Prophet Muhammad and Aisha listened to singers with musical instruments in their house. Prophet Muhammad said prophets before him used musical instruments. Prophet Muhammad rejected the idea that musical instruments are a tool of the Devil. Prophet Muhammad said that a singer had received a double reward in the hereafter. Prophet Muhammad told Abu Musa that the musical instruments that were given to him was something wonderful not something evil.
Music haram in Islam?
Songs haram in Islam?
Musical instruments
haram in Islam?
Sports haram in Islam?
Punishment for
listening to music?
Music and singing in
Islam.
Songs
in Islam.
Music in Islam.
Islam and music.
Music and Islam.
Does Islam allow music?
Is music allowed in
Islam?
Is music illegal in Islam?
Is music prohibited in Islam?
Is music prohibited in the Quran?
Is music legal in Islam?
Is music allowed in Islam?
Is music a sin?
Is music sinful?
Can Muslims listen to music?
Is music forbidden in
Islam?
Islam and singing.
Singing and Islam.
Does Islam allow singing?
Is singing allowed in
Islam?
Is singing illegal in Islam?
Is singing prohibited in Islam?
Is singing prohibited in the Quran?
Is singing legal in Islam?
Is singing allowed in Islam?
Is singing a sin?
Is singing sinful?
Can Muslims listen to singing?
Is singing forbidden
in Islam?
Islam and songs.
Songs and Islam.
Does Islam allow songs?
Are songs allowed in
Islam?
Are songs illegal in Islam?
Are songs prohibited in Islam?
Is song prohibited in the Quran?
Are songs legal in Islam?
Is song allowed in Islam?
Are songs a sin?
Are songs sinful?
Can Muslims listen to songs?
Are songs forbidden in
Islam?
Can Muslims use Musical instruments?
Is the use of Musical instruments
forbidden in Islam?
Islam and Musical instruments.
Musical instruments and Islam.
Does Islam allow Musical instruments?
Are Musical instruments allowed
in Islam?
Are Musical
instruments illegal in Islam?
Are Musical
instruments prohibited in Islam?
Is Musical
instruments prohibited in the
Quran?
Are Musical instruments legal in Islam?
Is Musical
instruments allowed in Islam?
Is the use of Musical instruments a
sin?
Are Musical
instruments sinful?
Can Muslims listen to Musical instruments?
Are Musical instruments forbidden
in Islam?
Watching sport is not forbidden in Islam.
Playing sport is not forbidden in Islam.
Prophet Muhammad and Aisha watched sport.
Prophet Muhammad rejected the idea that watching sport is forbidden.
Prophet Muhammad cheered the sports players when he and Aisha were watching
them.
Is watching sport forbidden in Islam?
Is sport haram in Islam?
Is sport haraam in Islam?
Is sports haram in Islam?
Punishment for watching sport in
Islam?
Sport in Islam.
Sports in Islam.
Islam and sports.
Islam and sport.
Sports and Islam.
Sports and Islam.
Is sport allowed in Islam?
Is sports allowed in Islam?
Is sport illegal in Islam?
Is sport illegal in Islam?
Is sports illegal in Islam?
Is sport legal in Islam?
Is sport prohibited in the Quran?
Is sports prohibited in the Quran?
Is sport prohibited in the Islam?
Is sports prohibited in the Islam?
Is watching sport a sin in Islam?
Is playing sport a sin in Islam?
Is sport sinful?
Can Muslims watch sports?
Can Muslims watch sport?
Can Muslims play sport?
Can Muslims play sports?
Is sport forbidden in
Islam?
Is sports forbidden in
Islam?
Is sport forbidden in the Quran?
Is sports forbidden in the Quran?
Does Islam allow sports?
Does Islam allow sport?
Is sport a sin in Islam?
Is sports a sin in Islam?
Can Muslims listen to sports?
Can Muslims listen to sport?
Can Muslims watch sports?
Can Muslims listen to sport?
INDEX:
Sport in Islam: see comment
32 and 40. The other comments
about music and musical instruments also apply to Sport.
Music,
song, musical instruments and sport are not prohibited, not haram, not forbidden in
Islam in Arabic.
Is song, music and musical instruments and sports legal,
allowed, prohibited, haram, forbidden in Islam?
Music is legal in Islam.
Singing is legal in Islam.
Musical instruments are legal in Islam.
There is
nothing from Allah (God) in the Quran that prohibits Song and Music and
Musical instruments but there are many warnings from Allah in the Quran about
people that say
Allah prohibited things that
Allah did not prohibit.
1. Quran 6:87, Quran 16:116, Quran 16:117 Allah does not allow man to prohibit
what Allah has not prohibited in the Quran. Quran
5:87, Verse 5:87
O you who have faith (in Allah),
do not forbid the good things that Allah
has made lawful for you and do not break the law. Allah does not love law breakers. Quran 16:116, Verse 16:116 And do not say falsely with your own tongues, "This
is lawful (allowed) and this is unlawful (forbidden)," so that you invent
a lie against Allah (Allaah) (by saying something that Allah (Allaah) did not
say). Those who invent a lie against Allah (Allaah) shall not succeed (in the
Hereafter).
