Available from ISI BOOKS
Human Goods, Economic Evils: A Moral Approach to the Dismal Science
The publisher says: Much of modern economic theory is based on a rather unflattering view of human nature, one that is essentially selfish and materialistic. Not surprisingly, this incomplete version of human anthropology makes for some rather incomplete economic theory, argues Edward Hadas in Human Goods, Economic Evils. Hadas argues that human beings are not simply utility maximizers, but seek to "maximize" morality in their everyday economic lives. For Hadas, economic man is moral man, who always strives for the good according to his nature. While the weakness of human nature ensures that the good is never fully achieved, economic activity is nevertheless best understood as part of the great moral enterprise of humanity
Human Goods, Economic Evils does not claim that the basic economic activities of laboring and consuming are the most important things in life, but they are literally vital, and as such deserve to be studied and understood through a more morally sympathetic view of human nature. With this in mind, Human Goods, Economic Evils provides both lay readers and policymakers the intellectual tools necessary to judge what is right and what is wrong about the modern economy, and returns the study of economics to its proper, more humanistic sphere.
I say: Since its pre-history in the 18th century, the discipline of economics has been built almost entirely on the philosophical foundation created by John Locke and David Hume: empiricist and anti-transcendental. Utilitarians contributed to economics a faith in the ability of numbers to describe the human good in a meaningful way. Neoclassical economists took the field on a journey to a land of equations and assumptions far from any actual society.
Despite many valiant efforts to make economic theory more realistic, the discipline still pays little attention to the human meaning and moral value of the various activities that can be identified as economic: labour, production, allocation and consumption.
Human Goods, Economic Evils is based on a much more realistic anthropology than that of the “economic man” of classical and neoclassical theory. The human who labours and consumes is treated as the same person who loves, studies, wonders and worships. The economic good, once studied in these broad terms, is different in important ways from the conventional notion, centred on something like a maximisation of utility. In the new view, money is irrelevant, GDP is simplistic and even unemployment cannot be understood without reference to the human search for meaning.
The book discusses a) what is wrong with the current theoretical approach (a fairly well-worn path); b) how economic activity fits into the human condition (newer territory); c) the true nature of economic goods and evils (nearly virgin ground, to my knowledge); and d) the virtue and vices of the current industrial economy. The conclusion, in rough terms, is that the economic aspect of the modern experiment is one of the most successful, but that from here there is relatively little more economic good to be obtained, at least in rich countries.
Contact me: edward.hadas@gmail.com
Note: All material on this site is copyright©2009 by Edward Hadas. All rights reserved.
All uncredited images are, to the best of my knowledge, in the public domain. Please notify me immediately of any violations.
Site design © Grace Andreacchi. |
|