Getting Scammed

Or how I met a Nigerian, was sent some artwork in the form of a cashier's check, talked to the FBI and was fully entertained for $0 

We have a small apartment we rent out on the Maine shore. You have probably come from that web page but if not, it's here.  On 5/8/08 we received this inquiry:

Arrival :: June-21-2008
Departure :: June-28-2008

Inquiry :: Hello,

I am planning a 7 nights honeymoon vacation with my wife. I will like to know if
we can use your place for 7 nights in June 21-28. Let me know the cost and the 
deposit to be made.I will also like to know the amenities attached to the property.
We do not smoke nor drink neither do we have pets.

Are you the owner or an agent?

Regards
Chad Mercer
 
I thought, hmm, isn't it strange he would be speaking of his wife instead of his fiancee or girlfriend? Also the strange word order reminded me of one of those Nigerian money laundering scams I'm always getting. I wrote back the details and he sent this:
 
Hello

I have discussed this with my Wife and we have decided to use the
apartment for the dates and as for the cost , we are alright with
it.Kindly get back to us with the deposit to be made to secure our
booking,My Wife's employers will be the one responsible for all our
our vacation expenses as a wedding gift and they have promised to send
you a certified cheque as soon as you have penned these dates down for
us. Kindly email me your full name, address, home and cell phone
number so thatthe payment can be mailed out to you soon.

This is our details for the booking.

Name : Chad Mercer

Address : [deleted]
Lansdowne Lane,Charlton
London,SE7 8JE
Phone : 07024020183

Waiting to read from you.

Regards
Chad Mercer
 
"Penned down these dates"? I had already sent very specific dates to him. It seemed as 
 if he was emailing a bunch of people and getting confused. "Waiting to read from you."
 Doesn't sound English to me. I sent him the other info he wanted. He wrote back:
 
 Hello,Thank you for the message.I just printed out the form and i will
mail it via regular mail and that should get to you in few days.I just
called my wife's employer whos the check will br coming from and he
said the check will be coming from US BANK.He livesin NY..and the
payment will be mail out to you asap.Kindly confirm your details as
below?


Payable Name : Bruce Gillett
Address : [our mailing address]
I waot to hear from you and thank you for your kind.


Regards
Chad
 
I thought it odd that he would say "regular mail". Later I found out that no scammers
use the US mail because that exposes them to the risk of getting busted for mail fraud.
It also seemed to me that his command of English was starting to falter, like he was 
getting outside of his normal correspondence. Also, I use no form, so what's this stuff
about "printed out the form"? I was waiting for the shoe to drop. I didn't have long to wait:
 
 

Hello,

I am glad to inform you that the payment has been mailed to you and will get to you soon. However,there is a mistake on the cheque..instead of  $727.60 for the total deposit it was written as $3,220 our feeding and traveling expenses was included in the cheque for our booking. This was suppose to come in a different cheque and not in the one for our booking.But since it has been sent, just deduct the full cost of our booking and send the remainder to us using Western Union money tranfer so that we can make all necessary things we need to do with it pending the time of our arrival.We will take the western union charges toward sending the money to us.I hope you understand this and we can be able to depend on you.We are so worried!!!Regards from my wife
My regards to all the members of your family.

We can't wait to be there.

Regards
Chad Mercer

Now we were in familiar territory! The old Nigerian Scam. Oddly, I felt a sense of relief. It was all making sense. Notice that he said he had already mailed it. I cleared his visit from our calendar but I couldn't resist playing along. I wrote back:

 Woops! I guess I need to know your address and how to send it. Should I send it to your London address? Don't worry! Bruce

He wrote back: 

We recieve a contact from the UPS Courier regarding the delievery of the payment and we were told that it will get to you by today with the tracking number xxxxxxxxx. You can check the status on there website to know what time you will recieve it.It is in the amount of $3,220.00 dollars,You are to deduct the full cost of our booking 727.60 from the total amount recieved and send the remainder $2492.4 to us via western union.We have other plans we will be using the money for in getting our flight tickect.Tickect are not easy to get at this period of time.My wife is in kansas at the moment and will be leaving for london in a couple of days so i advise you send the money to her because i will be busy doing other things regarding our wedding and also to limit the western union money transfer charges toward sending to london.
We are aware of thier charges.All you need to do is deduct the western union charges from the total amount left ($2492.4) after the deduction of our booking and get the remainder sent to us with her details bellow.


Reciever's Name : Kenneth Long

Reciever's City : Garnett

Reciever's State :Kansas

Reciever's Zip Code : 66032

This are the details you will be needing to get the different send to us via western union transfer.

You are to get back to us with the 10 Digits(MTCN CODE) Number you where giving at the western union outlet as the confirmation number that the money as been sent including the total amount sent after the deduction of the western union charges.

