The Essence of Madhva's Philosophy: Tattvavada: Dvaita

-by Sri Bannanje Govindacharya

Posted in http://www.geocities.com/madhvaonline

Acharya Madhva's line of thought gave a new turn to the tradition of Indian philosophy. This has been called by the name "Tatvavada" in ancient works. In later times, when the unphilosophical trend emphasizing only conflict became prominent for recognizing Vedic schools of thought, this came to be called the "dvaita" or "dualistic school". But from the standpoint of true Vedic tradition, this is not a name which can be fully justified.

In the philosophical system of the Acharya, tattvas or categories of reality are primarily two: svatantra-tatva or Independent reality and asvatantra tatva or dependent reality. God who created the universe is the independent reality; the entire universe create by him is the dependent reality.

Lord Narayana alone is the Supreme Independent God head. The entire Veda hymns only His praise by various epithets such as Agni, Indra and Varuna. Monotheism alone is thus the quintessence of Vedic literature and not polytheism.

All names (of God) are only epithets; God is the Ocean of all qualities or excellences, Hence any name is good enough to invoke God. All names designate only God. Not only Vedic words not only Sanskrit names, whatever the word may be, in any language whatever in the world, every name will designate Him alike. For, there is no sound or word in any language of the world which is not essentially a name of God.

Though God is one, divinities are many. These divinities are not God; they are only souls that have realized God and risen to a high estate by acquiring siddhi or divine power. These siddhas or realized adepts can serve as gurus to guide the jiva or soul who is still a sadhaka or religious seeker.

If God is 'bimba' or the original substrate, jivas or souls are His 'pratibibas' or images. The image is always dependent on the original substrate; it can never become identical with it. One original substrate can have many images. Even so the souls can be many. Each soul has its own distinct individuality, different from another. As many souls, so many varieties. Along with all these differential gradations, these souls are all entwined in the single thread of similarity to God in their knowledge-aspect.

Just as souls, the inanimate substances too that go into the creative apparatus of the universe are innumerable. Thus the soul (Jiva), who is at the center in the triple categories of God-soul inanimate world, becomes involved in the meshes of Samsara or bondage, if he leans towards one side; and if he leans towards another side, he becomes liberated.

There is one important point to be noted here. Mukti or liberation does not mean any cessation of the world itself. It is not any disappearance of the world falsely held as real. Liberation means release from the bondage of the world. The world does exist even after release; but there is no bondage. Earlier, the soul being unaware of its power of self-consciousness, was ignorant of the original substrate, (viz God); and had become a tool in the hands of the inconscient, searching in vain for the original. But now (in release) he has conquered inconscient nature; for he has now become conscious of God, who is the original and also the First cause of the entire universe.

The inconscient world is five-faceted, five elements, five elemental essences, five sheaths, five sense organs etc. That is why it is designated as "Pra-pancha" or a "perfect pentad". In this pentad intermixed in five fold manner, principle of prana or life is also five fold. They are prana, apana, vyana, udana and samana. Moreover, it is being controlled all the time by God who has also assumed a five fold form, viz: Anirudha, Pradyumna, Samkarasana, Vasudeva and Naraya.

Thus one might distinguish a five-fold difference too in this world; difference between one inconscient and another inconscient; difference between inconscient and the soul; difference between the inconscient and God; difference between one soul and another; difference between soul and God. This difference is neither temporary nor merely practical; it is an invariable and natural property of everything. For such is the law of nature: One is not two; two is not one.

The Acharya effected a synthesis and integration between several self-contradictory notions which had accumulated by his time regarding God, Devotion and the Universe. We might refer here to some of the important ones among them:

God is both endowed with forms and formless; both qualified and unqualified. He is endowed with forms because He has a body of knowledge and bliss. He is formless because he has no body within the reach of our finite thought. He is qualified because he possesses in perfection all good or auspicious attributes. He is unqualified also because he is devoid of all material adjuncts. When viewed from the right standpoint, it will be realized that all modes of utterance express varied aspects of the only truth. The Vedic literature will not open out its secrets to one who is not having this synthetic vision.

The World is not a magic show improvised by any magician. It is ultimately true. From another standpoint, it is untrue also. But then the word "untrue" does not mean "false"; it means "dependent reality". Its truth is restrained by God; hence it is untrue. Similarly there is no truth in the objection that the Vedic religion is tainted with iconolatry or image worship. For, it does not worship icons; it worships only God symbolized by the icons. Is not the all-existent God existing in the icon?

Among other significant contributions of the Acharya's tattvavada, vyakti-visitavada or unique individuality of every soul and svabhava or theory of unalterable natural law governing humanity deserve notice. The following is a summary statement of it:

There is no object like another. There is no person or Soul like another. No man's nature is like that of another. Underlying everything and every individual person, there is a unique individuality or specialty. The all round and complete development of this special personality is indeed the goal of human life. Human life of bondage (samsara) is none other than a practical workshop which helps the individual soul to attain the perfect development of his personality in dependence upon God. Mukti or release is only a state of perfection or enjoying the bliss of such a perfect development of one's own personality.

Each one's attainment is commensurate with one's effort. Our development is in keeping with our personality. The sea is full; the tank is full; even water pots may be full (of water). But what fullness in not identical in all these. The volume varies according to the variation in size. Everything is full; yet it is full of variation also.

