Recent site activity

Maryland Speed Camera Legislative Score-Card



In 2009 the General Assembly voted to authorize speed cameras statewide in Maryland. Since 2006 the cameras had previously been authorized in Montgomery County only.  The bill which authorized this was SB277.  SB277 authorized speed cameras in ‘school zones’ (which has been liberally interpreted by local governments to mean MOST local roads and state highways and has resulted in the creation of vast numbers of new school zones not adjacent to schools and even the lowering of some speed limits), and on freeways with speed limits greater than 45mph, including interstate highways, in temporary "work zones", "regardless of whether workers are present". It also established the low burden of proof, lack of oversight, and weak standards which exist under the current law, which in the opinion of the authors of this site contributed to cases of denial of due process and camera errors which are documented on the the StopBigBrotherMD.org website.   SB277 passed and became effective October 1, 2009.  SB277 was signed and personally championed by Governor Martin O'Malley.

ScoreCard:


For the 'ratings' column in the chart below the lowest(worst) value is -4 the highest(best) is +4 (green = good, red=bad).  Two of the items used in our ratings are the following:

SB277: 2009 legislation authorizing statewide speed cameras.  'Y' means they supported speed cameras (-2), 'N' means they opposed speed cameras (+2).  (H) applies to those senators who were in the house of delegates at the time of the vote and cast a vote there.  '---' means no vote is recorded (either did not vote or were not in office at the time).  'SPONSOR' means they were one of the bill's principal supporters (-3).  This bill is the primary reason there are statewide speed cameras today and identifies those lawmakers most directly responsible for this.

SB30/HB904:  2011 Legislation which would have imposed the modest restriction on 'workzone' speed cameras that workers actually be present at the time.  Current law permits speed cameras in workzones 'regardless or whether workers are present' and approximately 70% of tickets are issues when there is no work taking place.  The legislation was killed in committee so legislators were not permitted to vote on it.   'SPONSOR' means they were one of the bill's principal supporters (+1).  Y or N votes are only for those on the committee which voted on it.  'Y' means they supported the legislation (+1), 'N' means they opposed it.

An additional plus or minus 1-2 points were awarded to some lawmakers who made specific efforts either for or against photo enforcement.

Click HERE to find your legislative district and your representatives' contact information.  
Contact
 StopBigBrotherMD@gmail.com  to report an error.

State Senate:

District

Name

County

Party

Rating:

SB277 (2009, Statewide Speed Cameras)

SB30/HB904(2010, limiting workzone cameras)

Notes

1

George C. Edwards

Allegany, Garrett, and Washington

R

+2

N

---

 

2

Christopher B. Shank

Washington

R

+3

N(H)

---

 

3

Ronald N. Young

Frederick and Washington

D

no rating

---

---

 

4

David R. Brinkley

Carroll and Frederick

R

+2

N

---

 

5

Joseph M. Getty

Baltimore County and Carroll

R

no rating

---

---

 

6

Norman R. Stone, Jr.

Baltimore County

D

+3

N

SPONSOR

 

7

JB Jennings

Baltimore County and Harford

R

no rating

---

---

 

8

Katherine A. Klausmeier

Baltimore County

D

-3

SPONSOR

---

 

9

Allan H. Kittleman

Carroll and Howard

R

+4

N

---

 

10

Delores G. Kelley

Baltimore County

D

+2

N

---

 

11

Robert Zirkin

Baltimore County

D

0

Y

SPONSOR

 

12

Edward J. Kasemeyer

Baltimore County and Howard

D

-2

Y

---

 

13

James N. Robey

Howard

D

-3

SPONSOR

---

 

14

Karen S. Montgomery

Montgomery

D

-2

Y(H)

---

 

15

Robert J. Garagiola

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

16

Brian E. Frosh

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

17

Jennie Forehand

Montgomery

D

-3

SPONSOR

---

 

18

Rich Madaleno, Jr.

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

19

Roger Manno

Montgomery

D

-2

Y(H)

---

 

20

Jamie Raskin

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

21

James Rosapepe

Anne Arundel and Prince George's

D

-3

Y

---

Sen Rosapepe proposed legislation which would have essentially removed police oversight from speed cameras.

