by Jay Weiser
Michel Foucault's classic Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison states:
There is no power relation without the correlative constitution of a field of knowledge, nor any knowledge that does not presuppose and constitute at the same time power relations.
Was Foucault prophesying CUNY's Discipline Councils? They go back to the 1990s, as a forum for department chairs in a given discipline across the university. The Academic Program Planning policy (created by a 06/28/93 Board of Trustees resolution) contemplates Discipline Councils without expressly using the term, directing:
While the Academic Program Planning policy does not expressly address the UFS role, the Board of Trustees' 11/25/96 minutes offer an early mention, with thanks to then-UFS Chair Sandi Cooper. Former UFS Executive Director Bill Phipps reported that the Discipline Councils were jointly sponsored by the University Faculty Senate and the Office of Academic Affairs, adding:
Organic, but Not Always Natural
The Academic Program Planning policy provides little clarity on the Discipline Councils' powers. Having evolved organically over the last quarter-century, they do not always match CUNY's current configuration. With the Discipline Councils planning to meet with the University Faculty Senate Executive Committee this week, here are some observations based on recent UFS inquiries about facts on the ground:
CUNY has lacked a consistent principle for choosing when to coordinate academic policies through ad hoc task forces versus Discipline Councils. The latter may be better at providing consistency and institutional memory. As we move to a federal university with more shared courses across campuses, Discipline Councils are essential for shared governance in curriculum (including online courses), and can offer a forum for faculty development and instructional software evalution.
The UFS and Discipline Council members should explore a model of fewer and broader Discipline Councils (like the current sciences one) that can be more engaged -- with the ability to farm out specific disciplinary issues to subcommittees with mandates.
#disciplinecouncils #interdisciplinaryeducation #curriculum #sharedgovernance #academicprogramplanning
These are my observations alone, and not those of either the Executive Committee or the Discipline Councils. All errors are mine.
Jay Weiser is Associate Professor of Law at Baruch College, a member of the UFS Executive Committee and UFS Legal Affairs Chair. Thanks to former Executive Director William Phipps and UFS staff member Stasia Pasela for research.
UFS Blog >