There are no two things in this creation which are identical. Even two leaves of the same tree are not exactly identical. Hence the idea that all become one or all become identical ultimately, is only a sugar-coated sop. It is an idea opposed to scriptures. It is an idea going against the very law of nature.

The development of an individual takes place strictly in accordance with his inner nature. The environmental factors only help manifest what is already rooted in one's inner nature. Thus inner nature is the spontaneous way of life for a Jiva. It is an innate characteristic rooted firmly in the Jiva from the time immemorial. No amount of effort can alter its course. A sattvika or pure-hearted man cannot become a tamasa or evil-minded one. Nor can a tamasa turn into a satvik. One's attainment of perfection is nothing but a complete manifestation of one's unique individual nature.

The idea of four varnas in Gita vindicates this view only. The Gita idea of "four varnas" is quite distinct from the idea of "four castes" prevalent today. It is an idea which relates only to the soul's inmost nature or personality trait. The true color of the soul needs to be discovered. That indeed is a right social order. In such a social order, the son of a low born may be a nobleman.; contrary wise, a brahmin's son may also be a sudra. For, varna of color is not something which is transmitted hereditarily; it is something quite personal; something which is determined by the individual's own personality traits.

Only one who knows God can know the secret of the universe. It is impossible to know the universe completely by scientific research into matter. Hence one should know God Himself. It is only by knowing the root that one can tackle a tree. This indeed is the pathway of knowledge. The principle which unites the soul to God like a thread is called prana-tattva or the "vital principle". It is the one principle which embodies all souls and is also termed "jivottama-tattva" or the "principle of perfect jiva hood". The Acharya says about himself that it is an aspect of this supreme principle which incarnated itself in human for as Madhva in order to lay bare the Supreme truth.

The pathway of Jnana-Yoga or knowledge supreme is not opposed to Karma or action. The very dichotomy that the pathway of action is for the ignorant, while that of knowledge is for the adept, is absurd. Knowledge without action is an impractical intellectual exercise. Action without knowledge is but blind orthodoxy. Knowledge is necessary; knowledgeful action too is necessary. At the same time, an understanding of God's infinite glory is equally necessary. Having understood God's greatness, it is necessary to love him devotedly. The world also deserves to be lived, since the wonderful universe is just His creation in sport. Denying the world is as good as denying God's own infinite greatness. We should all dedicate ourselves to our duty in the following spirit: "We are all subjects in the kingdom of God; rendering assistance to those who are in distress is the tax we owe to God Himself, our king". Such an integral synthesis of the pathways of knowledge, action and Devotion becomes a perfect pathway for one's life.

The physical eye is not enough for the development of knowledge. The inner eye has to be opened; one has to turn inward. There are only two ways in which that goal can be realized; one is direct personal experience; and other is the word of wisdom bequeathed to us by sages who were "seers" of the Veda. Their word is a torch to illuminate our way. In the light of that torch and along that way alone we should walk on and discover Truth. thus when both the word of scriptures and our own immediate experience coincide, it becomes the highest criterion confirming our conviction. In order to achieve it, a continuous process of hearing, cogitation and realization of the scriptures is called for.

Not even scriptural statement is to be accepted if it is against one's own conscience. An awakened conscience can discover the integral unity underlying all Vedic statements. It is in order to demonstrate this synthetic essence of the Vedas that the Brahmasutras, Bharata, Pancaratra and Puranas have been written. These alone are primary authorities. Texts of smrti (moral code) written by sages like Manu are acceptable as authority only when they are in conformity with the essential message of the Veda. They are not at all ultimate authorities.

Another means of valid knowledge besides perception and scripture is interference or reasoning. Although it is an instrument of valid knowledge' it is not a independent instrument. Hence it is spoken of only as "anu-mana" or "ancillary instrument of knowledge"; it can be developed only as a supplementary instrument to the other two, viz., perception and scripture. It is important to note that in supersensory matters, nothing can be established by inference or reasoning independently. For, any thing one desires can be established by reasoning. Those who do not possess this awareness can establish nothing by the strength of their reasoning

Therefore in regard to super-sensory facts and especially, in regard to God, there is no use in one's surrendering oneself to reasoning. One should surrender oneself only to God. One should surrender oneself to the voice of hoary sages and wise men who had realized God; that is to say, to the Vedic words. One should know through word of sages and having known, one should experience it; having experienced, one should see; having seen, one should succeed and get liberated.

And for that to happen, one should surrender oneself to God; one should know through surrender ; and knowing, one should again surrender. This awareness is the key to bliss. This is broadly the sum and substance of the Acharya's spiritual view point.

On the whole, Acharya Madhvas's life message is this:

Kuru bhuksva cha karma nijam niyatam

Hari pada vinamradaya satatam

Harireva paro Harireva gurur

Harireva jagat pitrmatr gatihi.

Tadalam bahuloka vichintanaya

Paravanam kuru manasa misa pade

-Acharya Madhva in Dvadasha-stotra

Do your duty without any desire as worship to the lotus feet of Lord Sri Hari. Sri Hari is the sustainer, He is teacher, He is the father and mother of this whole world. Stop the worldly cares which are endless, Pin thy mind at the Lord's feet boundless!

The information on this page may not be republished on another webpage or website. Please LINK TO US instead