Visitors

Locations of visitors to this page


Recent site activity

Editorials‎ > ‎

The False Dilemma

Apostolic Apologetics: The False Dilemma


Introduction

In recent years, a great deal of effort has been spent trying to convince people with religious beliefs that there is a proverbial wedge between science and religion.
Furthermore, a commonly pushed argument in my time debating and studying is that the religious are impaired scientifically.

This problem has been dubbed by scholars as a "False Dilemma" or "False Dichotomy". The only excuse to support this lie is bluntly put, ignorance of history, or intellectual dishonesty and agenda.Below I have assembled a list of Catholic contributions to the world of Science. Hopefully, to the truth seeking critical thinker, this will shed light on the lie of the False Dilemma. This list is not meant to disrespect the contributions of those from other faiths, or no faith. It is geared towards Catholic contributors simply because that is the theology of this website.
  • There is link to a list of Contributors from Other Faiths towards the end of this page.
  • This list is by no means complete and I will add to it as time allows. These contributors are listed in no particular order.
  • This list proves through empirical evidence, that there is no intellectual advantage to being an Atheist.

Video Primer

Catholic Church: Builder of Western Civilization Episode 3:

I ask that you take 30 minutes to watch this video. In the spirit of science, do not accept any of what is said on faith. Independently verify what this man is saying. This video is a must watch for anyone interested in the relationship between the Church and Science, and the Galileo affair for that matter.

Catholic Church: Builder of Western Civilization



Some Background Information

In 313 the Edict of Milan ended Christian persecution in the Roman Empire. Although this is not the start of Christianity it may well be the start of Christians recorded achievements in many pursuits, including science.

The Edict of Nantes (1598) was an important event in allowing religious toleration among Christians. Hence this increased the ability of different kind of Christians to work in science among other things.


Catholic Contributors to Science


Thomas David Jones
Roman Catholic Layman
Astronaut
Pilot
Scientist
Doctorate in planetary sciences
Flew on four space shuttle missions to Earth orbit.
Led three spacewalks to install the centerpiece of the International Space Station.
Piloted B-52D strategic bombers
Studied asteroids for NASA
Engineered intelligence-gathering systems for the CIA

NASA Distinguished Service Medal (Info)
Four NASA Space Flight Medals (Info)
The NASA Exceptional Service award (Info)
The NASA Outstanding Leadership Medal (Info)
Phi Beta Kappa Honor (Info)
Air Force Commendation Medal (Info)
Honorary doctorate by Kings College, Wilkes-Barre, PA, in 2007.


Thomas David Jones (born January 22, 1955) is a United States astronaut. He was selected to the astronaut corps in 1990 and completed four space shuttle flights before retiring in 2001. He flew on STS-59 and STS-68 in 1994, STS-80 in 1996 and STS-98 in 2001. His total mission time was 53 days 48 minutes.
Click here to read more on his Wikipedia page.
For his official website, click here.


Eugene Cernan
Roman Catholic Layman
NASA astronaut
Electrical Engineer
Aeronautical Engineer
Last man on the Moon (as of 2009)


Eugene Andrew Cernan (born March 14, 1934) is a retired United States Navy officer and a former NASA astronaut of Czechoslovakian ancestry. He has been into space three times: as co-pilot of Gemini 9A in June 1966; as lunar module pilot of Apollo 10 in May 1969; and as commander of Apollo 17 in December 1972. In that final lunar landing mission, Cernan became "the last man on the moon" since he was the last to re-enter the Apollo Lunar Module during its third and final extra-vehicular activity (EVA). He was also a backup crew member for the Gemini 12, Apollo 7 and Apollo 14 missions. Click here to read his Wikipedia page.

Micheal Collins
Roman Catholic Layman
NASA Astronaut

Test Pilot
One of only 24 people to have flown to the Moon.
United States Air Force


Major General Michael Collins (born October 31, 1930 in Rome, Italy) is a former American astronaut and test pilot. Selected as part of the third group of fourteen astronauts in 1963, he flew in space twice. His first spaceflight was Gemini 10, when he and command pilot John W. Young performed two rendezvous with different spacecraft and Collins undertook two EVAs. His second spaceflight was Apollo 11 where he served as the command module pilot. While he orbited the Moon, Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin performed the first manned landing on the lunar surface. He is one of only 24 people to have flown to the Moon. Click here to read his entry on Wikipedia.


