You said to be honest so i will be, just a warning :)

Layout

I overall like your layout and i think its pretty nice. But i kinda dont like the backgrounds because its like swirls or target signs and kind of looks a big unprofessional and kind of...kidish. But overall i can tell you tried with it and I like the brushes used.

Organization/other

I think your sites pretty organized. But u think each of your reveiws should have there own page instead of crammed on one page. I think for your disclaimer you should add more to it, there is only one sentance or just delete it all together and make a page for it under your "site" section.

Content

I like that you have myspace comment signs those are a big hit on lots of sites. Although for some section on your content you have a little things and for others you have alot. I suggest you add more to each section once Adding enough to each section add more links oof different content. Some of the  pictures used in the Msn icons i dont really like, i think you should add more effects to them, and its helpful to visitors if you can code the icons. But i like most of things under content so good job keep it up.

Overall 3/5 stars

I feel like your site is new, it still has alot that needs to be added but i like it overall. I feel like you are really tring on your site. The reason for that is because you have a to-do list and your appliing for reveiws that will make your site better. Good job.