We appreciate your effort toward making our honeymoon a successful one.

Regards
Chad Mercer

Sure enough, the  check was not coming by US mail but UPS. I checked the tracking and saw that it would arrive the next day. I also noticed that the tracking info said the envelope was mailed a day and a half after Chad told me of the mistake on the check. I started to phone law enforcement agencies to ask them how we could catch this crook but no one seemed interested. They just said to ignore him or tear up the check. Certainly, I would not be sending any money to Chad's wife Kenneth! I felt a certain satisfaction at least that Chad had actually spent some money on this scam. I was ahead in this game!

I thought the game would be over as soon as Chad saw that I rejected the UPS delivery through the tracking info.  Although I really wanted to see the bogus check, I decided that refusing the shipment would be the best way to end this caper. My bank informed me that phony cashier's checks will not say "void" all over them when photocopied like the legitimate ones do. She also told me that I could bring it in for her to see; she said she could spot a phony check easily. However I also learned that some cashier's checks are very well forged and that if drawn on a real but stolen account, will take more than a week to be determined as bogus. I think I made the right move in rejecting the shipment. The next day Chad wrote:

 What is going on?

I wrote back:

 Much quicker to send it back. It would have taken a long time for the check to clear.

Next thing I know, he calls me up! I was walking to the mailbox at the time so my wife tells him I'll be right back. In the meantime he sends me this email:

Hello,How are you today?Thank you for the message.I just called you and i talked to some one telling me you just walk away and will be back in few minutes.I will try and call back.Kindly go ahead and deposited the check because the funds as been made available to your name and get back to us with the date the money will be available at your bank.Thank you for your kindness. We do appreciate your kind toward making our honeymoon a successful one. 

Regards Chad

I'm thinking, "Man this guy is either stupid or he just doesn't give up" After thinking about it, I realized he had made an investment in a forged check and a UPS overnight, so I guess it was normal for him to pretend that I didn't really refuse the shipment. Just to make sure, I sent this:

Chad, I refused delivery. The check is going back to the return address.

But then soon after, the phone rang. It was Chad calling from a loooooong way off. He tells me how hurt he is that I refused his check and that he has no way to get it back. I tried to explain the concept of a return address and how his envelope had one and how when shipments can't be made...but I couldn't get a word in edgewise. He said I told him I agreed to send him the money, but I never agreed to send him any Western Union money, I just said "Don't worry" and offered to mail it back. He went on to tell about how his honeymoon (with Kenneth?) would be ruined and I was to blame and then asked me what I was going to do about it. When I finally heard a pause I said, "Nothing". He continued to rail against me and ended up with "I hate you, I hate you, I hate you!" I said, "OK, see ya later, Bye." That was the end. Just for fun, I went back to the tracking info and found, as I totally expected, the return address was bogus: (UPS forbids copying their info, so this is rearranged and retyped:)

 5/14/2008      The receiver did not want the order and refused this delivery/ Returned to shipper

Brewer, ME    Departure Scan

(several more stops and finally)

5/15/2008    A correct company or receiver name is needed for delivery. UPS is attempting to obtain this                      information/returned to shipper.

Chester, NY, US     9:05 pm

Conclusion: Unless you have a perverse sense of humor like me, watch out for rental inquiries with bad spelling, flowery language, emotional hooks, constantly traveling customers and most importantly, NEVER accept a check for more than the required amount and NEVER NEVER send money back by wire. And by the way, if you are a scam artist (and I do have respect for their abilities, it really is art), go somewhere else, you haven't a chance with me! Bruce


UPDATE 7/11/08:

It seems the Chad Mercer story will never go away! People who were in the process of getting scammed by our tormentor googled his phone number and found this page. Here are a few of the emails I've gotten:

  •  
    Hi Bruce,

    Thank you for posting info on Chad, the Nigerian scammer. I have a rental here in California and received his first inquiry this morning. I was suspicious right away so I googled his phone number and that's when I found your posting and read about his antics.

    I sent an email to the company where my rental is listed to let them know he's probably emailing all of the property owners with the same message. Hopefully, they get the word out to the other owners ASAP.

    What has me angry is that I can't find a single agency that will go after these low-life scum-bags who use so much creative energy to rip people off when they could be doing something productive instead.

    Hopefully, other's will Google his phone number too and not get caught up in his hype. I don't understand why there isn't an agency pursuing these people, especially when they're using addresses in the US? I think UPS needs to have the same rules as the USPS when it comes to mail fraud.

    Thanks again for posting your experience with this scammer. 
    •  

      Thank you so much for posting the “honeymoon scam”  -  I found your page by Goggling the phone #! 

