A Cynic's Dictionary of Economics
Aid Worker
An aid worker is a person on a trip of self
discovery to exotic places at the taxpayer's expense.
Altruism
We know that people in different countries behave more or less
altruistically (drop a wallet and the difference is noticeable). Since
economics has no use for real world social behavior, economics textbook
are not encumbered with such irrelevances as altruism.
Bank
Managers
Speculators who gamble with other people's money,
pocket the gains and transfer the losses to shareholders and the
taxpayer.
Banks
According to economic textbooks, banks collect savings from the public and transfer them to firms that invest the money in productive activities. In actual fact, they "invest" these savings in government bonds and other speculative assets.
Chicago School
Adherents of the
Chicago School believe that markets would operate perfectly were it not
for state regulations that foul them up. The failure of unregulated or
deregulated markets on the other hand - such as the financial markets -
is invariably attributed to missing regulations.
Competition
In classical economics, competition ensures that resources go to
those who can make the most of them. This leads to allocative efficiency
and, more importantly, erodes excess profits. Innovation yields high profits that are subsequently eroded
through competition. This process is driving the productivity and income growth of the
capitalist system. Mainstream economists have no use for competition.
In their models firms have exploited all potential efficiency gains and
inventions and innovations fall from heaven.
Competition
Economists
are convinced that activities not exposed to market competition are
delivered inefficiently. This analysis is never applied to what
economists do.
Consumer choice
Consumers have
constant preferences, perfect information and all the power of
computation necessary to evaluate all the possible options they have -
that, at least, you learn from economic textbooks. You are lucky you
find in your economics department some fringe figure located at the end
of corridor next to the bathroom who tells you these assumptions lead
you seriously astray in important fields such as health, finance and
savings and that policy recommendations based on these assumptions may actually reduce welfare.
Corruption
Corruption is unknown in the economics profession since there is
nothing illegal about testimonies and reports blatantly biased in favor
of those who commission them.
Development Aid
Originally,
development aid was supposed to improve the productivity of the
inhabitants of the Third World. One of the best established findings in
economics is that development aid did nothing of the sort. This does not
stop the some economists from clamoring for more. Their behavior is
entirely uninfluenced by the fact that a part of it flows their way in
form of large payments for travel allowances, consultancy reports and
research funds.
Development Economics
Fell on hard
times and came low in the pecking order of economics since its
practitioners were supposed to have some knowledge of the societies they
dealt with. Fortunately, this prerequisite has now fallen by the
wayside with the advent of the new wave of development enthusiasm and
economists who manage to become country experts in a couple of days
after the motto "been to China twice".
Development Expert
A development expert is someone who is developed by means of large
amounts of aid money.
Econometrics
A branch of
metaphysics; it transposes empirical data into speculations that have no
known bearings on any observed economic relationships. It is the modern
equivalent of calculating how many angels can dance on the head of a
pin.
Economic Development
A field that reached its
peak with the publication of the Wealth of Nations in 1776 and has gone
downhill ever since. From time to time readers stumble over some of his insights and generate a new
fashion in economics. Adam Smith's human capital theory was rediscovered by
T.W. Shultz and got him (Shultz, not Smith) a Nobel Prize. The World Bank rediscovered that
the nature and kind of government has something to do with growth. They
called it Governance but haven't got the Nobel yet.
Economic
Forecasting
Since future behavior of humans is unknowable - it
is impossible to know the future preferences of human beings - economic
forecasting predicts the future correctly only by accident and has no
greater scientific standing than astrology. Were the market for
forecasting to operate efficiently, the low-cost provider "astrology"
would have put the high cost provider "economic forecasting" out of
business long ago. Fortunately, the economic profession is a proficient
rent-seeker and subsidies continue to flow into the failed profession.
Economic
Growth
Economic growth is a long term issue that does not
concern mainstream economists since "in the long run we are all dead".
Economic
History
A subject that has been expunged from the canon of
economic teaching and research on the ground that explaining singular
events is not amenable to statistical procedures - quite apart from
involving knowledge about the real world.
Economic Language
The language of economics is increasingly mathematical. The reason
is simple. If transformed into common language it would be blindingly
obvious that the ideas contained in most economic theories are either
unoriginal or utterly trivial or both.