Quran 16:117, Verse 16:117 (For those that claim that Allah (Allaah) said something
that Allah (Allaah) did not say there is)
a brief enjoyment (in life) but for them shall be a painful punishment (in
the Hereafter).
2. Allah asks mankind 31 times in Quran chapter 55, “From everything that Allah has provided to you which of
them do you deny?” (What do you say is not from Allah? or What do you say Allah
has prohibited to you when in fact it is not prohibited to you by Allah?).
Quran 55:13, Quran 55:16, Quran 55:18, Quran 55:21, Quran 55:23, Quran 55:25, Quran 55:28,
Quran 55:30, Quran 55:32, Quran 55:34, Quran 55:36, Quran 55:38, Quran 55:40, Quran 55:42,
Quran 55:45, Quran 55:47, Quran 55:49, Quran 55:51, Quran 55:53, Quran 55:55, Quran 55:57,
Quran 55:59, Quran 55:61, Quran 55:63, Quran 55:65, Quran 55:67, Quran 55:69, Quran 55:71,
Quran 55:73, Quran 55:75, Quran 55:77 Which of the bounties of your Lord will
you deny (meaning, which of all the things that Allah gives you will you deny by saying
they did not come from Allah or by saying that Allah has prohibited things to you that Allah has not prohibited to you)?
3. Quran 6:21 from Allah about man inventing prohibitions and then saying that
the prohibition is from Allah.
Quran 6:21, Verse 6:21 And who commits a
greater sin than he who invents a lie against Allah (by saying that Allah
ordered things that He did not order) or denies His revelations? Those
wrongdoers shall not be successful (in the hereafter).
4. Quran 6:140 from Allah about those that prohibit what Allah has given to mankind.
Quran 6:140, Verse 6:140 Lost
(from the love of Allah are
those) who have killed their children (by burying their children alive) in
foolishness without sense (because of their false belief in stone idols)
and (those who) have prohibited what (food) Allah has provided them by inventing a lie against Allah (by saying Allah prohibited things that He
did not prohibit). They have gone astray and are not (rightly) guided (by Allah).
5. Quran 6:144 from Allah about those that have no evidence from Allah’s Quran for what they say is
prohibited by Allah.
Quran 6:144, Verse 6:144 And consider a
pair of camels and a pair of oxen. Say, “Has He (Allah) forbidden the two males or the two females and what is
in the wombs of the two females or were you a witness when Allah ordered this for you (that
you use it to support your claim that such laws exist)? Then who does the
greatest wrong than he who fabricates a lie concerning Allah (by saying that Allah ordered something that he
did not order) so that he may lead mankind astray without knowledge. Surely
Allah does not (rightly)
guide the people that do wrong.
6. Quran 5:101
from Allah about asking
questions about things that are not in the Quran. Quran
5:101, Verse 5:101 O you who have faith (in Allah), do not ask about things that if they were made known
they might be a burden to you. But if you ask questions when the Quran is
being revealed then they shall be answered. Allah gives his pardon for (those that did) this. Allah is forgiving and tolerant.
7. Quran 5:101
from Allah about people that
prohibit things for themselves and later other people say it was Allah that prohibited it. Quran 3:93, Verse 3:93 (Despite
what some of the Jews of Medina said, in fact) all food was lawful to the Children
of Israel, except what Israel (Prophet Jacob, Yaqub, Yaqoob, Yaqob, Yaakov,
Israel) made unlawful for himself before the Torah was revealed. Say (O Muhammad,
to them), "Bring the Torah here and recite it (to us) if you are
truthful."
(Comment1. Quran 3:93 makes clear that no food was prohibited by Allah in the
time of Abraham (Ibrahim, Ibraham, Ibraheem, Ebrahim, Abraham,
Avraham) and that it was Prophet
Jacob (Yaqub, Yaqoob, Yaqob, Yaakov, Israel) who prohibited food for himself).
(Comment 2. This is confirmed in the
Jewish Torah of the Old Bible in Genesis 32:26 – 32:33).
8. Quran 3:94
from Allah about those that
continue to say that something that Allah
did not prohibit in Allah’s
Quran, is prohibited. Quran 3:94, Verse 3:94 If anyone
after this (time when the truth has been revealed) invents a lie (regarding
when and why certain foods were prohibited) and attributes it to Allah then they are truly wicked.
9. The
Holy book of Allah (God) is the Quran.
Shortly before his death Prophet Muhammad, messenger of Allah
(God), said “I have perfected (completed) Islam as your religion.”
The Quran is the gift of knowledge and the
commandments for this life and the path to success in the hereafter.