      I had a feeling that something was amiss and your web page really helped me out.  Just wanted to email you and let you know that your internet advice was appreciated and utilized.
    •  

      Hi Bruce,

       

      The emails (2 of them) we almost identical but now “he” is Ciara West.  Thanks again for being a good internet neighbor.
    •  
      Hi Bruce-
      We have rental property in California - advertised online. had a rental
      inquiry today that didn't look right. googled the phone # and came up with
      your chad mercer/scammer info at
      http://seacatsrest.googlepages.com/gettingscammed. i probably wouldn't have
      responded to our inquiry anyway but i did enjoy reading about your
      adventure. thanks for posting it.
      • Bruce!

         

        You rock!  

         

        I didn’t like the language in this guy’s inquiry and started searching. He inquired about one of our homes  (www.vrbo.com/*****). I also googled his phone number to find your awesome account and strategy to squeeze information out of a crook and beat him at his own game.  

         

        Seems if enough of us asked him to send checks and then returned them, eventually he’ll spend all that stolen money on UPS!  Perhaps we should buy stock in UPS before we begin the scam.  ;-)

         

        Thanks again for your detailed account!  
      • Hi Bruce,

        Thanks for the info on your website.  He just approached us as Cole Smith.  Unusual name for someone who can’t write English!  It started to sound strange in the second email, so I googled his info.  Same strategy – honeymoon, “wife’s” employer, certified check.  Thanks!
         
       
      Some of you have also forwarded "Chad's" message text. Here are a few: 
      • From: ray.schultz1992@gmail.com [mailto:ray.schultz1992@gmail.com]
        Sent: Thursday, July 10, 2008 4:26 PM
        To: ***********
        Subject: FindVacationRentals.com Listing *** Inquiry [Ray Schultz]


        FindVacationRentals.com Rental Inquiry

        Name: Ray Schultz
        Email: ray.schultz1992@gmail.com
        Telephone: 07024020183
        Arrival: July 19, 2008
        Departure: July 26, 2008
        Adults: 02
        Comments:
        Hello, I am planning a 7 nights honeymoon vacation with my wife. I will like
        to know if we can use your place for 7 nights in july 19-26. Let me know the
        cost and the deposit to be made.I will also like to know the amenities
        attached to the property.

        We do not smoke nor drink neither do we have pets. Are you the owner or an
        agent?

        Regards
        Schultz
      •  
        Listing: Great Cabin / Reasonable Rates! 
        Cabin URL: 
        Desired Arrival Date: july 19,2008 
        Length of Stay: 7
        Number in Party: 2 of Adults & 0 of Children
        Name: Donald Schultz
        Email Address: donald.schultz6@gmail.com
        Telephone: 07024020183
        Questions and Comments: Hello, I am planning a 7 nights honeymoon vacation with my wife. I will like to know if we can use your place for 7 nights in july
        19-26. Let me know the cost and the deposit to be made.I will also like to know
        the amenities attached to the property.

        We do not smoke nor drink neither do we have pets. Are you the owner or an
        agent?

        Regards
        Donald Schultz 
         
        Have any stories about this character? Email me at seacatsrest@gmail.com
        I may quote unidentifiable parts of your emails here unless you tell me otherwise. Bruce 
       Finally, not all scams seem to come from the same person. Here are a few more:

         

Subject: New Enquiry from www.directholidaylets.com
Date: Sun, 27 Jul 2008 05:32:24 +0100
From: Direct Holiday Lets - Automated Email<meetjamesfleet@yahoo.co.uk>

 

Property: View ID: 571
Full Name: James Fleet
Email: meetjamesfleet@yahoo.co.uk
Phone: +447
Message: let me know if you still have availability for sept 5th to 11th 2008.I will also like to know the rates and deposit. we are non smoker and we do not have pet. meetjamesfleet@yahoo.co.uk

I was suspicious about the non smoker and pet line as it was the same as Chad's. The clincher was when my reply bounced back, no such address! Here's another:

      

lw.tyler@yahoo.com
+ 1 866-666-8992
Nov 1 2008
Nov 6 2008
1 (including children)
0
Good day I have two members from our board of directors coming on
vacation with their spouses no children please. I would like to know
how much it would cost for them to stay in your place during this
period. It is going to be a total of four people,if you do not have an
accommodation for four people let me know what you have and we can
work something out.They will be staying for five days
November1-November5.How much would it cost? and also let me know what
discount we can receive. I would like to have an accommodation
reserved and paid for as soon as possible because planning ahead is
the key of successful vacation. Thanks Tyler L.W lw.tyler@yahoo.com
    Not to put too fine a point on it, but November in Maine is like standing in the dark and being sprayed with cold water, not exactly a "successful vacation". 
 I responded to this guy in the usual way along with:
any payments in excess of the required amount
will be returned by mail and not deposited.

          And never heard back. Is this all? I doubt it! Google your inquiries!