22

Paul G. Pinsky

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

23

Douglas J.J. Peters

Prince George's

D

-3

SPONSOR

---

 

24

Joanne C. Benson

Prince George's

D

-2

Y(H)

---

 

25

Ulysses Currie

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

26

C. Anthony Muse

Prince George's

D

-3

Y

---

sponsored other pro camera legislation

27

Thomas V. Mike Miller, Jr.

Calvert and Prince George's

D

-4

SPONSOR

---

 

28

Thomas M. "Mac" Middleton

Charles

D

-2

Y

---

 

29

Roy Dyson

Calvert, Charles, and St. Mary's

D

+2

N

---

 

30

John Astle

Anne Arundel

D

+2

N

---

 

31

Bryan Simonaire

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

32

James E. DeGrange, Sr.

Anne Arundel

D

+3

N

---

 

33

Edward R. Reilly

Anne Arundel

R

+1

---

---

 

34

Nancy Jacobs

Cecil and Harford

R

+3

N

SPONSOR

 

35

Barry Glassman

Harford

R

+2

N

---

 

36

E. J. Pipkin

Caroline, Cecil, Kent, and Queen Anne's

R

+4

N

---

 

37

Richard F. Colburn

Caroline, Dorchester, Talbot, and Wicomico

R

+2

N

---

 

38

James N. Mathias, Jr

Somerset, Wicomico, and Worcester

D

-2

Y(H)

---

 

39

Nancy J. King

Montgomery

D

-3

Y

---

In 2009 Nancy King changed her vote on statewide speed cameras from N to Y under pressure from the administration.   Hers was a key vote in passing statewide speed cameras.

40

Catherine E. Pugh

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

41

Lisa A. Gladden

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

42

James Brochin

Baltimore County

D

+4

N

SPONSOR

Brochin sponsored legislation which would have require 'workzone' speed cameras to actually have workers present.

43

Joan Carter Conway

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

44

Verna L. Jones

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

45

Nathaniel J. McFadden

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

46

William Ferguson

Baltimore City

D

no rating

---

---

 

47

Victor R. Ramirez

Prince George's

D

-2

Y(H)

---

 



House of Delegates:

District

Name

County(s)

Party

Rating ( -3=worst, +3=best )

SB277 (2009, Statewide Speed Cameras)

SB30/HB904(2011, limiting workzone cameras)

Notes

1A

Wendell R. Beitzel

Allegany, Garrett

R

+2

N

---

 

1B

Kevin Kelly

Allegany

D

+2

N

---

 

1C

LeRoy Myers

Allegany, Washington

R

no rating

X

---

 

2A

A. Serafini

Washington

R

no rating

X

---

 

2B

Neil Parrott

Washington

R

+1

---

---

 

2C

John P. Donoghue

Washington

D

-2

Y

---

 

3A

Galen R. Clagett

Frederick

D

-2

Y

---

 

3A

Patrick N. Hogan

Frederick

R

+1

---

Y

 

3B

Michael Hough

Frederick, Washington

R

no rating

---

---

 

4A

Kathy Afzali

Frederick

R

no rating

---

---

 

4A

Kelly M. Schulz

Frederick

R

no rating

---

---

 

4B

Donald B. Elliott

Carroll, Frederick

R

+2

N

---

 

5A

Justin Ready

Carroll

R

no rating

---

---

 

5A

Nancy Stocksdale

Carroll

R

+2

N

---

 

5B

Wade Kach

Carroll, Baltimore County

R

+2

N

---

 

6

Joseph J. Minnick

Baltimore County

D

+2

N

---

 

6

John Olszewski

Baltimore County

D

+2

N

---

 

6

Michael H. Weir, Jr.

Baltimore County

D

+1

N

N

 

7

Richard Impallaria

Baltimore County, Harford

R

+3

N

---

 

7

Pat McDonough

Baltimore County, Harford

R

+3

N

---

 

7

Kathy Szeliga

Baltimore County, Harford

R

+1

---

---

 

8

Joe Boteler

Baltimore County

R

+3

N

---

 

8

Eric M. Bromwell

Baltimore County

D

+3

N

---

 

8

John W. E. Cluster, Jr.