Economic Man
Maximizing
one's self-interest leads to the greatest degree of welfare of the
person concerned. Economists conclude from this that any witless
creature not following this path is unworthy to occupy a position of
social responsibility.
Economic Planning
By 1940 the
majority of economists held that a planned economy was perfectly
feasible, the arguments of its critics without force, the difficulties
of monitoring state firms and of acquiring the necessary knowledge to
conduct efficient planning much exaggerated.[i]
When planning had manifestly failed in 1989 they had known all along
that Socialist Planning didn't work. Yet there are still some who
continue in the old vein to advocate the virtue of planning on a smaller
scale, claiming that some additional pieces of legislation would produce an efficient national health system.
Economic Theory
Builds mathematical models on the basis of simplifying
assumptions about the behavior of market participants, of a limited number
of additional variables and of assumed functional forms. These models habitually fail to
predict and explain - which provides excellent reasons to do more of the
same.
Economists
Academics that unsuccessfully
engage in predicting the future and fail to agree on the causes of past
economic developments.
Efficiency
Undergraduates were
taught (before the advent of modern textbooks) that efficiency means
getting maximum output from a given input. Since economists produce
output whose marginal product is largely negative (resources are
employed in disseminating results that are of no value to anyone), the
term has fallen into disuse.
Efficient Markt Hypothesis
When is a market efficient? According to some, it is efficient if a
person without insider knowledge is unable to predict future prices:
future market prices follow a random walk. Most people believe financial
markets are reasonably efficient in this sense. Unfortunately,
efficient markets were also defined differently. A whole lot of
economists claimed that financial markets priced assets “correctly”, reflecting long run fundamentals such as future
earning power. The dot-com-bubble wasn’t enough to explode this myth.
Will the current financial crisis finally persuade analysts that asset prices
follow a random walk: the way of the drunk on the way home?
Empirical Research
A
mugs game where quantitative economists analyze data of dubious quality
with dubious methods and increasingly without any theoretical guidance.
Their findings are then going to be disproved by the next test using
slightly different data sets and other dubious methods. Despite 30 years
of research no findings of any significance - contributing to the
understanding of the economy - have emerged yet.
Entrepreneur
Entrepreneurs embark on innovations and take personal risks in
doing so. They have long been considered the moving force of capitalism
and the supply of entrepreneurship was deemed a vital factor in
explaining the wealth of nations. Not so modern economics - since the
supply of entrepreneurship depends of social factors economists have
nothing to say on the topic and therefore prefer not to mention
entrepreneurs in their teaching at all.
Ethics
Ethics
is a field that has been imposed on the profession by the misguided
public and has never been accepted by economists as a serious subject of
inquiry. Since markets are perfect, each participant goes bust if she
deviates in pricing, production and employment decisions from what
markets dictate. There is therefore no room for ethics at all.
Ethics
Ethics is a field staffed
with would-be philosophers who refuse to acknowledge that in the real
world business decisions constantly confront moral dilemmas. This
conveniently allows professors of ethics to give cheap advice and accuse
businesspeople of acting unethically whatever they do.
Exchange
Rates
Exchange rates are the mysterious prices of currencies.
There are no theories of the exchange rates because the assumptions of
economics are unable to deal with actually observed human behavior such
as rapidly changing expectations. This does not stop economists from
integrating exchange rate movements in their models.
Experimental Economics
Experimental
economics suggests that people sometimes behave in ways incompatible
with rationally maximizing monetary gains. Since such behavior disrupts
the ease of modeling, it is presumed to have no relevant effects on the
operation, stability and success of the economic system we live in.
Finance
Finance is a field in economics that is supposed to analyze the
operation of financial markets. That professors of finance have little knowledge of their subject has been amply proved by their failure to predict
the current financial crisis. Since knowledge of actual business
processes has never been a criterion of employment and promotion in the
field of financial economics, this is unlikely to change.
Financial
Regulation
Designed to increase the profits of banks by
approving new financial products that increase the level of
disinformation among the public and legalize dissimulation and fraud.
Financial
Supervision
Institutions where bank managers regulate their
scope for misappropriating funds.
Firms
In economic
theory, firms appear and disappear from nowhere like ghosts in a mystery
tale. Thus in a recession firms vanish but appear again after it is
over and therefore recessions have as little impact on production in the
long.
