William I, byname WILLIAM
The CONQUEROR,
or The BASTARD, or WILLIAM of NORMANDY, French GUILLAUME le CONQUÉRANT,
or le
BÂTARD, or GUILLAUME de NORMANDIE (b. ca 1028, Falaise, Normandy -- d. 9
September 1087, Rouen), Duke of Normandy (as William II) from 1035 and
king of England
from 1066, one of the greatest soldiers and rulers of the Middle Ages. He made himself the mightiest feudal lord in
France and then changed the course of England's history by his conquest of that
country.
Early years
William was the elder of two children of Robert I of Normandy and his
concubine
Herleva or Arlette, the daughter of a burgher from the town of
Falaise. In 1035 Robert died when returning from a
pilgrimage to Jerusalem and William, his only son, whom he had
nominated as his
heir before his departure, was accepted as duke by the Norman magnates
and his
feudal overlord, King Henry I of France. William and his friends had
to overcome enormous obstacles. His illegitimacy (he was generally
known as
the Bastard) was a handicap, and he had to survive the collapse of law
and
order that accompanied his accession as a child.
Three of William's guardians died violent deaths before he grew up, and his
tutor was murdered. His father's kin
were of little help; most of them thought that they stood to gain by the boy's
death. But his mother managed to
protect William through the most dangerous period. These early difficulties probably contributed to his strength of
purpose and his dislike of lawlessness and misrule.
Ruler of Normandy
By 1042, when William reached his 15th year, was knighted and began to play a
personal part in the affairs of his duchy, the worst was over. But his attempts to recover rights lost
during the anarchy and to bring disobedient vassals and servants to heel inevitably
led to trouble. From 1046 until 1055 he dealt with a series of baronial
rebellions, mostly led by kinsmen.
Occasionally he was in great danger and had to rely on Henry of France
for help. In 1047 Henry and William
defeated a coalition of Norman rebels at Val-ès-Dunes, southeast of Caen. It was in these years that William learned
to fight and rule.
William soon learned to control his youthful recklessness. He was
always ready to take calculated risks
on campaign and, most important, to fight a battle. But he was not a
chivalrous or flamboyant commander. His plans were simple, his methods
direct,
and he exploited ruthlessly any advantage gained. If he found himself
at a disadvantage, he withdrew
immediately. He showed the same
qualities in his government. He never
lost sight of his aim to recover lost ducal rights and revenues, and,
although
he developed no theory of government or great interest in
administrative
techniques, he was always prepared to improvise and experiment. He
seems to have lived a moral life by the
standards of the time, and he acquired an interest in the welfare of
the Norman
church. He made his half brother, Odo,
bishop of Bayeux in 1049 at the age of about 16, and Odo managed to
combine the
roles of nobleman and prelate in a way that did not greatly shock
contemporaries. But William also
welcomed foreign monks and scholars to Normandy. Lanfranc of Pavia, a
famous master of the liberal arts, who
entered the monastery of Bec about 1042, was made abbot of Caen in 1063.
According to a brief description of William's person by an anonymous author,
who borrowed extensively from Einhard's Life of Charlemagne, he was just above
average height and had a robust, thick-set body. Though he was always sparing of food and drink, he became fat in
later life. He had a rough bass voice
and was a good and ready speaker.
Writers of the next generation agree that he was exceptionally strong
and vigorous. William was an
out-of-doors man, a hunter and soldier, fierce and despotic, generally feared;
uneducated, he had few graces but was intelligent and shrewd and soon obtained
the respect of his rivals.
New alliances
After 1047 William began to take part in events outside his duchy. In support of his lord, King Henry, and in
pursuit of an ambition to strengthen his southern frontier and expand into
Maine, he fought a series of campaigns against Geoffrey Martel, count of
Anjou. But in 1052 Henry and Geoffrey
made peace, there was a serious rebellion in eastern Normandy, and, until 1054
William was again in serious danger.
During this period he conducted important negotiations with his cousin
Edward the Confessor, king of England, and took a wife.
Norman interest in Anglo-Saxon England derived from an alliance made in 1002,
when King Ethelred II of England married Emma, the sister of Count Richard II,
William's grandfather. Two of her sons,
William's cousins once removed, had reigned in turn in England: Hardecanute
(1040-42) and Edward the Confessor (1042-66).