The Quran is written for the eyes of all
mankind and womankind.
10. Where is
music banned (made forbidden, prohibited by Allah) in the perfected
(completed) Quran?
The Quran says
nothing about Music, songs and musical instruments.
11. The
Quran warns against extreme ideas.
The
Quran repeats 31 times one question in Quran chapter 55: “Which of the
blessings of the Lord do you deny?” so as to warn us against extreme ideas
that come from man and not from the orders of Allah in the Quran.
12. Musical instruments near Prophet Muhammad.
In
Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith 70 Prophet Muhammad warned people against extremism (extreme ideas)
especially regarding music, singing, songs and musical instruments because
Islam is a religion of moderation (moderate ideas as ordered by Allah). In Bukhari, Book 15,
Hadith 70 as narrated by Aisha (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) “…….when Abu Bakr came
and spoke to me (Aisha, the wife of Prophet Muhammad) harshly saying, "musical
instruments of Satan near the Prophet?" Prophet Muhammad turned his face towards
him (Abu Bakr) and said (to Abu Bakr), "Leave them alone."…….”
Moderation is what Allah has ordered for the religion
of submission to Allah (Islam).
Extremism (extreme ideas) is the doing of
things that God (Allah) has not ordered.
The Quran warns
mankind not to prohibit what Allah
has not prohibited.
The
Quran repeats 31 times one question in Quran chapter 55: “Which of the
blessings of the Lord do you deny?” so as to warn us against extreme ideas
that come from man and not from the orders of Allah in the Quran.
13. Prophet Muhammad showed that
songs, music and musical instruments are among the blessings of Allah. Bukhari, Book 15,
Hadith 70 is narrated by Aisha (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) that, “Prophet Muhammad came to my house while
two girls were singing beside me the songs of Buath (a story about the war
between the two tribes of the Ansar, the Khazraj and the Aus, before the
time of Islam). Prophet Muhammad lay down and turned his
face to the other side. Then Abu Bakr came and
spoke to me (Aisha, the wife of Prophet Muhammad) harshly saying, "musical
instruments of Satan near the Prophet?" Prophet Muhammad turned his face towards
him (Abu Bakr) and said (to Abu Bakr), "Leave them alone."
Comment. In the house
were singers, musical instruments, Prophet Muhammad, Prophet Muhammad’s wife and 2 girl entertainers
singing and playing musical instruments. The prophet and his
wife are relaxing and listening to the music and the songs from the times
before Islam. Prophet Muhammad was lying down on the bed
or on the floor. Abu Bakr (Prophet Muhammad’s relative) walked in
saying, "musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet?" Prophet Muhammad teaches Abu Bakr that it
is an extreme idea to connect musical instruments with Satin by
telling Abu Bakr to "Leave them alone." (Meaning, "Leave the
people that are singing and playing musical instruments alone." Meaning,
"Let the people that are singing and playing musical instruments continue
singing and playing their musical instruments").
14. God (Allah) wants man and
woman to enjoy all the blessings that Allah has provided.
That is why God (Allah) asks us 31 times:
"Which of the blessings of the Lord (Allah, God) do you deny?"
God (Allah) tells us not to deny his
blessings.
God (Allah) in the completed perfected Quran
does not say that music, songs or musical instruments is prohibited.
15. Who will deny that
music, songs or musical instruments are among the blessings of Allah?
Prophet Muhammad in his conversation with
Abu Bakr teaches Muslims that to say music, songs, singers, entertainers
and musical instruments is not allowed is an extreme view in Islam, the
wrong path in Islam and is not the order of Allah or of Prophet Muhammad.
Prophet Muhammad in his conversation with
Abu Bakr teaches Muslims that to say music, songs, singers, entertainers
and musical instruments is a tool of Satin is an extreme view in Islam, the
wrong path in Islam and is not the order of Allah or of Prophet Muhammad.
Prophet Muhammad in his conversation with
Abu Bakr teaches Muslims that to say music, songs, singers, entertainers
and musical instruments is a tool of the Devil is an extreme view in Islam,
the wrong path in Islam and is not the order of Allah or of Prophet Muhammad.
Moderation is what Allah has ordered for the religion
of submission to Allah (Islam).
Extremism (extreme
ideas) is the doing of things that God (Allah) has not ordered.
16. Some people at the
time of Prophet Muhammad like
some people today felt that denying something to themselves and also
denying it to other people was a sign of righteousness.
The Quran said that is
not correct.
The Quran in chapter
55 says 31 times that the righteous people do not deny for themselves or
for others that which Allah has blessed for them.
Prophet Muhammad was teaching the first
Muslims in Islam the way of worship, belief and behaviour and in Bukhari,
Book 15, Hadith 70, we learn how the first Muslims in Islam unnecessarily
denied for themselves Allah’s blessings and they also
denied the rights of other people to accept Allah’s blessings (Abu Bakr denied himself musical
instruments and then put his belief in harsh words on other people such as
Aisha the wife of Prophet Muhammad).