Georges Lemaître

Came up with "The Big Bang".
Catholic Priest and Monsignor.

Monsignor Georges Henri Joseph Édouard Lemaître (July 17, 1894 – June 20, 1966) was a Belgian Roman Catholic priest, honorary prelate, professor of physics and astronomer at the Catholic University of Leuven. He sometimes used the title Abbé or Monsigneur.

Lemaître proposed what became known as the Big Bang theory of the origin of the Universe, which he called his 'hypothesis of the primeval atom'. This man's accomplishments go beyond that however, as Lemaître's 1927 paper derived what became known as
Hubble's Law. You can read more information about Monsignor Georges Henri Joseph Édouard Lemaître by clicking here.

Kenneth R. Miller
Roman Catholic Layman
Molecular Biologist
Cell Biology
Biochemist
Evolutionary Biologist
Science Advocate
Author

A biology professor at Brown University who wrote Finding Darwin's God ISBN 0-06-093049-7. Testified in the Dover trials against Micheal Behe's team. Strong advocate for science in the classroom. Debater and speaker. Click here for his Wikipedia Page. Additionally, here is his official website.

Dr. Joseph Murray
Roman Catholic Layman
American surgeon
Performed first successful human kidney transplant
Performed the world's first successful allograft.
Nobel Laureate in Medicine and Physiology 1990


Joseph E. Murray (born 1 April 1919), American surgeon, performed the first successful human kidney transplant from an adult to his identical twin. Click here to visit the Wikipedia article about him.

Klaus von Klitzing
Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Laureate in Physics (1985)
For his discovery of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect
Named to Pontifical Academy of Sciences By Pope Benedict XVI (October 2007)
Professor of physics at the Max Planck Institute for Solid State Research in Stuttgart, Germany
German physicist

Klaus von Klitzing, born June 28, 1943 in Schroda (Środa Wielkopolska ) is a German physicist. For his discovery of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect he was awarded the 1985 Nobel Prize in Physics. In 2007 he was named to the Vatican's Science Academy, the Pontifical Academy of Sciences. Read more about him on his Wikipedia page.

Augustin Louis Cauchy
Roman Catholic Layman
Mathematician

Member of the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul.
Defender of the Jesuits
Tried to convert other mathematicians to Catholicism


Augustin Louis Cauchy (21 August 1789 – 23 May 1857; was a French mathematician. He started the project of formulating and proving the theorems of infinitesimal calculus in a rigorous manner and was thus an early pioneer of analysis. He also gave several important theorems in complex analysis and initiated the study of permutation groups. A profound mathematician, through his perspicuous and rigorous methods Cauchy exercised a great influence over his contemporaries and successors. His writings cover the entire range of mathematics and mathematical physics. Click here to read more.

Gregor Mendel


Father of Genetics
Augustinian Catholic Priest


Gregor Johann Mendel (July 20, 1822 – January 6, 1884) was a German speaking Austrian Augustinian priest and scientist, and is often called the father of genetics for his study of the inheritance of certain traits in pea plants. Mendel showed that the inheritance of these traits follows particular laws, which were later named after him. The significance of Mendel's work was not recognized until the turn of the 20th century. Its rediscovery prompted the foundation of the discipline of genetics. Click here to read more.

Francesco Faà di Bruno
Roman Catholic Saint (Beatified 1988)
Roman Catholic Deacon ordained on 18 December 1856.
Roman Catholic Priest ordained on 4 January 1857.
Mathematician
Writer


Francesco Faà di Bruno (29 March 1825–27 March 1888) was an Italian mathematician and priest, born at Alessandria. He was of noble birth, and held, at one time, the rank of captain-of-staff in the Sardinian Army. Coming to Paris, he resigned his commission, studied under Augustin Cauchy, and Urbain Le Verrier, who shared in the discovery of the planet Neptune, and he became intimate with Abbé Moigno and Charles Hermite. On his return to Turin, he was ordained, but the remainder of his life was spent as Professor of Mathematics at the University. In recognition of his achievements as a mathematician, the degree of Doctor of Science was conferred on him by the Universities of Paris and Turin. Click here to read the full article.