Fiscal Drag
Fiscal drag is a way for the government to make money through inflation.
How? If your income goes up because of inflation, you end up in higher
income tax brackets even if your real income remains constant –
something often described as “bracket creep”. A similar effect operates
on savings. An increase in the inflation rate reduces what’s left of the
after-tax interest payments.
Foreign Private Debt
Debt
incurred abroad by private individuals is not something an economist
worries about. After all, these funds will surely be invested and will
generate the funds to service the debt. The U.S. housing bubble is of course entirely irrelevant for the argument, since it was caused by faulty regulations.
GDP
per head of the population
A measure to establish the amount of
goods and services available per head of the population. Economists
teach that an increase in the GDP per head improves economic welfare.
Hence if the burden of regulation increases and more regulators are
employed and more people in firms are busy complying with the
regulations, we are better off. When the crime rate increases and we
"consume" more security services and spend less on food and leisure activities, economists report no
change in welfare.
Government Debt
Is
not really debt at all and therefore has not implication on future
generations, at least when financed domestically. After all, future generations
inherit both the debts as well as assets. So let's increase domestic
government debt!
Human Capital Theory
Human capital
theory holds that human capital increases labor productivity and it is
therefore an important ingredient in economic growth and the wealth of
nations. The theory is either a tautology or bunk. It is tautological
when human capital is defined as those characteristics of the work force
that improve labor productivity. It is bunk when human capital is
identified with education. As anyone with some education knows, sometimes it does increase labor productivity and sometimes is does do not, and that frequently education lowers it. Not
surprisingly, the bunk version is especially popular among the
educationalists, including academic economists.
Human Capital
Theory
The human capital theory was formulated by Adam Smith
and has been rediscovered by modern economic theory. After the
rediscovery it got trivialized to the point that any sort of school
attendance makes people more productive, independent of its content or
the environment those attending "school" live and work. Belly dancing
and engineering classes both improve human capital.
Inflation
Introductory textbooks tell you that inflation is costly because it
distorts price signals and leads to an undesirable redistribution from
the private sector to the government. The governments get the income
from the newly printed money – the seigniorage – plus the income from
the fiscal drag. Whereas no one disputes the distributive consequences
of inflation, the interpretation has suddenly changed after the financial
crisis and the ballooning government debts: Leading economists now
declare that plundering private sector income is a good thing
because governments are in danger of going broke and desperately need more
income.
Information
Asymmetry
A seller knows more about a product than the buyer.
Thus when a bank flogs you a share of a firm it knows will go bust, the
deal suffers from information asymmetry. According to the laws of economic theory, if the bank takes
advantage of the information asymmetry and acts in its own best interest, it also acts in the best interest of all of us. Not taking advantage of asymmetric information is
therefore morally irresponsible.
Invisible Hand
According
to modern economics, cheating everybody (some economists call it
behaving opportunistically) fosters the common good.
Liberals
(collectivist liberals)
Liberals of the collectivist kind
(American liberals) blame markets for any social ills they observe. When
the central bank stuffs up the economy by flooding it with cheap money
and a housing bubble results, at fault is the housing market. When the
bubble bursts and the government authorities charged with supervising the
financial system have slept through the bubble, the fault is with the
free financial markets.
Macroeconomic Policy
In a
recession, increase government spending, decrease taxes and cut interest
rates. Cutting edge macroeconomic theory signifally fails to agree on what happens when you do this. Increase government spending and macroeconomic theory predicts that income will increase, decrease or stay the same.
Macroeconomic Theory
A theory how
the main variables in the economy behave - such as income, inflation,
and unemployment - that is immediately disregarded when it is needed, as
in the case of recessions or depressions.
Market Failures
Do not exist. Oligopolies support growth, externalities can be
dealt with by negotiations of market participants and information
failures are uncommon because everybody has perfect information about
everything concerning past, present and future and therefore always
makes decisions in her best interests. This is particularly true of
those who invest in shares.
Markets
According to
economic theory markets are places where everybody cheats everybody
else.
Methodology
Methodology analyzes the principles
and procedures of inquiry in a particular discipline, i.e. its methods.
Since methodology sounds more important than method, most economists,
in line with other social scientists, use the former when they mean the
latter.