Baltimore County

R

+1

---

---

 

9A

Gail H. Bates

Howard

R

+3

N

---

 

9A

Warren E. Miller

Howard

R

+3

N

---

 

9B

Susan W. Krebs

Carroll

R

+2

N

---

 

10

Emmett Burns

Baltimore County

D

-2

Y

---

 

10

Adrienne A. Jones

Baltimore County

D

-2

Y

---

 

10

Shirley Nathan-Pulliam

Baltimore County

D

-2

Y

---

 

11

Jon S. Cardin

Baltimore County

D

no rating

X

---

 

11

Dan K. Morhaim

Baltimore County

D

-2

Y

---

 

11

Dana Stein

Baltimore County

D

-3

Y

N

 

12A

Steve DeBoy

Baltimore County, Howard

D

-2

Y

---

 

12A

James Malone

Baltimore County, Howard

D

-2

Y

N

 

12B

Elizabeth Bobo

Howard

D

-2

Y

N

 

13

Guy Guzzone

Howard

D

-2

Y

---

 

13

Shane Pendergrass

Howard

D

-2

Y

---

 

13

Frank S. Turner

Howard

D

-2

Y

---

 

14

Anne R. Kaiser

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

14

Eric Luedtke

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

14

Craig Zucker

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

15

Kathleen M. Dumais

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

15

Brian J. Feldman

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

15

Aruna Miller

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

16

William Frick

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

16

Ariana Kelly

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

16

Susan C. Lee

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

17

Kumar P. Barve

Montgomery

D

-4

Y

---

Delegate Kumar Barve loses points for the hypocrisy of having endangered driver safety when he was caught drunk driving.

17

James W. Gilchrist

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

N

 

17

Luiz Simmons

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

18

Alfred C. Carr, Jr.

Montgomery

D

-3

Y

N

 

18

Ana Sol Gutierrez

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

18

Jeff Waldstreicher

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

19

Sam Arora

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

19

Bonnie Cullison

Montgomery

D

no rating

---

---

 

19

Ben Kramer

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

20

Tom Hucker

Montgomery

D

-3

Y

---

 

20

Sheila E. Hixson

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

20

Heather R. Mizeur

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

21

Barbara A. Frush

Anne Arundel, Prince George's

D

-4

4

N

 Delegate Frush proposed legislation which would have essentially removed police oversight from speed cameras

21

Ben Barnes

Anne Arundel, Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

21

Joseline Pena-Melnyk

Anne Arundel, Prince George's

D

-1

Y

---

 

22

Tawanna Gaines

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

22

Anne Healey

Prince George's

D

-3

Y

N

 

22

Justin D. Ross

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

23A

James W. Hubbard

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

23A

Geraldine Valentino-Smith

Prince George's

D

no rating

---

---

 

23B

Jr. Marvin Holmes

Prince George's

D

-3

Y

N

 

24

Tiffany Alston

Prince George's

D

+1

---

SPONSOR

 

24

Carolyn Howard

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

24

Michael L. Vaughn

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

25

Aisha N. Braveboy

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

25

Dereck E. Davis

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

25

Melony G. Griffith

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

26

Veronica L. Turner

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

26

Kris Valderrama

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

26

Jay Walker

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

27A

Jim Proctor

Calvert, Prince George's

D

no rating

X

---

 

27A

Joe Vallario

Calvert, Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

27B

Mark N. Fisher

Calvert

R

no rating

---

---

 

28

Peter Murphy

Charles

D

-2

Y

---

 

28

Sally Y. Jameson

Charles

D

-2

Y

---

 

28

C.T. Wilson

Charles

D

-1

---

N

 

29A

John F. Wood, Jr.