Abu Bakr was corrected
by Prophet Muhammad who said “leave them
alone (the singers and the players of musical instruments and allow them to
continue the entertainment).”
1400 years later we
today are thankful to Allah (praise Him) who has shown us through Prophet Muhammad (bless him) and Abu Bakr
(bless him) and the examples of other Muslims of the past and present
(bless all the rightly guided) about how they were taught to follow the correct
guidance of Allah.
17. The Quran tells us not to deny Allah’s blessings.
The moderate view in Islam promoted by God
(Allah) in the Quran is that our life is balanced by the duty to worship
the creator (Allah, God) and our responsibility for our parents, family and
children and the laws of the creator which include the welfare of the
environment and not to deny the blessings (of our soul, mind, body,
relationships, knowledge and creativity) that has been given to us by
Allah, God.
18. Like every blessing given
by Allah (God), music, songs and musical instruments must be enjoyed with
moderation.
Moderation means that music is balanced by the
duty to worship the creator (Allah, God), show responsibility for our
family and follow the laws of the creator.
Every allowable action and deed including good
music and songs are a blessing from the Lord (Allah, God) just as good and
kind talk is a blessing from the Lord (Allah, God).
19. Music or Songs with bad
words or bad behaviour is to be avoided just as bad and unkind talk with
bad behavior is to be avoided.
Every Muslim country including Saudi Arabia,
the home of Prophet Muhammad and the largest Muslim nation Indonesia all broadcast
music on radio and TV.
20. The Quran does not prohibit music. It is not allowed to prohibit (make illegal, make forbidden) that which is not prohibited by Allah (God) in the completed perfected Quran.
21. The Quran does
prohibit Muslims from killing each other.
To understand better here is an imaginary
conversation but remember only Allah really knows the future. Those who say music is prohibited
(illegal, forbidden) “might” be asked in the hereafter (Judgment Day), “Why
in your time did you not stop Muslim killing Muslim which is clearly
prohibited by Allah (God) in the Quran instead of telling people that music
was prohibited when there is no such prohibition in the completed and
perfected Quran?”
May Allah (God) forgive my errors and that
which I do not see or understand.
Comments
from readers.
22. Ibrahim from Kuwait asks for a comment on
the following Hadith (story from early Islam):
Sahih
Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v, narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik
Al-Ash'ari that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers
there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the
wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical
instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the
side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with
their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return
to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the
mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys
and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."
And Allah knows best.
Reply
from Sam:
Thank you Ibrahim, see 23 to 38 below.
23. The
interpretation of all Hadith must be in agreement with the word of Allah
(God).
In Sahih
Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v where people will consider
illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic
drinks and the use of musical instruments as lawful describes people that
are having an orgy of sin. An orgy is supported by sexual intercourse, the
wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and music (musical
instruments) all happening at the same time.
Some
take Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v to mean that musical
instruments are illegal but Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith 70 shows that is not
true because Prophet Muhammad stopped Abu Bakr from calling musical instruments a
tool of Satin when Prophet Muhammad was in the house of his
wife Aisha when they were both listening to entertainers that were with
them singing and playing musical instruments in their house.
What
is the real meaning of musical instruments being unlawful in the Hadith
(story from early Islam) Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v
if Prophet Muhammad and his wife were happy
to have people with musical instruments sing and entertaining them in their
house as described in Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v?
24. The
meaning of the story from early Islam (hadith) Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7,
Book 69, Number 494v.
The
meaning of the story when both Hadith are considered is that you are free
to enjoy the blessings from Allah but if you do something that is forbidden like illegal
sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk by men and the drinking of
alcoholic drinks then not only are those things illegal (as ruled in the
Quran) but every other thing (in the Quran or not in the Quran) that is
part of that illegal activity also becomes illegal such as, for example musical instruments. But not only musical instruments, everything involved in that
activity is illegal.
25. The
central message in Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v is that
anything supporting an illegal act becomes itself illegal in Islam.
The central
message of Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v is that when
someone does something illegal (anything illegal) they are really saying
that illegal behavior and illegal action is legal for him or her.
For
example, when one Muslim kills another Muslim he or she is saying this
action is lawful (legal) for me to do.
During
such killing everything that leads to it (the use of technology to promote
killing people, behaviours to kill people, thoughts to kill people,
motivations to kill people and actions to kill people) all become illegal.
For
example, using telephone devices which are normally legal becomes illegal when
used to kill people or for planning to kill people.
Speech
that is normally legal becomes illegal when a voice is used in talking
about the killing of people or in planning to kill people.
Computers
that are normally legal become illegal to use when used to promote the killing
of people or in planning to kill people.
26. Musical
instruments are the same as telephones, computers, the human voice and the
human mind.