Julian Tenison Woods
Roman Catholic Priest
Co-founder of the Sisters of St Joseph of the Sacred Heart
Awarded the Clarke Medal for distinguished contribution to Natural Science


Julian Edmund Tenison Woods (15 November 1832 – 7 October 1889) was an English Roman Catholic priest and geologist, active in Australia. Click here for more information.

Louis Pasteur
Roman Catholic Layman
One of the three Founders of Microbiology.
Founder Immunology

Invented First vaccination for Rabies.
Inventor of Pasteurization (hence the it's name).
Pioneer in the field Chemistry. Made several discoveries in this field.


Louis Pasteur (December 27, 1822 – September 28, 1895) was a French chemist and microbiologist best known for his remarkable breakthroughs in the causes and prevention of disease. His experiments supported the germ theory of disease, also reducing mortality from puerperal fever (childbed), and he created the first vaccine for rabies. He was best known to the general public for inventing a method to stop milk and wine from causing sickness - this process came to be called Pasteurization. He is regarded as one of the three main founders of microbiology, together with Ferdinand Cohn and Robert Koch. Pasteur also made many discoveries in the field of chemistry, most notably the molecular basis for the asymmetry of certain crystals.[1] He is buried beneath the Institut Pasteur, a rare honor in France, where being buried in a cemetery is mandatory save for the fewer than 300 "Great Men" who are entombed in the Panthéon. Click here to read more.
St. George Jackson Mivart
Roman Catholic Layman
English Biologist

Fellow of the Zoological Society of London

St. George Jackson Mivart PhD MD FRS (November 30, 1827 – April 1, 1900) was an English biologist. He is famous for starting as an ardent believer in natural selection who later became one of its fiercest critics. Trying to reconcile Darwin's theory of evolution with the beliefs of the Catholic Church, he ended up being condemned by both parties. Click here for his Wikipedia page.

Armand David
Roman Catholic Priest
Zoologist
Botanist
Found in China all together 200 species of wild animals, of which 63 were hitherto unknown to zoologists.
Found 807 species of birds, 65 of which had not been described before.


Father Armand David (27 September 1826 near Bayonne –10 November 1900 in Paris) was a Lazarist missionary Catholic priest as well as a zoologist and a botanist. Click here to read more.

Stanley L. Jaki, OSB
Roman Catholic Benedictine priest.
Professor of Physics
Leading thinker in the philosophy of science, theology and where they meet.
Awarded the Templeton Prize (1987)


Benedictine priest and Distinguished Professor of Physics at Seton Hall University, New Jersey, who won a Templeton Prize and advocates the idea modern science could only have arisen in a Christian society. Click here to read more.

Alexander Fleming
Roman Catholic Layman
Discovered Penicillin (Nobel Prize for this)
Bacteriologist
Discovered the enzyme lysozyme.


Sir Alexander Fleming (6 August 1881 – 11 March 1955) was a Scottish biologist and pharmacologist. Fleming published many articles on bacteriology, immunology and chemotherapy. His best-known achievements are the discovery of the enzyme lysozyme in 1923 and the antibiotic substance penicillin from the fungus Penicillium notatum in 1928, for which he shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1945 with Howard Walter Florey and Ernst Boris Chain. Click here to read more.

Carlos Chagas Filho

Roman Catholic Layman
Neuroscientist
Physician
Biologist
Headed the Pontifical Academy of Sciences for 16 years.
Studied the Shroud of Turin


A neuroscientist from Rio de Janeiro who headed the Pontifical Academy of Sciences for 16 years. He studied the Shroud of Turin and his "the Origin of the Universe", "the Origin of Life", and "the Origin of Man" involved an understanding between Catholicism and Science. Click here to read more.