Charles, St. Mary's

D

+2

N

---

 

29B

John Bohanan

St. Mary's

D

-2

Y

---

 

29C

Tony O'Donnell

Calvert, St. Mary's

R

+3

N

Y

 

30

Michael E. Busch

Anne Arundel

D

-3

Y

---

 

30

Ron George

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

30

Herb McMillan

Anne Arundel

R

+1

---

Y

 

31

Don Dwyer

Anne Arundel

R

+3

N

---

 

31

Nic Kipke

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

31

Steve Schuh

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

32

Pamela Beidle

Anne Arundel

D

-2

Y

N

 

32

Mary Ann Love

Anne Arundel

D

-2

Y

---

 

32

Ted Sophocleus

Anne Arundel

D

-2

Y

---

 

33A

Tony McConkey

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

33A

Cathy Vitale

Anne Arundel

R

+1

---

Y

 

33B

Robert A. Costa

Anne Arundel

R

+2

N

---

 

34A

Glen Glass

Cecil, Harford

R

no rating

---

---

 

34A

Mary-Dulany James

Cecil, Harford

D

+2

N

---

 

34B

David D. Rudolph

Cecil

D

-2

Y

---

 

35A

Wayne Norman

Harford

R

+4

N

Y

 

35A

Donna Stifler

Harford

R

+2

N

---

 

35B

Susan McComas

Harford

R

+2

N

---

 

36

Stephen S. Hershey, Jr.

Caroline, Cecil, Kent, Queen Anne's

R

+1

---

---

 

36

Jay Jacobs

Caroline, Cecil, Kent, Queen Anne's

R

+2

---

Y

 

36

Michael D. Smigiel

Caroline, Cecil, Kent, Queen Anne's

R

+4

N

---

 

37A

Rudolph C. Cane

Dorchester, Wicomico

D

-2

Y

---

 

37B

Addie Eckardt

Caroline, Dorchester, Talbot, Wicomico

R

+2

N

---

 

37B

Jeannie Haddaway

Caroline, Dorchester, Talbot, Wicomico

R

+2

N

---

 

38A

Charles James Otto

Somerset, Wicomico

R

+1

---

Y

 

38B

Norman Conway

Wicomico, Worcester

D

-2

Y

---

 

38B

Mike McDermott

Wicomico, Worcester

R

no rating

---

---

 

39

Charles E. Barkley

Montgomery

D

-2

Y

---

 

39

Kirill Reznik

Montgomery

D

-4

Y

---

Penalized for demonstrating a particular lack of concern for the legal rights of motorists.

39

Shane Robinson

Montgomery

D

-1

---

N

 

40

Frank Conaway

Baltimore City

D

no rating

X

---

 

40

Barbara Robinson

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

40

Shawn Z. Tarrant

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

41

Jill P. Carter

Baltimore City

D

-1

Y

SPONSOR

 

41

Nathaniel T. Oaks

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

41

Sandy Rosenberg

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

42

W. Stephen Lafferty

Baltimore County

D

-2

Y

N

 

42

L. M. Susan Aumann

Baltimore County

R

-2

Y

---

 

42

J. William J. Frank

Baltimore County

R

+2

N

---

 

43

Curt Anderson

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

43

Maggie McIntosh

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

N

 

43

Mary L. Washington

Baltimore City

D

no rating

---

---

 

44

Keith E. Haynes

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

44

Keiffer Mitchell

Baltimore City

D

no rating

---

---

 

44

Melvin L. Stukes

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

45

Talmadge Branch

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

45

Cheryl Glenn

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

N

 

45

Hattie N. Harrison

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

46

Luke Clippinger

Baltimore City

D

no rating

---

---

 

46

Peter A. Hammen

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

46

Brian K. McHale

Baltimore City

D

-2

Y

---

 

47

Jolene Ivey

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

---

 

47

Doyle L. Niemann

Prince George's

D

-2

Y

N

 

47

Michael G. Summers

Prince George's

D

no rating

---

---

 


OTHER LEGISLATION:                            

Other legislation proposed or voted on in 2009 and 2010.  These were taken into consideraation in scoring state lawmakers.  To see how lawmakers voted, open the bill file, open the bill link and see the “Roll Call Vote” at the end of the page.  For information on other bills, go to the Maryland General Assembly Website. 


2011 Legislation:
SB671/ HB 664:Legislation introduced by Delegate Barbara Frush and Senator James, but failed to pass, which would have removed the requirement that police review citations before they are sent, essentially removing oversight by law enforcement from the system and potentially placing this into the hands of contractors paid based on the number of citations issued.  StopBigBrotherMD.org is of the opinion that was is a stupid idea (unless their goal was to drive more traffic to our website) since it would potentially have resulted in more erroneous citations being mailed to innocent drivers.