Musical
instruments, music and song themselves are not evil and are not illegal in
Islam but they become illegal if they are used with illegal sexual
intercourse, the wearing of silk by men and the drinking of alcoholic
drinks or in promoting the killing of people or when used in any illegal
activity.
27. Legal
musical instruments, telephones and computers in Islam.
The
use of the telephone, the human voice, the computer, the human mind, music,
song, and musical instruments are all legal when used for good and illegal
when used for bad.
28. Hadith
(stories from early Islam) must be explained so they agree with the Quran.
When
the Hadith of Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v is explained
with insight and understanding it is a powerful warning to help people understand
that people who consider Muslim killing Muslim as lawful are incorrect.
The
Hadith of Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v cannot be used
to ban music in Islam because no such ban exists in the Quran and we have
seen in Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith 70 that Prophet Muhammad did not ban musical
instruments, songs, singers, and entertainers from the house of his wife
Aisha.
If the creator made
music (musical instruments) illegal for all time then every person can read
that order in the Quran.
The Quran confirms
that sexual intercourse outside marriage, the wearing of silk by men and
the drinking of alcoholic drinks are all illegal.
The
Quran does not confirm that music (musical instruments) is illegal.
Instead
the Quran says "Which of the many bounties of the Lord do you
deny?" and "Don’t make illegal that which the Lord has not made
illegal (in the Quran)".
The
Hadiths are an important treasurer but they are man made and cannot
overrule the Quran which is God’s (Allah's) word.
Whenever
there is conflict you must follow the Quran because on the Day of Judgment
(remembering that only Allah knows the real future) you “might” be asked why did you
follow what one man said to another (in a Hadith) when you were told by
Prophet Muhammad that the Quran is Allah’s
complete and perfected word and Allah
sent a clear warning that was repeated 31 times in Quran chapter 55 for
those whom Allah willed to see, “Which of the bounties of
your Lord will you deny (meaning, which of all the things that Allah gives you will you deny by saying they did not
come from Allah or by saying that Allah has prohibited things to you that Allah has not prohibited to you)?”
29. The
Quran is the light that removes any doubt.
Hadith
are a man made treasurer because the collected wisdom of Hadith interpreted
in the light of the Quran increases our understanding of practical matters
and decisions that allow us to consider the wide range of interpretations.
Today
everyone can read the accumulated knowledge of Hadith and Quran and Allah
guides each person as he wills.
30. Is the interpretation
correct that songs are sometimes good and sometimes bad just as talk is sometimes
good and sometimes bad?
31. Prophet
Muhammad showed there is bad song
and bad talk and one is not worst than the other.
In Sahih Muslim, Book 33, Hadith 6422,
Abu Huraira reported that the Messenger of Allah said that, Allah
fixed the portion of adultery which a man will indulge in and there is no
escape from it. The adultery of the eye is the lustful look and the
adultery of the ears is listening to voluptuous (sensual pleasure from song or talk) and the adultery of
the tongue is licentious speech and the adultery of the hand is the lustful
grip (embrace) and the adultery of the feet is to walk (to the place) where
he intends to commit adultery and the heart yearns and desires which he may
or may not put into effect.
Comment 1. This Hadith (story from early
Islam) shows that Prophet Muhammad considered that both song and talk to be equally
capable of both good and bad.
Comment 2. Since
song and talk is equally capable of both good and bad this supports the
earlier interpretation of Sahih Al-Bukhari,
Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v, where sometimes
musical instruments are illegal such as when they are used in illegal activities
such as an orgy (that involves illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk by men,
the drinking of alcoholic drinks) however in legal and
appropriate situations musical instruments, song and music are legal.
32. Prophet Muhammad showed by his action and by his words that singing, music, musical instruments and sports are not prohibited in Islam. Watching sports in Islam. Listening to sports in Islam. Playing sports in Islam. Prophet Muhammad listened to music and song and sport. Music, songs and musical instruments in the home of the wife of Prophet Muhammad. Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith 70 is narrated by Aisha (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) who said that, “Prophet Muhammad came to my house while two girls were singing beside me the songs of Buath (a story about the war between the two tribes of the Ansar, the Khazraj and the Aus, before the time of Islam). Prophet Muhammad lay down and turned his face to the other side. Then Abu Bakr came and spoke to me (Aisha, the wife of Prophet Muhammad) harshly saying, "musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet?" Prophet Muhammad turned his face towards him (Abu Bakr) and said (to Abu Bakr), "Leave them (alone)." When Abu Bakr became inattentive, I (Aisha, the wife of Prophet Muhammad) signaled to those girls to go out and they left. It was the day of 'Id, and the Black people were playing with shields and spears; so either I (Aisha) requested the Prophet Muhammad or he (Prophet Muhammad) asked me whether I would like to see the display. I replied “Yes”. Then Prophet Muhammad made me stand behind him and my cheek was touching his cheek and he was saying, "Carry on! O Bani Arfida," until I got tired. Prophet Muhammad asked me, "Are you satisfied (Is that sufficient for you)?" I replied “Yes” and he told me to leave.
