Everyone knows, or at least should know, that corporations are legal
artifacts, not real persons. Nevertheless, some people insist on
talking as if corporations were real people with human attributes.
Corporations are often said to be greedy or heartless. This is
anthropomorphic nonsense, but it is persistent nonsense.
The
underlying reality is that only real people can be greedy. In a
corporation, there are only two kinds of people that his might pertain
to: shareholders and employees.
Let's examine
shareholders. It's easy to form a mental picture of a bunch of wealthy
tycoons owning corporations. To a degree, this is true. Most
corporations have some very wealthy shareholders. But they are not
normally in the majority.
Good data is hard to
come by, but the best estimate I've seen says that 40% of corporate
shares are owned by pension funds, the largest of which benefit public
employees like police, firefighters, and teachers.
Now
add to that 40% another big chunk for 401Ks, the retirement accounts
that have replaced pensions in so many businesses. Add to that the
individual savings in IRAs and college savings vehicles it's easy to
see that it's ordinary people who own the bulk of corporate America.
Does anyone really think that average American's are greedheads because
they want a comfortable retirement or want to send their kids to
college?
If it's not the shareholders who are
greedy, it must be the employees, specifically CEOs and senior
management. After all, some of these folks are very richly rewarded for
their work. Are they the greedheads?
Generally,
shareholders want corporations to pay employees what they have to in
order to have qualified employees - and not a dime more. But for many
senior management positions, there's a shortage of qualified people.
Corporations (and private companies) must engage in bidding wars to
attract the talent they need. No one wants to be stuck with incompetent
management (that happens enough without trying!).
So,
competent senior managers are constantly being offered big rewards to
go to another company or to stay with the one they're already with.
They take the money happily - and who wouldn't? But is this greed?
Talking
about greedy corporations is anthropomorphic nonsense. The real source
of this kind of talk is resentment that exceptionally talented people
can be richly rewarded. The moral problem here isn't greed - it's envy!