PM by Unknown user

Logical Fallacies:

A. Ad Hominem

2. Ad Populem

3. Appeal to Tradition

4. Appeal to Improper Authority

5. Argumentum Ad Misericordiam

6. Argument from Adverse Consequences

7. Argument from Personal Incredulity

8. Straw Man Argument

9. Either/Or Fallacy

10. Undistributed Middle Term

J. Moving the Goal Posts

Q. No True Scotsman Fallacy

K. The Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy

Joker. The Slippery Slope Fallacy

Your Job is to research it an teach it.

Joker. 
Make sure we can know what it is and what give us a few examples.

Monday, April 25th, 2016

posted Apr 25, 2016, 12:06 PM by Unknown user

You have the first 10 minutes to get your poop in a group:

Again the order looks like this:
1. Prosecution Declaration - state first who is the defendant and what they are accused of
2. Defense Plea
3. Prosecution Opening Statement 2 Minutes
4. Defense Opening Statements 2 minutes
5. Prosecution Evidence and Prebut
6. Defense Evidence and Rebut
7. Any closing statements (Prosecution then defense)


Trial order
1. Tyler & Hagen
2. Amy and Mady
3. Janessa and Brylie
4. Sami and Avery
5. Hallie and Becca
6. Tabitha and Monica
7. Gage and Isaac
8. Kalista 

Wednesday
1. Sianlei and Teresa
2. Noelia and Skyly
3. Landon and Max
4. Marcus and Alex
5. Mika and WEston
6. Austin
7. Brittani and Sahron
8. Kasey and Kenzie

Friday
1. Conner and Coby
2. Einfeldt and Miranda
3. Overlfow

Thursday, April 21st, 2016

posted Apr 21, 2016, 11:53 AM by Unknown user   [ updated Apr 21, 2016, 1:22 PM ]



Things to do:
You have 30 minutes to get your trials in order:

Trials:
1. Sharon/Brittney
2. Kalista/Kiley
3. Kasey/Kenzie

Order of this debate:
1. Present the case 
        a. Who is the defendant?
        b. What are they accused of doing?
        c. What is the plea?
2. Prosecution Opening Statement (2 minutes)
3. Defense Opening Statement (2 minutes)
4. Prosecution Case (2 minutes min)
5. Defense Case (2 minutes min)
6. Closing statements if needed


A 75% voting in favor of the prosecution is needed for a Guilty verdict to be rendered.

Friday, April 15th, 2016

posted Apr 15, 2016, 11:28 AM by Unknown user

So, you should have your opening statements planned out.

Next we want to present the evidence:

Since the burden of proof lies with the prosecution, the prosecution need to come up with at least 3 pieces of evidence to support their claim.  
Evidence includes:
1. Eyewitness testimony (clips or screen shots from the event)
2. Character witness (people saying things from the movie about the character)
3. Expert Testimony (people that are familiar with similar aspects of the case)

For the defense, you must anticipate these claims by being able to dispute them with:
1: Your own Eyewitness Testimony (clips or screen shots from the event)
2. Character witness (people saying positive things about the character)
3. Expert Testimony (people who are familiar with your character's situation)

Each of you need to prepare about 2 minutes of evidence.
Each piece of evidence should last 20 seconds each and presented on a Haiku Deck format (It is an app).

How to Haiku Deck.

It should look and sound like this:
1-20 seconds: Introduction 
21-40 seconds: Evidence 1
41-60 seconds: Evidence 2
60-80 seconds: Evidence 3
80-100 seconds: Rebut or Prebut your opponent
100-120 seconds: Conclusion

Today you need to get this prepared through research.

So by the end of class you need to have:
1. Your opening statement
2. Your 2 minutes of evidence blocked out. 

Docket for Trials starting on Tuesday:

Wednesday, April 13th, 2016

posted Apr 13, 2016, 12:31 PM by Unknown user   [ updated Apr 13, 2016, 12:31 PM ]

Today you will need to write your opening statements.

Here are a few examples:

YouTube Video


YouTube Video


YouTube Video


YouTube Video



Where to go:
1. Paint a picture of your character. Describe them as someone that could or could not commit this crime.
2. Describe the situation. Describe it as one that is either possible or impossible for there to be a crime committed
3. Describe the motive. Describe this as something that could or could not lead to them committing a crime.
4. Describe a moral imperative of the jury.
5. Begin with a hook and tie it in to the end of your statement.

1-10 of 61