René Descartes
Roman Catholic Layman
Founder of Analytical Geometry
Father of Modern Philosophy (The Science of Thought).
Mathematician
Scientist
Thought to have proved the existence of God with near certainty.

Prolific Writer
Influenced by St. Augustine
Influenced by St. Thomas Aquinas.
Influenced Spinoza.
Influenced Pascal.

René Descartes, (31 March 1596 – 11 February 1650), also known as Renatus Cartesius (latinized form), was a French philosopher, mathematician, scientist, and writer who spent most of his adult life in the Dutch Republic. He has been dubbed the "Father of Modern Philosophy," and much of subsequent Western philosophy is a response to his writings, which continue to be studied closely to this day. In particular, his Meditations on First Philosophy continues to be a standard text at most university philosophy departments. Descartes' influence in mathematics is also apparent, the Cartesian coordinate system allowing geometric shapes to be expressed in algebraic equations being named for him. He is accreditied as the father of analytical geometry. Descartes was also one of the key figures in the Scientific Revolution.

While there may indeed be considerable debate about Descartes' religious beliefs, this appears to be nothing more than later attempts to divorce him from his stated views.
Read more about Descartes here.

Nicolaus Copernicus

Roman Catholic Cleric
Founder of Heliocentric Cosmology

Mathematician
Astronomer
Physician
Classical Scholar
Translator
Artist
Jurist
Governor
Military leader
Diplomat
Economist
Among the great polymaths of the Renaissance.



Nicolaus Copernicus (February 19, 1473 – May 24, 1543) was the first astronomer to formulate a scientifically-based heliocentric cosmology that displaced the Earth from the center of the universe. His epochal book, De revolutionibus orbium coelestium (On the Revolutions of the Celestial Spheres), is often regarded as the starting point of modern astronomy and the defining epiphany that began the Scientific Revolution. Read more here.

Galileo Galilei
Devout Roman Catholic Layman.
Founder of Experimental Physics

Physician
Physicist
Mathematician
Astronomer
Philosopher
Played a major role in the Scientific Revolution.
Improved the telescope.
Made astronomical observations.
Supported Copernicanism


Galileo Galilei (15 February 1564 – 8 January 1642) was a Tuscan physicist, mathematician, astronomer, and philosopher who played a major role in the Scientific Revolution. His achievements include improvements to the telescope and consequent astronomical observations, and support for Copernicanism. Galileo has been called the "father of modern observational astronomy", the "father of modern physics", the "father of science", and "the Father of Modern Science." The motion of uniformly accelerated objects, taught in nearly all high school and introductory college physics courses, was studied by Galileo as the subject of kinematics. His contributions to observational astronomy include the telescopic confirmation of the phases of Venus, the discovery of the four largest satellites of Jupiter, named the Galilean moons in his honour, and the observation and analysis of sunspots. Galileo also worked in applied science and technology, improving compass design. Click here to read more.

Charles P. Poole, Jr.

Roman Catholic Deacon
Physics
Astronomy
Magnetic Resonance
Solid State Physics
Superconductivity
Applications of Clifford Algebras.


On his official website, his research interested are described as:
Microwave absorption in high temperature superconductors is being studied to obtain information on the pinning centers. Understanding the pinning problem is necessary for the development of superconductors with large current carrying capability. Magnetic field cycling and sample orientation studies clarify how quantized magnetic flux localized in vortices moves into and out of the sample. Time dependent studies provide insights into the dynamics of the vortex motion within the material as well as the entry and exit of vortices at the surface. Interactions between vortices are being investigated by computer simulation techniques. Click here for his official website.

Erwin Schrödinger
Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Laureate in Physics

Crater on Moon Named for Him
Worked in Colorimetry

Erwin Rudolf Josef Alexander Schrödinger (12 August 1887 – 4 January 1961) was an Austrian theoretical physicist who achieved fame for his contributions to quantum mechanics, especially the Schrödinger equation, for which he received the Nobel Prize in 1933. In 1935, after extensive correspondence with personal friend Albert Einstein, he proposed the Schrödinger's cat thought experiment. Click here for his Wikipedia page.

