Austin Social Biz group - Sheet 1
April 11, 2008
Rvw of material from M. Yunus' "Creating a World without Poverty - Social Business and the Future of Capitalism"
http://www.booksite.com/texis/scripts/oop/click_ord/listbooks.html
Quotes for starters:
"The essence of development is changing the quality of life of the
bottom half of the population. And that quality is not to be defined
just by the size of the consumption basket." p. 5
"Poor people are bonsai people." p. 54
Chapter 3:
Who is Muhammad Yunus?
Bengali, born 1940. Fulbright scholarship in 1965 to study in the United States. He obtained his Ph.D. in economics from Vanderbilt University in the United States
Returned
to Bangladesh in 1972. Famine there in 1974 radicalized his perspective
and put him on the path to start Grameen Bank. He and Grameen Bank won
the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Yunus for all you Prof. Y groupies: http://www.muhammadyunus.com/
What is Grameen Micro-Credit?
Financial landscape for very poor in Bangladesh similar to that all over world: loan sharks, financial apartheid.
Very
small loans given mostly to poor women. The women form groups and are
responsible for approving and guaranteeing each other's loans. They
also provide a support group.
Why women?
www.grameen-info.org
P. 58 - The 16 Decisions - extends the change into the social sphere, not just financial. #7 esp. relevant.
Economic Blind Spots: p. 52 - 56. traditional assumptions:
-
collateral necessary for loans
-
only motive of individuals is to maximize profit
-
full employment is the solution to poverty - effects are:
-
feeds large development mentality and projects.
-
only kind of employment that traditional eco theory recognizes- firms, farms,
-
labor as defined by wage level, "robot-like" beings working for a firm undifferentiated, default value is male
-
in
reality, labor in developing world is men, women children. furthermore,
women tend to spend money on their children and household, so Grameen
focused on loans to women.
-
does not recognize household as a production unit.
-
no concept in trad. eco for self-employment, direct sales among individuals. Ironically, this is the primary way poor exist.
-
entrepreneurship is a rare quality.
-
focus on material accumulation and achievement.
"The Logic of Consumption" and "How Much Consumption" - Chapter 10: p. 210 - 213 -
Capitalism emphasises profit maximization. Overemphasis on profit maximization can lead to:
these are very real issues with China and India coming on strong via
the capitalist path which is rapidly approaching a disastrous
intersection with global warming.
spanks the wealthy countries for hogging resources
(who wants to play devils advocate? US is responsible for 19% of world
economy GDP. Only other bigger is EU at a little over 19%. Huge net
importers.)
source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)
may whiteboard bulleted ideas on P. 210 - - traditional philosophy of capitalism,
- basic view of for-profit and non-profit organizational structure.
Chapter 1: A New Kind of Business
Quote: "The presence of our multi-dimensional personalities means that
not every business should be bound to serve the single objective of
profit maximization." p. 19
40% of people receive 94% of worlds income
60% of people recieve 6% of income.
almost one billion people live on less than $1 per day
HALF of the world lives on $2 per day or less. (This happens to be the half where population is growing.)
Why have free markets failed so many people. "Unfettered markets in
their current form are not meant to solve social problemsn and instead
may actually exacerbate poverty, disease, pollution, corruption, crime
and inequality." p. 5
Is Government the Answer?
pros:
cons:
NGOs
pros
cons
Multilateral Institutions: Development elite
pros
cons
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
weak: Do no harm to people or the planet (unless that means sacrificing profit)
strong: Do good for people and the planet (as long as you can do so without sacrificing profit)
reasons why CSR won't save the planet (in other words, capitalism in its current form):
Capitalism is half developed structure:
Chapter 2: Social Business: What it is and What it is Not.
Need
for new type of business that recognizes multidimensional nature of
human beings (and diversity of economic activity says Kala). Not a
replacement for current system, but an enhancement.
Terms: PMBs: profit-maximizing businesses.
Social Businesses is totally dedicated to solving social and
environmental problems. Investors get their investment back but forgo
interest or dividend.
Accepts Investor Investor Business
investor recoups expects must become
funds principal $ return self - sustaining
PMB x x x x
Non-Profit* x (write-off)
Social Biz x x x
*(aka Social Profit, see Biz Week interview with Philip Berber)
Two types of social businesses:
1.
Companies that focus on providing social benefit rather than maximizing
profit for their owners, and are owned by investors seeking social
benefit
The nature of the product or service creates social benefit.
2. PMBs that are owned by poor or disadvantaged.
Goods or services may or may not create direct social benefit.
|