SB679: 2011 legislation was passed to introduce an entirely new type of photo enforcement, placing cameras on school buses to send out $250 fines for passing violations.



2010 Legislation:

SB916 HB 1477 : Bill which redefines the procedure for authorizing school zones or the use of speed cameras in school zones by Municipalities in Prince George's County (We are still awaiting a response from the sponsors of this legislation regarding the intended purpose of this bill is and what prompted it).  Contains language which forbids the county government to "Place Exactions, Fees, or unreasonable restrictions" on the use of municipalities within Prince Georges's County (we are still awaiting a response from the sponsors of this legislation as to whether that has actually occurred.  In addition the Prince George's County Government violated the law by ignoring a Maryland Public Information Act request for information related to this bill).  The primary effect of this legislation appears to be to limit th eamount of oversight that county and state agencies can place over municipal speed camera programs, by limiting the amount of time they have to respond to requests to create new school zones and speed camera sites and place the burden on those agencies to justify rejecting a request rather than on the municipality to show why it is necessary. This bill PASSED the legislature in 2010 and was signed into law by Governor O'Malley.



2009 Legislation:

 HB313 2009 bills to authorize speed cameras in every county in Maryland on local roadways, band on freeways (with speed limits greater than 45mph) in temporary "work zones", "regardless of whether workers are present".  SB277 passed and became effective October 1, 2009.  This was superceeded by SB277 and was only voted on in the House.


SB388, HB396 
2009 bills to authorization speed cameras in Baltimore.  Only HB396 came to a vote, and only in the house.  This was superceeded by SB277 and did not pass.


HB1020, HB1023: 
2009 bills to authorize speed cameras in Prince George's County.  Sponsored by the Prince George's County Delegation.  This was superceeded by SB277 and did not come to a vote.


HB1314: 
Authorization for use in Howard County.  This was superceeded by SB277 and was only voted on in the House..

Amendment 993028/1: This amendment was proposed to SB277 in the house and was voted down by the house majority. If it had passed it would have  required that "the owner of a vehicle with license plates indicating membership in the United States Congress, the Maryland General Assembly, or any other state legislature, that is recorded by a speed monitoring system as being in violation of § 21-809 or § 21-810 of the Transportation Article, may not be exempt from receiving a warning or a citation for the violationSEE HOW LAWMAKERS VOTED ON THIS HERE!



FUTURE LEGISLATION:
    Come back soon


Take Action

You can find the contact information for your state lawmakers HERE.  Writing to them is one way to express your displeasure for lawmakers who have contempt for the rights of drivers.

Unfortunately if you did not vote in November 2010 you will not have the chance to vote for state offices again until 2014.  You may still have the opportunity to cast your vote on this matter in County and municipal elections if applicable, check with your local board of elections for the terms of local officials.  Many municipal elections are dominated by only a handful of voters, sometimes with less than 15% of the town participating, so casting your vote in municipal elections if you have that opportunity is vitally important.

If you have received a camera citation you might consider making a "matching contribution" to a lawmaker who has opposed speed cameras ($40 for a speed camera ticket, $75 for a red light ticket).  

If you wish to support an organization which opposes speed cameras you might consider joining or making a donation to the National Motorists Association, the only nationwide organization exclusively dedicated to drivers' rights.  (StopBigBrotherMD.org is not sponsored by or affiliated with the NMA).  Some other "motorist groups" who speak about speed cameras to the press are really insurance companies or travel agencies, not motorist rights organizations.  When push come to shove on speed camera legislation they will trade motorist rights away for some shiny bauble.  To the NMA, motorist rights are the family jewels: Accept no imitation!  The more members they have in Maryland the more they can do to oppose photo enforcement here.

We also recommend that people write to the State Highway Administration and tell them that you do not want them to approve any more permits for speed cameras on state highways, and that you believe any requests for speed camera permits, new school zones, or lowered speed limits should be published to the SHA web site and opened to public hearings for ALL members of the public(whose taxes paid for the road), not just the region making the request.  (The SHA will probably respond that this is not their jurisdiction or that the matter should be taken up with the local government involved -- to which you should reply that this response is not an acceptable response and that the SHA bears responsibility in the matter if they are issuing permits.)


For more information about fighting speed cameras, see StopBigBrotherMD.org