William had met Edward during that prince's exile on the Continent and
may well have given him some support when he returned to England in 1041. In that year Edward was about 36 and William
14. It is clear that William expected
some sort of reward from Edward and, when Edward's marriage proved unfruitful,
began to develop an ambition to become his kinsman's heir. Edward probably at times encouraged
William's hopes. His childlessness was
a diplomatic asset.
In 1049 William negotiated with Baldwin V of Flanders for the hand of his
daughter, Matilda. Baldwin, an imperial
vassal with a distinguished lineage, was in rebellion against the Western
emperor, Henry III, and in desperate need of allies. The proposed marriage was condemned as incestuous (William and
Matilda were evidently related in some way) by the Emperor's friend, Pope Leo
IX, at the Council of Reims in October 1049; but so anxious were the parties
for the alliance that before the end of 1053, possibly in 1052, the wedding
took place. In 1059 William was
reconciled to the papacy, and as penance the disobedient pair built two
monasteries at Caen. Four sons were
born to William and Matilda: Robert (the future duke of Normandy), Richard (who
died young), William Rufus (the Conqueror's successor in England), and Henry
(Rufus' successor). Among the daughters
was Adela, who was the mother of Stephen, king of England.
Edward the Confessor was supporting the Emperor, and it is possible that
William used his new alliance with Flanders to put pressure on Edward and
extort an acknowledgment that he was the English king's heir. At all events, Edward seems to have made
some sort of promise to William in 1051, while Tostig, son of the greatest
nobleman in England, Earl Godwine, married Baldwin's half sister. The immediate purpose of this tripartite
alliance was to improve the security of each of the parties. If William secured a declaration that he was
Edward's heir, he was also looking very far ahead.
Between 1054 and 1060 William held his own against an alliance between
King Henry
I and Geoffrey Martel of Anjou. Both
men died in 1060 and were succeeded by weaker rulers. As a result, in
1063 William was able to conquer Maine. In 1064 or 1065 Edward sent
his
brother-in-law, Harold, earl of Wessex, Godwine's son and successor, on
an
embassy to Normandy. William took him
on a campaign into Brittany, and in connection with this Harold swore
an oath
in which, according to Norman writers, he renewed Edward's bequest of
the
throne to William and promised to support it.
When Edward died childless on 5 January 1066, Harold was accepted as
king by
the English magnates, and William decided on war. Others, however,
moved more quickly. In May Tostig, Harold's exiled brother, raided
England, and in
September he joined the invasion forces of Harald III Hardraade, king
of
Norway, off the Northumbrian coast.
William assembled a fleet, recruited an army, and gathered his forces
in
August at the mouth of the Dives River.
It is likely that he originally intended to sail due north and invade
England
by way of the Isle of Wight and Southampton Water. Such a plan would
give him an offshore base and interior
lines. But adverse winds detained his
fleet in harbour for a month, and in September a westerly gale drove
his ships
up-Channel.
The Battle of Hastings
William regrouped his forces at Saint-Valéry on the Somme. He had suffered a costly delay, some naval
losses, and a drop in the morale of his troops. On September 27, after cold and rainy weather, the wind backed
south. William embarked his army and
set sail for the southeast coast of England.
The following morning he landed, took the unresisting towns of Pevensey
and Hastings, and began to organize a bridgehead with between 4,000 and 7,000
cavalry and infantry.
William's forces were in a narrow coastal strip, hemmed in by the great
forest
of Andred, and, although this corridor was easily defensible, it was
not much
of a base for the conquest of England.
The campaigning season was almost past, and when William received news
of his opponent it was not reassuring.
On 25 September Harold had defeated and slain Tostig and Harald
Hardraade at Stamford Bridge, near York, and was retracing his steps to
meet
the new invader. On 13 October, when
Harold emerged from the forest, William was taken by surprise. But the
hour was too late for Harold to push
on to Hastings, and he took up a defensive position. Early the next
day William went out to give battle. He attacked the English phalanx
with archers
and cavalry but saw his army almost driven from the field. He rallied
the fugitives, however, and
brought them back into the fight and in the end wore down his
opponents. Harold's brothers were killed early in the
battle. Toward nightfall the King
himself fell and the English gave up.
William's coolness and tenacity secured him victory in this fateful
battle, and he then moved against possible centres of resistance so
quickly
that he prevented a new leader from emerging.
On Christmas Day 1066 he was crowned king in Westminster Abbey. In a
formal sense the Norman Conquest of
England had taken place.
King of England
William was already an experienced ruler.
