Western Maine Learning

Evaluating Information

Should the U.S. government provide universal health care for its citizens?


  • What are some reasons not to do so? (3)
  • What are some reasons to do so? (3)
  • What else needs to be considered?



Propaganda


Logical Fallacies

Scientific Method


Point of View: Perspective   

Omission / Commission (The Art of Lying)





Expert Source (Authoritative)     MARVEL - Maine's Virtual Library

Democratic Approach - Reputation   Wikipedia 





So what is a person to do?

"Trust, but Verify"
~ President Ronald Reagan
  • Check source

  • Check Multiple sources

  • "If it seems too good to be true, it probably is" . . . look closer before leaping. Don't Jump.



To Look for:

•Is the information reliable?
•Is the information biased or is the author presenting more than one side of the argument?
•Is the page designed to sway different opinions?
•Is the purpose of the page clearly identified?


Other things to consider:

•Are dates provided for the information stated?
•When the information was written?
•Is the information on the page outdated?
•When the page was last modified or updated?
•What topics are covered?
•How in-depth does the information go?
•Does the page offer information that is not found anywhere else?

Checklist



The Onion

The New York Times


Google News

Google Alert

Online Newspapers

Online News and Political Magazines

Universal Health Care on YouTube



Newsweek: Healthcare Made Simple

Should the government provide Universal Health Care for Americans?

The Case for Universal Health Care

Pros and Cons of Universal Health Care (Discussion Board)

Wikipedia: Universal Health Care

The Problem with Socialized Health Care


Newspaper Generator


Project/Discussion:  Should the U.S. government provide universal health care for its citizens?

  • What are some reasons not to do so? (3)
  • What are some reasons to do so? (3)
  • What else needs to be considered?

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z