Comment.
In Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith
70, the
singing with musical instruments was in the house of Aisha, the wife of Prophet Muhammad. Aisha enjoyed listening
to singing and music with Prophet Muhammad. Prophet Muhammad enjoyed listening to
singing and music with Aisha. Prophet Muhammad was laying down resting
and listening to the singing and music as entertainment. Prophet Muhammad and Aisha listened to
songs about the days before Islam. “Prophet Muhammad lay down and turned his
face to the other side.” This is exactly the same thing that listeners to
music and song do today when they are resting in bed listening to music and
song on the radio.
33. Musical instruments are not the
tool of Satin. Musical instruments are not the
tool of the Devil. Prophet Muhammad showed that musical
instruments are not the tool of Satin. Prophet Muhammad showed that musical
instruments are not the tool of the Devil. Prophet Muhammad showed that musical
instruments are a tool of mankind. In Bukhari, Book 15,
Hadith 70, when musical instruments were described
as the tool of Satin, Prophet Muhammad
rejected this idea and ordered the singers and the music to continue. Prophet Muhammad did not believe that singing, music or musical
instruments where a tool of Satin. To call singing, music or musical
instruments tools of the devil is extreme and Prophet Muhammad did not believe such extreme ideas because Islam is
a religion of moderation.
34. Moderate ideas and
extreme ideas in the time of Prophet Muhammad and the same ideas today. In Bukhari, Book 15,
Hadith 70, the Hadith (story
from early Islam) shows that from the time of Prophet Muhammad until today there are those that understand Islam
as the religion of moderation as shown by Prophet Muhammad and others who have extreme ideas that are
different to the belief of Prophet Muhammad.
Prophet Muhammad was sent to teach and show the first Muslims of
Islam the correct way to think and behave.
We must be thankful that today we
have collected 1400 years of history to study and use to understand the
correct path to Allah
thanks to the examples of those of the past and the wisdom that Allah gives to us today (Allah willing).
Allah guides who are
the people with the moderate ideas that are like Prophet Muhammad and who are the people with different ideas to
those of Prophet Muhammad.
If you discover you have been
misguided then you know that Allah
has shown you His mercy by giving you His (Allah’s) guidance to the right path, Allah willing.
35. Are there other Hadith that do not relate to festivals to
show any change to the attitude of Prophet Muhammad to music, singing songs and musical instruments?
36. Prophet Muhammad recognised that musical instruments were used by the prophets of Allah before him. Prophet Muhammad expressed high respect for musical instruments. Bukhari, Book 61,
Hadith 568, is narrated by Abu Musa, that Prophet Muhammad
said to him' "O Abu Musa, You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the
family of David.”
Comment
1. Bukhari, Book 61,
Hadith 568, is a statement of respect for musical instruments spoken by Prophet Muhammad because Prophet Muhammad recognised those musical instruments as the same
type of musical instruments that were played by the family of David (Prophet
David, Dawud, Dawood, Dawid, King David, David Hamelech, the second king of
Israel).
Comment
2. Prophet Muhammad confirmed that Prophets played musical instruments
before him.
Comment
3. Prophets of Allah do not
use tools of Satin and this confirms what Prophet
Muhammad said in Bukhari, Book 15, Hadith 70, the Hadith (story
from early Islam) where Prophet Muhammad rejected the idea that musical instruments are a
tool of Satin.
Comment 4. When Satin whispers
into the heart, only those that Allah
does not guide shall listen to Satin. Musical instruments have nothing to
do with the powers of Satin because only Allah decides who shall be among the guided
and who shall be among the misguided.
Comment 5. Musical instruments are
a tool of the Prophets of Allah
and of mankind as a blessing from Allah
to man and women.
Comment 6. Prophet Muhammad is telling Abu Musa that the musical instruments that were
given to him was something wonderful not something evil.
37. Prophet Muhammad enjoyed listening to a singer of songs. The people loved the singing so much that they asked Prophet Muhammad if the singer could keep singing longer. Prophet Muhammad said about a singer of songs, "May Allah bestow His Mercy on him." Prophet Muhammad said about a singer of songs, the singer “gets double reward in the hereafter because he obeyed in the way of Allah.” Bukhari, Book 83,
Hadith 29, is narrated by Salama that, We went out with Prophet Muhammad
to Khaibar. A
man (from the companions) said, "O 'Amir, Let us hear some of your
Huda (camel-driving songs.)" So
he sang some of them (as a lyric in harmony with the camels walk). Prophet Muhammad said, "Who is the driver (of these
camels)?" They
said, "Amir." Prophet Muhammad said, "May Allah bestow His Mercy on
him." The
people said, "O Prophet of Allah,
Could you let us enjoy his company longer." Then
'Amir was killed the following morning. The
people said, "The good deeds of 'Amir are lost as he has killed
himself." I
returned at the time while they were talking about that. I
went to Prophet Muhammad and said, "O Allah's Prophet, Let my father be sacrificed for you. The
people claim that 'Amir's good deeds are lost." Prophet Muhammad said, "Whoever says so is a liar, for
'Amir will have a double reward as he exerted himself to obey Allah and fought in Allah's cause. No other way of
killing would have granted him greater reward."
