In 2015-16, Our Lady of Fatima Catholic School completed a self-study that involved a thorough evaluation of all aspects of the school from financial planning to educational programs. The results were submitted to a Visiting Team of the Accrediting Commission for Elementary Schools of the Western Catholic Educational Association (WCEA) and the Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC).

The school was granted a six year term of accreditation through June 2022.