Home

FLL Research Project

Climate Issue: Urban Heat Islands

An Urban Heat Island is the name given to describe the characteristic warmth of both the atmosphere and surfaces in cities (urban areas) compared to their (non-urbanized) surroundings. The heat island is an example of unintentional climate modification when urbanization changes the characteristics of the Earth's surface and atmosphere.
I got this definition from:
http://www.actionbioscience.org/enviroment/voogt.html

Picture Showing Urban Heat Island Effect


This picture came from http://www.technovelgy.com/graphics/content06/heat-island.jpg

Heat Island Facts

  • Urban heat islands can make it hotter in the city
  • Both the air and city surfaces can be hotter.
  • Solar heat adds to surface temperatures.
  • The warmest air is found downtown.  - Because most of the buildings and parking lots are downtown, and it is usually the center of the city.
  • Dry, dark surfaces absorb more sunlight.  - Dark surfaces such as asphalt roads and parking lots absorb more sunlight and become much warmer than light-colored surfaces.
  • Certain structures and city geometry favor heat islands. - These are thick walled buildings that are slow to warm and cool, and so they store a lor of heat.
  • Storm Water runs off instead of being filtering through the ground.  Covering the ground with waterproof surfaces makes it dryer and keeps the rain from cooling it down. Also the storm water doesn't filter through the ground and it carries pollutants directly in to streams and waterways.
  • Storm Water run off can cause flooding

 

How This Hurts People

  • Higher daytime temperatures & slower nighttime cooling Can affect human health by making people miserable, causing respiratory difficulties, heat cramps and exhaustion, non-fatal heat stroke, and heat-related deaths.
  • Heat islands can make heat waves last longer Children, older adults and those with existing health problems suffer most.

Solutions for Heat Islands That Already Exist

  • Green roofs Another alternative to traditional roofing materials is a rooftop garden, or "green roof". On hot summer days, the surface temperature of a vegetated rooftop can be up to 90 degrees Fahrenheit (50 degrees Celsius) cooler.
  • Cool Pavements Cool paving does not get as hot. There are two types of cool paving materials: lighter-colored materials and porous materials (porous means the water goes through). Lighter-colored materials reflect the sun's energy and stay cooler. Lighter-colored materials come in shades of white, beige. light gray and terra cotta.
  • Plant trees and plants Increasing the cover of trees and vegetation in a city is a simple and effective way to reduce the urban heat island effect. Trees provide a wide range of other benefits, from increasing property value to reducing storm water runoff.
  • Use less energy This reduces smog
  • Light Colored Roofs Light colored roofs reflect the sunlight back up and do not absorb as much heat.
  • Some things we can't change: Some of these factors, like prevailing weather patterns, geography, and pollution transported from up-wind regions, are largely beyond the influence of local policy. However we can affect all of the ones listed above.

Brainstorming a Solution

Our team gathered and we came with these solutions:  Simon came up with solar powered wind mills (if we put them to the West of town they would blow the hot air away like ocean breezes do for towns on the coast). Max kept saying we should all plant trees.  Other ideas were to go with: porous pavement, cool pavement, green roofs (or walls), or planting trees and plants.

So we decided to ask an expert.

Dr. James Voogt

Dr.Voogt is an Associate Professor in the Department of Geography at the University of Western Ontario in Canada. He says "My academic training is in physical geography and boundary layer climatology and meteorology. My current research combines surface and boundary layer meteorology and climatology with remote sensing and GIS. It focuses on the importance of the surface." We got a lot of our information from his web sites. He agreed to email back and forth with us and help us with our questions.
His school web page is:
http://geography.uwo.ca/faculty/voogtj/

The Email to Dr. Voogt

For the email to Dr. Voogt we all wrote down our questions and then Kaisa and Deja sent him the email. Our questions were: 1) The solutions seem to be porous pavement, cool pavement, green roofs, planting trees and plants, and using less energy. 2) If we could only do one which would make the biggest difference? 3) Would solar powered windmills work to blow heat away from the city like ocean breeze heat from the coast? 4) If everyone planted a tree which kind of tree would be best for the urban area? 5) Are there any cities where something has been done and it worked? 6) What are those cities and how did they know it worked?

He answered all our questions (see attached document). He said planting trees made the most difference, and our windmills idea was interesting, but not efficient. He told us we needed to research trees for our area, and that there were cities where they thought it had made a difference, but there was not a lot of research yet.

The Best Choice is Planting Trees

The reason that he made this choice is that for many cities plants provide multiple benefits, not just reduction of air temperature. Trees and plants typically reduce daytime air temperature because some of the energy they receive is used to transpire water, rather than heating the air. They also create shade which can be important for cooling surfaces or building in a city. Other advantages of trees and plants are to filter the air of some pollution particles, and providing habitat for other animals, or acting as source of food (for some plants). Trees and plants can also provide important benefits in cities where there is a cold winter and warm summer. Trees that lose their leaves can allow buildings to receive sunlight in the winter when they need it to offset heating costs. Evergreen trees can be used as windbreaks to help reduce the heat lose from cold northerly winds.
 