38. Listening to singing was something normal in the life of
Prophet Muhammad.
In
Sahih Muslim, Book 30, Hadith 5743, Anas reported that Prophet Muhammad
had in one of his journeys his black slave who was called Anjasha
along with him. He goaded by singing the songs of the camel-driver. Thereupon Prophet Muhammad said, Anjasha, drive slowly
as you are driving (the mounts that are carrying) glass vessels.
39. Those that say Allah forbids
music in Islam when Allah has made no such prohibition in Allah’s Quran.
Music would not be allowed at the
time of Muslim festivals if music was evil or if Allah prohibited music.
Hadith (Stories from early Islam,
discussed earlier) tell us of Prophet Muhammad and Aisha listening to singers
using musical instruments in Aisha’s house during a Muslim festival).
The lawful in Islam and the unlawful in Islam.
(Interpretations to assist in understanding is contained within brackets).
Quran 7:32, Verse 7:32 Say
(to mankind), “Who has forbidden the adornments (things of beauty) of Allah which
He has created for His servants (mankind) and the good things that He (Allah)
provides (for mankind to see, to hear, to think, to feel, to eat)?” Say, “These
(good things from Allah to mankind) are for the believers in the life of this
world and exclusively for them on the Day of Resurrection. We explain Our
revelations for people who have understanding (because they are the people that
shall profit in this life and in the hereafter from this knowledge).”
Quran 7:33, Verse 7:33 Say (to mankind), “Our Lord has only
forbidden (things like) indecencies such as (indecencies) that can be seen (in
public) or (indecencies) that are hidden, and sin (that comes from disobedience
to Allah) and unjust oppression (to Allah's creations, men, women and
children), and that which you associate with Allah (when you pray to
something or someone instead of praying only to Allah) because no
authority has been revealed (to pray to anyone except Allah your creator),
and to say about Allah things that you do not know (such as Allah prohibited
this or that when you do not know).
What is the greatest sin against Allah in Islam?
Quran 6:21, Verse 6:21 And
who commits a greater sin than he who invents a lie against Allah (by saying
that Allah ordered things that He did not order such as you can pray to anyone
when in fact only Allah has the power to hear prayer) or denies His
revelations (by saying that Allah ordered things that Allah did not order
in what Allah has described as His completed and protected Quran)? Those
wrongdoers shall not be successful (in the hereafter). Quran 10:59 Verse 10:59 Say,
"Did you think about how Allah sends down to you all kinds of provisions
(everything that exists) and then you make some of them unlawful, and some
lawful?" Say, "Did Allah give you permission to do this? Or, do you
invent lies and then say it is an order from Allah?"
Quran 10:60 Verse 10:60 And those who invent a lie concerning
Allah what do they think will be their situation on the Day of Resurrection?
Allah truly sends all Bounty (everything that exists) to mankind, but most of
them (mankind) give no thanks (to Allah).
40. Those that say Allah forbids watching
sport in Islam or playing sport in Islam when Allah has made no such
prohibition in Allah’s Quran.
Sport would not be allowed at the
time of Muslim festivals if sport was evil or if God (Allah) prohibited sport.
Hadith (Stories from early Islam)
tell us that Prophet Muhammad and Aisha specially left their home to go to watch
a sports game during a Muslim festival and Prophet Muhammad cheered "Carry on! O
Bani Arfida" urging the African sport players to
continue their traditional sports games. (See comment 32 above).
In Bukhari, Book 55,
Hadith 592 Narrated by Salama bin Al-Akwa that, Prophet Muhammad passed
by some people from the tribe of Aslam practicing archery (throwing arrows) and
Prophet Muhammad said, "O offspring of Ishmael (Ismael, Ismail, Isma'il, Yismael), practice archery (throwing arrows) as your father
was a great archer (arrow-thrower). I am with (on the side of) the son of so
and so." Hearing that, one of the two teams stopped throwing. Prophet Muhammad
asked them, “Why are you not throwing?" They replied, "O messenger of
God (Allah), How shall we throw when you are with (supporting) the opposite
team?" Prophet Muhammad said, "Throw, I am with all of you."
The other comments about music and musical
instruments also apply to Sport.
Index
for Music, song, musical instruments, sports are
not prohibited, not haram, not forbidden in Islam using Arabic names.
Index
for Is song, music and musical
instruments, sport legal, allowed, prohibited, haram, forbidden in Islam?
1. Quran 6:87, Quran 16:116, Quran 16:117 Allah does not allow man to prohibit what Allah has not
prohibited in the Quran.