In Normandy he had replaced disloyal nobles and ducal servants with his
own friends, limited private warfare, and recovered usurped ducal
rights,
defining the feudal duties of his vassals.
The Norman church flourished under his rule. He wanted a church free
of corruption but subordinate to him. He would not tolerate opposition
from
bishops and abbots or interference from the papacy. He presided over
church synods and reinforced ecclesiastical
discipline with his own. In supporting
Lanfranc, prior of Bec, against Berengar of Tours in their dispute over
the
doctrine of the Eucharist, he found himself on the side of orthodoxy.
He was never guilty of the selling of church
office (simony). He disapproved of
clerical marriage. At the same time he
was a stern and sometimes rough master, swayed by political
necessities, and he
was not generous to the church with his own property. The reformer
Lanfranc was one of his advisers; but perhaps even
more to his taste were the worldly and soldierly bishops Odo of Bayeux
and
Geoffrey of Coutances.
William left England early in 1067 but had to return in December because of
English unrest. The English rebellions
that began in 1067 reached their peak in 1069 and were finally quelled in
1071. They completed the ruin of the
highest English aristocracy and gave William a distaste for his newly conquered
kingdom. Since his position on the
Continent was deteriorating, he wanted to solve English problems as cheaply as
possible. To secure England's
frontiers, he invaded Scotland in 1072 and Wales in 1081 and created special
defensive "marcher" counties along the Scottish and Welsh borders.
In the last 15 years of his life he was more often in Normandy than in England,
and there were five years, possibly seven, in which he did not visit the
kingdom at all. He retained most of the
greatest Anglo-Norman barons with him in Normandy and confided the government
of England to bishops, trusting especially his old friend Lanfranc, whom he
made archbishop of Canterbury. Much
concerned that the natives should not be unnecessarily disturbed, he allowed
them to retain their own laws and courts.
William returned to England only when it was absolutely necessary: in 1075 to
deal with the aftermath of a rebellion by Roger, earl of Hereford, and Ralf,
earl of Norfolk, which was made more dangerous by the intervention of a Danish
fleet; and in 1082 to arrest and imprison his half brother Odo, bishop of
Bayeux and earl of Kent, who was planning to take an army to Italy, perhaps to
make himself pope. In the spring of
1082 William had his son Henry knighted, and in August at Salisbury he took oaths
of fealty from all the important landowners in England, whosoever's vassals
they might be. In 1085 he returned with
a large army to meet the threat of an invasion by Canute IV (Canute the Holy)
of Denmark. When this came to nothing
owing to Canute's death in 1086, William ordered an economic and tenurial
survey to be made of the kingdom, the results of which are summarised in the
two volumes of Domesday Book.
William was preoccupied with the frontiers of Normandy. The danger spots were in Maine and the Vexin
on the Seine, where Normandy bordered on the French royal demesne. After 1066 William's continental neighbours
became more powerful and even more hostile.
In 1068 Fulk the Surly succeeded to Anjou and in 1071 Robert the Frisian
to Flanders. Philip I of France allied
with Robert and Robert with the Danish king, Canute IV. There was also the problem of William's heir
apparent, Robert Curthose, who, given no appanage and seemingly kept short of
money, left Normandy in 1077 and intrigued with his father's enemies. In 1081 William made a compromise with Fulk
in the treaty of Blancheland: Robert Curthose was to be count of Maine but as a
vassal of the count of Anjou. The
eastern part of the Vexin, the county of Mantes, had fallen completely into King
Philip's hands in 1077 when William had been busy with Maine. In 1087 William demanded from Philip the
return of the towns of Chaumont, Mantes, and Pontoise. In July he entered Mantes by surprise, but
while the town burned he suffered some injury from which he never
recovered. He was thwarted at the very
moment when he seemed about to enforce his last outstanding territorial claim.
Death
William was taken to a suburb of Rouen, where he lay dying for five weeks. He had the assistance of some of his bishops
and doctors, and in attendance were his half brother Robert, count of Mortain,
and his younger sons, William Rufus and Henry.
Robert Curthose was with the King of France. It had probably been his intention that Robert, as was the
custom, should succeed to the whole inheritance. In the circumstances he was tempted to make the loyal Rufus his
sole heir. In the end he compromised:
Normandy and Maine went to Robert and England to Rufus. Henry was given great treasure with which he
could purchase an appanage. William
died at daybreak on 9 September, in his 60th year, and was buried in rather
unseemly fashion in St Stephen's Church, which he had built at Caen. |