Cincinnati has a Climate Protection Action Plan
Cincinnati has a "Climate Protection Action Plan" called the "Green Cincinnati Plan". So far they are wanting to offer grants and loans to people and businesses that want to install green roofs. They also plan to plant more trees in the city. This plan is a proposal. They recommend a lot of other things that are environmentally friendly. The news articles we found said that Cincinnati would like to become a leader in green roofs. You can find the plan on their web site if you really look for it. You can see the actual plan at: http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/cmgr/downloads/cmgr_pdf18280.pdf
 

How Chicago Reduces Urban Heat Island Effect

Chicago has an official plan in place to reduce the Urban Heat Island Effect. The information below is from their web site.

Reducing the Urban Heat Island Effect

There are two main ways to reduce the Urban Heat Island effect: replace dark-colored surfaces (such as black tar roofs and asphalt parking lots) with light-colored surfaces, and increase vegetation. Light-colored roofs and paving materials reflect light and heat, making the surrounding area cooler than when dark-colored roofs and paving are used. Adding vegetation to an urban area helps clean and cool the air, and trees can be located to shade asphalt roads and parking lots.
The City of Chicago has used these strategies in a variety of ways to reduce the Urban Heat Island effect. Projects include the rooftop garden on City Hall, a permeable and reflective alley on the North Side, miles of median planters and many campus parks that transform asphalt parking lots around public schools into parks. The City of Chicago also uses green building technologies and practices in all of its public building projects. Additionally, Chicago has enacted legislation to require landscaping around parking lots and require more energy-efficient building practices.

What You Can Do to Reduce the Urban Heat Island Effect

Consider using light-colored, reflective materials when repairing or replacing the roof on your building. If you are building or repairing a driveway, consider using concrete or other reflective materials. Plant trees on your property to increase the shading of buildings and parking lots, and increase the amount of vegetation overall, if possible. Use rain gardens and other storm water management techniques to capture rainwater on your property, so that it is absorbed into the ground instead of diverted into the sewer system; doing so will increase the amount of moisture in the air, providing cooling.

This information came from:
http://egov.cityofchicago.org/
 

Our Solution - Porous Parking Lots and Trees

We wanted to choose the one thing that would make the most difference. We chose to:

Replace asphalt parking lots with porous parking lots, and to plant trees in the parking lots using silva cells to keep the ground from becoming compacted

We got this picture from: http://www.landscapeonline.com/products/listing.php?id=4306 

To see a movie explaining porous pavement and sivla cells click HERE



The Benefits

  • Grass covered parking lots do not absorb as much heat
  • Trees provide shade for buildings and cars
  • Water now filters through ground and roots, reducing storm water run off
  • Each mature tree reduces atmospheric carbon by 903 pounds per year

 

Every Mature Tree* Will Provide the Following


  • Reduce atmospheric carbon by 903 pounds
  • Eliminate 10,996 gallons of storm water runoff
  • Conserve 289 Kilowatt hours of electricity for cooling and reduce consumption of oil or natural gas by 8 therms.
  • Absorbing pollutants like ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide through their leaves
  • Intercept particulate matter like dust, ash, and smoke
  • Release oxygen through photosynthesis
  • Lower Air temperature which reduces the production of ozone
  • Reduce energy use and subsequent pollutant emission from power plants.
  • itree tools.com For our example we used a mature sugar maple, 30 inches in diameter. We chose a sugar maple based on the a pamphlet called "Recommended Street Trees" that we got from the Clermont County Soil and Water District. Data came from the “Tree Benefits Calculator" at itreetools.com

 

Sharing

To share our information we gave our presentation to our teachers and put up a poster presentation for the whole school.

We also wrote Cincinnati Mayor Mallory explaining our research and how trees reduce the Urban Heat Island Effect. We thought he would be interested because Cincinnati wants to see green roofs on building tops and plans to offer financial incentives to property owners to replace tar and shingles with vegetation. It might be cheaper to give money to people to buy trees.

We also emailed the team Cyberthunder in Chattanooga, TN and told them our solution. For their solution they came up with the idea of a water powered lawnmower. It would use the water to make hydrogen and the engine would run on hydrogen and would reduce pollution.

Sources

These are just some of the places we got our information from.

 

Č
ĉ
ď
Jolene Esz,
Dec 3, 2008 5:13 AM
ć
ď
Max.ppt
(40k)
Jolene Esz,
Dec 3, 2008 10:22 AM