Alexis Carrel
Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Prize Laureate in Physiology or Medicine 1912

Alexis Carrel (June 28, 1873 - November 5, 1944) was a French surgeon, biologist and eugenicist, who was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1912. Click here to read more about him.

John Carew Eccles

Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Prize Loreate in Physiology or Medicine (1963)


Sir John Carew Eccles, AC FRS FRACP FRSNZ FAAS (27 January 1903 – 2 May 1997) was an Australian neurophysiologist who won the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on the synapse. He shared the prize together with Andrew Fielding Huxley and Alan Lloyd Hodgkin. Click here for his Wikipedia page which has more information.

Michał Kazimierz Heller

Roman Catholic Priest ordained 1959.
Friend of Pope John Paul II

Professor of philosophy
Member of the Vatican Observatory staff.
Founding member of the International Society for Science and Religion.
Mathematical physicist
Lecturer in the philosophy of science and logic
Winner of the Templeton Prize


He is a Catholic priest, a member of the Pontifical Academy of Theology, a founding member of the International Society for Science and Religion.' He also is a mathematical physicist who has written articles on relativistic physics and Noncommutative geometry. His cross-disciplinary book Creative Tension: Essays on Science and Religion came out in 2003. For this work he won a Templeton Prize. He teaches at Kraków, hence the picture of a Basilica from the city. Click here for more about him on Wikipedia.

See Also: Professor wins prize for maths link to God
See Also: Million-Dollar Prize Given to Cosmologist Priest (New York Times)

E. T. Whittaker

Roman Catholic Layman
Mathematician

Awarded Copley Medal
Member of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences
Author: Space and Spirit.
Author:Theories of the Universe and the Arguments for the Existence of God.


Edmund Taylor Whittaker (24 October 1873 - 24 March 1956) was a mathematician who contributed widely to applied mathematics, mathematical physics and the theory of special functions. He had a particular interest in numerical analysis, but also worked on celestial mechanics and the history of physics. Near the end of his career he received the Copley Medal, the most prestigious honorary award in British science. Click here to read more.

Pierre Duhem
Catholic Layman
Physicist
Mathematician
Philosopher of Science
Wrote histories advocating that the Roman Catholic Church helped advance science.


Pierre Maurice Marie Duhem (10 June 1861 – 14 September 1916) was a French physicist, mathematician and philosopher of science, best known for his writings on the indeterminacy of experimental criteria and on scientific development in the Middle Ages. Duhem also made major contributions to the science of his day, particularly in the fields of hydrodynamics, elasticity, and thermodynamics. Click here to read more about Pierre Duhem.

Leonardo da Vinci
Roman Catholic Layman
Polymath
Scientist
Mathematician
Engineer
Inventor
Anatomist
Painter
Sculptor
Architect
Botanist
Musician
Writer


Leonardo di ser Piero da Vinci (it-Leonardo di ser Piero da Vinci.ogg pronunciation (help·info), April 15, 1452 – May 2, 1519) was an Italian polymath, being a scientist, mathematician, engineer, inventor, anatomist, painter, sculptor, architect, botanist, musician and writer. Leonardo has often been described as the archetype of the renaissance man, a man whose unquenchable curiosity was equaled only by his powers of invention.[1] He is widely considered to be one of the greatest painters of all time and perhaps the most diversely talented person ever to have lived. Helen Gardner says "The scope and depth of his interests were without precedent. His mind and personality seem to us superhuman, the man himself mysterious and remote". Click here to read more on Wikipedia.



Jesuit Scientists


The Society of Jesus (Latin: Societas Iesu, S.J. and S.I. or SJ, SI) is a Roman Catholic religious order of clerks regular whose members are called Jesuits, Soldiers of Christ, and Foot soldiers of the Pope, because the founder, Saint Ignatius of Loyola, was a knight before becoming a priest.