Monetarism
Money influences output in the
short run but only prices in the long run. The short run lasts from a
month to infinity. The long run is slightly longer.
Money
Supply
Some economists think that the supply of money is
determined by the central bank (money is exogenous), others believe that
the quantity of money is determined by the money or credit creation
process within the financial system (money is endogenous). Such
inconsistent anslses do not stop economists from freely proffering their
advice on what monetary policy a central bank ought to pursue.
Neoliberals
Liberals of the free market type fight any regulation of
markets tooth and nail. If such unregulated markets fail, they blame it
on the government that has neglected to regulate them properly.
Networking
In practice means establishing yourself as a well-connected crony. Everyone knows
that careers are made through networking. You will hear little about it
from economists. If networks are important, then the allocation mechanism goes out of the window and private economic decisions might turn out to be socially detrimental.
Networking
Not part of the canon
of economics. There is no formal training that tells young economists
that their career is strongly influenced by attaching
themselves to networks that help each other in getting jobs, promotions
and journal publications.
New Classical Macroeconomics
Explains
recessions when all markets remain in equilibrium, but some people have
misestimated inflation rates. Only the Nobel Price Committee ever
seriously believed that major recessions can be caused by
uncertainties over slight variations of the inflation rate.
New
Keynesian Macroeconomics
Labor and product markets are
inefficient and generate unemployment on grounds that are not quite
clear.
Nobel Prizes in Economics
The only Nobel Prize
that is given without the burden of having to produce a significant
original idea that sheds light on economic life.
Oriental
Bazaar
The ideal world of economic theory - prices are fixed by
haggling, information on prices and product quality unavailable and
fraud is ripe.
Performance Incentives
Performance incentives are a central element of an economist's policy
toolkit. These incentives consist exclusively of material
rewards. Even economists grudgingly agree that most people are motivated
not only by monetary gain but also by social norms, such as by doing a
good job or by intrinsic job satisfaction. However, the dismal science fights bitterly against
the well-established insight that monetary rewards often undermine these
other motivators and, as a consequence, additional monetary rewards may
reduce performance.
Performance Incentives
All incentives
in economics are material - which implies that salaries have to be tied
to performance, otherwise economic man starts to shirk. A different part
of economics, that dealing with imperfect information, teaches that
complex tasks cannot be monitored effectively. If it were true that only
performance related pay prevents shirking and performance cannot be
monitored, economists have nothing sensible to say on how to shape work
incentives of complex tasks.
Progress in Economic Theory
Progress
in economics consists in cloaking trivial ideas in mathematics.
Public
Sector Organizations
Public activities are always and
everywhere done ineffectively even if they deliver profitably the same
services at the same cost as firms in the private sector.
Quantitative
Economics
A method that is forced upon unsuspecting students who
initially believe that it leads to deeper insights into social or
economic life. Some of them later realize that they have been
fraudulently deceived, but in the absence of any alternative employment
opportunities they are forced to perpetuate the fraud on the next
generation of students.
Quantity Theory of Money
If
the quantity of money increases significantly, the price level ought to
go up - in the long run. So far no-one has been able to specify what the
long run is.
Rating Agencies
Rating agencies pretend to assess the future creditworthiness of firms
and governments. Barred from knowing the future, they assess current
creditworthiness and utter expensively what everybody gets from news
anyway: They upgrade when news are good and downgrade when news are bad.
Still, there are sufficient fools to be fleeced to make rating a
lucrative business.
Rational
Expectations
People’s expectations are always identical to the
forecast of the model that happens to be constructed. This definitional
twist allows modelers to avoid dealing with expectations altogether –
since everybody is assumed to believe that in the future the world
behaves as in the model. Unsurprisingly, this intellectual obfuscation
was considered worthy of a Nobel price.
Rationality
The
insight that people do not behave rationally cannot be accommodated in
economic models and has therefore, regrettably, to be disregarded.
Real
Business Cycle Macroeconomics
Markets are always in equilibrium
- unemployment is an illusion beheld by simpletons who cannot see that
the unemployed could easily find a job at the going wage rate.
Reality
Economists often talk about reality. It consists of masses of
data-sets that are collected by all sorts of institutions that are then
manipulated statistically. Data not contained in such data sets are not
part of reality.