2. Allah asks mankind 31 times in Quran chapter 55, “From everything that Allah has provided to you which of
them do you deny?” (What do you say is not from Allah? or What do you say Allah
has prohibited to you when in fact it is not prohibited to you by Allah?).
3. Quran 6:21 from Allah
about man inventing prohibitions and then saying that the prohibition is
from Allah.
4. Quran 6:140 from Allah
about those that prohibit what Allah
has given to mankind.
5. Quran 6:144 from Allah
about those that have no evidence from Allah’s Quran for what they say is prohibited by Allah.
6.
Quran 5:101 from Allah about asking questions about
things that are not in the Quran.
7.
Quran 5:101 from Allah about people that prohibit
things for themselves and later other people say it was Allah that prohibited it.
8.
Quran 3:94 from Allah about those that continue to
say that something that Allah
did not prohibit in Allah’s
Quran, is prohibited.
9. The Holy book
of Allah (God) is the Quran. 10. Where is music banned (made forbidden,
prohibited by Allah) in the perfected (completed) Quran?
11. The Quran
warns against extreme ideas.
12. Musical instruments
near Prophet Muhammad.
13. Prophet Muhammad showed that
songs, music and musical instruments are among the blessings of Allah.
14. God (Allah) wants man and woman to enjoy
all the blessings that Allah has provided. 15. Who will deny that music,
songs or musical instruments are among the blessings of Allah? 16. Some people at the time of
Prophet Muhammad like some people today felt that denying something
to themselves and also denying it to other people was a sign of
righteousness.
17.
The Quran tells us not to deny Allah’s
blessings. 18. Like every blessing given by Allah (God),
music, songs and musical instruments must be enjoyed with moderation.
19. Music or Songs with bad words or bad
behaviour is to be avoided just as bad and unkind talk with bad behavior is
to be avoided.
20. The Quran does not prohibit
music.
21. The Quran does prohibit
Muslims from killing each other. 22. Ibrahim from Kuwait writes for a comment on the following Hadith
(story from early Islam):
23. The
interpretation of all Hadith must be in agreement with the word of Allah
(God).
24. The meaning
of the story from early Islam (hadith) Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69,
Number 494v.
25. The central
message in Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 69, Number 494v is that
anything supporting an illegal act becomes itself illegal in Islam.
26. Musical
instruments are the same as telephones, computers, the human voice and the
human mind.
27. Legal musical
instruments, telephones and computers in Islam.
28. Hadith
(stories from early Islam) must be explained so they agree with the Quran.
29. The Quran is
the light that removes any doubt.
30. Is the
interpretation correct that songs are sometimes good and sometimes bad just as talk
is sometimes good and sometimes bad?
31. Prophet Muhammad showed there is bad song and bad talk and one is
not worst than the other.
32. Prophet Muhammad showed by his action and by his words that singing, music, musical instruments and sports are not prohibited in Islam.
Watching sports in Islam.
Listening to sports in Islam.
Playing sports in Islam. Prophet Muhammad listened to music and song and sport. Music, songs and musical instruments in the home of the wife of Prophet Muhammad.
33. Musical instruments are not the tool of Satin.
34. Moderate ideas and extreme
ideas in the time of Prophet Muhammad and
the same ideas today.
35. Are there other Hadith that do
not relate to festivals to show any change to the attitude of Prophet Muhammad to music, singing songs and musical instruments?
36. Prophet Muhammad recognised that musical instruments were used by
the prophets of Allah before him. Prophet Muhammad expressed high respect for musical instruments.
37. Prophet Muhammad enjoyed listening to a singer of songs.
38.
Listening to singing was something normal in the life of Prophet Muhammad. 39. Those that say
Allah forbids music in Islam when Allah has made no such prohibition in Allah’s
Quran.
40. Those that say Allah
forbids watching sport in Islam or playing sport in Islam when Allah has made
no such prohibition in Allah’s Quran.
Interpretations of the Quran (Al-Quran,
Al Quran).
(The Coran, Al-Coran, Al Coran, The
Koran, Al-Koran, Al Koran, The Qur'an, Al-Qur'an, Al
Qur'an, The Qur’ān, Al-Qur’ān, Al Qur’ān).
This is an interpretation of some of the
meanings in the Quran.
This is not a perfect translation of the Quran because the Quran is in the
Arabic language.
The Arabic language in the Quran must be understood as it was understood
over 1400 years ago.
Allah guides who he wills to
the correct understanding of the Quran.
In the English language the word Allah is God.
Allah (God) is the creator of the Jews, Christians, Muslims and
everyone and everything that exists.
Praise is to Allah (God) and blessings to
all whom are His rightly guided.
Forgive me for my errors,
misinterpretations, misunderstands and omissions.
Corrections and questions are welcome and can be emailed to
somaliahamradio@yahoo.com
|