Literary Contributions

J. R. R. Tolkien

Catholic Layman
Friend of C.S. Lewis often credited for Lewis' conversion to Christianity from Atheism. (Christian Writer famous for "Mere Christianity" and "The Lion The With and The Wardrobe")


John Ronald Reuel Tolkien, CBE (3 January 1892 – 2 September 1973) was an English writer, poet, philologist, and university professor, best known as the author of the classic high fantasy works The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. Click here to read more about him.

T.S. Eliot
Anglo-Catholic Layman.
Nobel Laureate in Literature 1948


Thomas Stearns Eliot, OM (26 September 1888 – 4 January 1965), was a poet, dramatist, and literary critic. He received the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1948. Among his most famous writings are the poems The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, The Waste Land, The Hollow Men, Ash Wednesday and Four Quartets; the plays Murder in the Cathedral and The Cocktail Party; and the essay "Tradition and the Individual Talent". Click here for his Wikipedia page.

François Mauriac

Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Prize Laureate in Literature (1952)


François Mauriac (11 October 1885 — 1 September 1970) was a French author; member of the Académie française (1933); laureate of the Nobel Prize in Literature (1952). He was awarded the Grand Cross of the Légion d'honneur (1958). He is acknowledged to be one of the greatest Roman Catholic writers of the 20th century. Click here for his Wikipedia page.

Sigrid Undset
Roman Catholic Layperson.
Lay Dominican (Third Order of Saint Dominic)
Nobel Prize Laureate in Literature (1928)


Sigrid Undset (20 May 1882–10 June 1949) was a Norwegian novelist who was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1928.
Undset was born in Kalundborg, Denmark, but her family moved to Norway when she was two years old. In 1924, she converted to Catholicism and became a lay Dominican. She fled Norway for the United States in 1940 because of her opposition to Nazi Germany and the German occupation, but returned after World War II ended in 1945. Click here to read more.

Contributors to Peace

Kim Dae-Jung
Roman Catholic Layman
15th President of South Korea
Nobel Peace Prize Laureate (2000)

Called the "Nelson Mandela of Asia"
Only South Korean Nobel Prize Laureate

Kim Dae-jung (Born December 3, 1925, is a former South Korean president and the 2000 Nobel Peace Prize recipient. He is the first and only Nobel laureate from Korea.[1] A Roman Catholic since 1957, he has been called the "Nelson Mandela of Asia"[2] for his long-standing opposition to authoritarian rule. Kim Dae-jung was the President (succeeding Kim Young-sam) from 1998 to 2003. Click here for his Wikipedia page.

Adolfo Pérez Esquivel
Roman Catholic Layman
Nobel Peace Prize Laureate


Adolfo Pérez Esquivel (born November 26, 1931 in Buenos Aires, Argentina) was the recipient of the 1980 Nobel Peace Prize. He is noted for leading protests against the Free Trade Area of the Americas and for alleging that the Argentine police are forming children into paramilitary squads, an operation he compares to the creation of Nazi Germany. Click here for his Wikipedia article.


Mother Teresa
President Ronald Reagan presents Mother Teresa with the Presidential Medal of Freedom at a White House ceremony, 1985

Mother Teresa, one of the more renowned figures on this page, is someone of whom much can be said, as far as her accomplishments, care and love for the people she encountered during her time on Earth. She received not only the Presidential Medal of freedom, but is a Nobel Peace Prize Laureate, as well as the recipient of several other awards and recognitions.


Click here for her Wikipedia entry.

Pope John Paul II The Great
President Bush presents the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Pope John Paul II during a visit to the Vatican, June 2004.

He has been credited with the downfall of the Soviet Union [2][4][5][6][7][3][102]. He was a champion of freedom, and of Peace. John Paul II The Great, so called because of his case of beatification being opened, was almost Martyred three times, the latest attempt, funded by Al Qaeda, was thwarted when a chemical fire alerted authorities to the activites of the would be murderers.

Click here to read his Wikipedia Article.


Other Christian Thinkers

Wikipedia currently has a list of Christian thinkers in Science. This list is extensive and includes almost everyone on my list here (save the Jesuits) and includes non Catholics.

View the List of Christian Thinkers in Science Wikipedia page by clicking here.