Rent-seeking
Trying to attract
income beyond what can be had in a well-regulated market is a ubiquitous
phenomenon and of great practical import which disqualifies it from
being taken seriously by economists - perhaps because the profession is
an extreme example of siphoning off rent.
Securitization
Transfer
of debt from one financial institution to another without the knowledge
of the debtor. The term was invented to hide the fact that
securitization increases the risk of default.
Social Science
Social
science is generally not a word mentioned in a society of polite
economists since it involved - at least before it got contaminated with
economics - such wasteful pursuits as acquiring some knowledge of
societies, possibly even a foreign language.
Socialism
Socialists
believe that if government and enterprises are in the hands of the
Socialist Party, the welfare of the members of the Socialist Party will
improve. The theory is one of the best established truths in social
science.
Stakeholder
Any activist group politically
important enough to extort funds from firms for worthy causes, mainly
the cause of increasing the welfare of the leading activists.
Trade
Unions
Trade Unions are an unnecessary encumbrance of the
market economy, since wages are determined by the theory of wage
determination.
Trade Unions
Trade Unions are a
nuisance preventing the efficient allocation of resources. They
interfere in the labor market that would otherwise work perfectly and
allocate resources efficiently according the theory of the labor market.
Trust
Is not a category in economics.
Truth
Truth is
not a category in economics (and in social science generally). Most economists claim
that they formulate hypotheses which they then try to refute. Fiddling with extremely
simplified if not simple-minded hypotheses that are hardly ever conclusively
refuted will never lead to anything approaching “knowledge” of “truth”. No
wonder these categories are not encountered in economic writings.
U.S.
Federal Reserve Bank
The Federal Reserve Bank is a public
institution that buys junk assets in exchange from newly printed money
in order to improve the stability of the US economy and the welfare of
its citizens.
Unemployment
Without government
intervention labor markets always clear. That is trivially true because those
fired either find a job at the same wage rate or a lower wage rate,
including one that is close or equal to zero and some people are reduced
to cleaning shoes or beg. Thus the absence of beggars in the street is a
clear and regrettable sign of government messing up labor markets.
Unproductive
Labor
Economics teaches that there is no such thing as
unproductive labor. Increasing the number of economists will increase
the value of the output generated. All lawyers are
engaged in productive activities. If you increase the complexity of the
law and you need many more lawyers and expert-economists to produce
the same output, economists would cheerfully declare this work of
lawyers and economics to be productive activities. As usual, Adam Smith
beats modern economics; at least he knew that there was something like
unproductive labor.
Virtue
Is not a category in
economics. Since it would be most unlikely that a virtuous economist
would get a job in a university and everybody knows this, the term is an
embarrassment.
Wage Determination
Wages are
determined by the supply and the demand for labor. It is assumed that
there are large numbers of mobile employees and a large number of firms
in each category of work at each and every location. Since economists
habitually confuse models with reality, it follows that in the real
world too wages are negotiated freely by employees with a high degree of
bargaining power because they have a great many alternatives readily available.
For this reason alone, trade unions are entirely superfluous
organizations hampering the free development of individual workers.
Wages
of Management
The theory of wage determination justifies any
wage rate, including those of the top management. Never mind that wage
rates are set by these very managers who sit on each others board of
directors and happily agree to the bonuses of their colleagues that allow
increases of their own salary in the next round.
Welfare
State
Modern Utopia - where everybody has access to education,
health and old age pensions at no cost to themselves.
Welfare
According to welfare economics, welfare increases if we can
consume more material goods or increase our leisure or both - never mind
that job security goes down the gurgler and "job flexibility" destroys
our private and family life.
World Bank
The World
Bank gives large loans to countries of the Third World so that they
might "develop". Since the money is habitually wasted, the resulting
debt has to be regularly forgiven after some seemly interval.
--> Top of Page
[i]
Bergson notes that „by now it seems agreed that the argument on those
questions advanced by Mises ... is without much force”; the alleged
information and monitoring problems “exaggerate the difficulties of the
problems” (Colander, 370 – quotes Abram Bergson. Social Economics. A
Survey of Contemporary Economics, Vol. I, ed. Howard S. Ellis. Homewood,
Ill Richard D. Irwin, 1948, p. 412).
|
|